pape avenue toronto home

Man in Toronto laments childhood home demolished and replaced with modern box

Revisiting a childhood home can bring back a flood of happy memories, but not so much when that home is replaced.

Joe Brancati, who grew up in Toronto in the 1950s but now lives in Whitby, decided to look up his old home out of curiosity. He heard homes in the neighbourhood were expensive these days.

"I heard they were selling for mega-bucks," he told blogTO.

The home was on Pape Avenue in Leslieville, south of Dundas Street.

"It wasn't Leslieville when I lived there, it was just the east end," said Brancati.

pape avenue home toronto

This is what Joe Brancati's home on Pape used to look like. Photo via Joe Brancati 

But in an online search, he found his home had been replaced.

"I was really surprised that they had not just renovated it but removed it," he said. "I was taken aback for sure. It's gone, that's it."

In fact, the home was purchased in 2014 for $821,230, according to Zoocasa. It was torn down, and the new home sold for $1.9 million in 2018.

Brancati wasn't too thrilled with the new modern design.

"I think it is pretty bland looking — no character whatsoever," he said.

However, he admitted that the interior looks "fantastic."pape avenue home toronto

This is what the new home looks like. Photo via Google Maps

From 1954 to 1959 Brancati has good memories living in the Pape home: "It was a different time for sure," he said.

There was a police station down the street and he said "most of the police were on horseback."

The beach wasn't far away, and he recalls stopping at a dump on the way to go swimming.

"We would go in there [the dump], grab big pieces of wood and go out onto the lake," he said. He and his friends would use the wood to float on in the water.

The old home had three different units, which were rented out. His family lived on the main floor and two other families lived on the other floors. There wasn’t a lot of space for each family.

"It's not like today where everybody needs an ensuite — we had one bathroom for the whole place (all three families)."

Brancati posted a photo of his home and the new build in the Friends Who Like Vintage Toronto Facebook group lamenting the loss of his childhood home. He got dozens of responses from people with similar stories.

Some people didn't like new renovations to their old homes.

"They took away all the charm and every perennial and tree we had spent years establishing," one person wrote.

Most didn't like the modern look of the home on Pape.

"I hate these box houses. Ruining the character of the old neighbourhoods," wrote one person.

Still, a few liked the design.

"I like the new look," another person wrote.

Whatever your tastes, the Toronto real estate market shows no signs of slowing down and finding any type of home will be a challenge.

Lead photo by

via Friends Who Like Vintage Toronto

Join the conversation Load comments

Latest in Real Estate

Toronto rent prices now rising in most neighbourhoods but there are some exceptions

The average house in Toronto is going to cost $275K more in two years

This big lake house two hours north of Toronto is selling for less than $500K

This $8.9 million Toronto condo comes with views of the CN Tower and an infinity pool

Brad Lamb wants to replace Toronto's famous auto repair shop with a flatiron building

Historic Toronto hotel is at risk of being demolished

This $4.4 million mansion near Toronto comes with 180 feet of private lake access

This laneway house in Toronto is a literal work of art and is renting for $5,500