1134 county road 2 monaghan

This beautiful 1883 church in Ontario costs the same as an average Toronto condo

A church for sale in Ontario comes with a long history but has been beautifully converted into a rural home.

The four-bedroom home at 1134 County Road 2 in Monaghan, near Peterborough, is listed for sale for $689,900, almost exactly the same price as the average condo in Toronto.

1134 county road 2 monaghan

The converted church comes with its original stained glass windows.

In Toronto, large churches have been converted into lofts, and in Ontario, country churches occasionally come up for sale.

They're usually a lot more expensive than this.

1134 county road 2 monaghan

The living room is open concept but there is a small office space with doors.

This home, not far from church recently for sale in Port Hope, used to be Bensfort Church, a Methodist (and later United) church, completed in 1883.

1134 county road 2 monaghan

There is a wood-burning fireplace on the main floor.

It was converted into a home a century after it was built and has nearly 3,000 square feet of open concept living space.

1134 county road 2 monaghan

The kitchen is spacious with hardwood floors.

The main level has a large kitchen, with a breakfast bar made from reclaimed glazed barn board.

1134 county road 2 monaghan

The kitchen has a breakfast bar that looks over a large part of the house.

The living room boasts 25-foot ceilings with exposed beams, restored original pine floors and the original stained glass windows.

1134 county road 2 monaghan

Each of the loft bedrooms has skylights.

The converted loft has three bedrooms, including a primary bedroom with built-in shelving at one end and an amazing arch over the likeliest place for a bed.

1134 county road 2 monaghan

The primary bedroom has a large storage cabinet.

The loft bathroom has a pebble-floored glass-walled shower.

1134 county road 2 monaghan

The upstairs bathroom has a shower with a pebble floor but no bathtub.

Opposite the primary bedroom is a large open area with lake views and a Juliette balcony.

1134 county road 2 monaghan

The loft has an open area that could be used as a yoga space or reading nook.

The one-bedroom basement is partially finished and has a separate entrance and a roughed-in bathroom.

1134 county road 2 monaghan

The basement has one bedroom and a separate entrance.

There is a barn on the property for wood storage as well.

1134 county road 2 monaghan

The barn on the property could be used to store firewood.

The home is rural, about a 20-minute drive to Peterborough and an hour and a half to Toronto. But it is quite near Rolling Grape Vineyard and Rice Lake, known for boating and fishing.

1134 county road 2 monaghan

The front of the church has been opened up with picture windows.

If you are ready to make the move out of Toronto, this place would make a unique choice.

Photos by

Doug Logan

Latest Videos

Latest Videos

Join the conversation Load comments

Latest in Real Estate

You can buy this $17 million Toronto home interest free

Homes in this Ontario city cost half the Toronto average but barely anyone is buying them

This tiny two-bedroom house is on sale for the first time in 30 years

Here's how you should vet your future landlord in Toronto

Here is the part of the GTA where you will find the best value for homes in 2024

Here's how much home prices have changed compared to rental prices in Toronto

This completely renovated Toronto home is surprisingly under $1 million

Frank Lloyd Wright-inspired Toronto home on sale for $5 million