pizzeria badiali

This is how long Toronto residents are willing to wait in line for the city's best pizza

Toronto's best pizzeria officially opened its highly requested second location earlier this month, and if its opening day was any indication, the lines that made it famous on Dovercourt have followed it straight to the Annex.

After years of rumours, Pizzeria Badiali confirmed that it would be opening its long-awaited sister location on Markham Street on Monday, May 11.

The original shop, located at 181 Dovercourt Rd., has steadily built a reputation that needs no introduction, thanks to its steady stream of customers and lines that regularly stretch down the block even during off-peak hours and weekdays.

On opening day at the new Markham Street location, we asked customers just how long they've previously waited for a Badiali slice.

Most Toronto residents said they've waited anywhere from 30 minutes to a mind-boggling two hours, depending on the day and the lineup, while others admitted that they were prepared to stand in line "as long as it takes" for a slice.

Despite the buzz, the wait on opening day itself was relatively tame, taking about 20 minutes around lunchtime, although true Badiali fans will know that's unlikely to last once word fully spreads.

"We are excited to join the Annex neighbourhood, and even more excited about reopening this historic building for people to come have great pizza and hang out with their friends and family," said chef and co-owner Ryan Baddeley, ahead of the opening.

The new location is also bigger than Badiali's flagship Dovercourt shop at 1,400 square feet, with indoor seating available for 30 hungry customers.

The menu at its sister location also remains true to what made the pizzeria a cult favourite, with the same lineup of pizzas, salads, and dips, plus a thin-crust "Granny style" pizza exclusive to the Markham Street shop.

Pizzeria Badiali Annex is located at 581 Markham St.

Lead photo by

Fareen Karim


Latest Videos



Latest Videos


Latest in Eat & Drink

I tried all the weird and wacky foods at the 2026 CNE so you don't have to

A huge public pizza party is happening at a Toronto park this weekend

New BBQ business at a Toronto brewery is taking the city by storm

Viral Ontario fried chicken chain opening first downtown Toronto location this month

YouTube star Mark Wiens just visited Toronto and here's every restaurant he reviewed

5 new patios in Toronto you need to check out before the summer ends

6 slightly unhinged Canada fast food hacks to max out your meal

People in Toronto love this new sandwich shop that's already expanding through Ontario