tesla ontario lawsuit

Tesla just won its lawsuit against the Ontario government

An Ontario Superior Court judge has ruled that Tesla Motors was treated unfairly and unlawfully by Doug Ford's PC government when the province abruptly cancelled its electric vehicle rebate program last month in favour of lowering gas prices by 10 cents.

This means that the PCs can no longer move forward with their plan to immediately block Tesla buyers — and only Tesla buyers — from receiving Electric and Hydrogen Vehicle Incentive Program (EHVIP) rebates.

Like any other type of electric car sold in the province, a Tesla delivered and registered by September 10 will still be eligible for rebates of up to $14,000.

Yesterday's court ruling also stipulated that Ontario must now pay $125,000 to cover Telsa's legal costs. How's that for fiscal responsibility, folks?

The decision comes less than two weeks after Tesla Motors Canada ULC filed a lawsuit against the provincial government, asking court to throw out what it called an "arbitrary and entirely unreasonable" transition plan.

Tesla Canada argued at the time that its business and its customers had suffered "substantial harm" following the cancellation of Ontario's EHVIP rebates.

Ontario Superior Court Justice Frederick L Myers agreed.

"If the government wants to transition out of the electric car subsidy program, [Transportation Minister John Yakabuski] must exercise his operational discretion in a lawful manner," wrote Myers in what Robert Benzie called a "scathing" 17-page ruling.

"He has yet to do so," continued the ruling. "I therefore quash and set aside the Minister’s unlawful exercises of discretion to implement the transition program announced July 11."

Lead photo by

Tesla Motors Canada


Join the conversation Load comments

Latest in City

There are now flags for pedestrians to hold at dangerous Toronto crosswalks

New study finds Uber and Lyft causing major increase in Toronto traffic

Popular downtown Toronto bike lane is about to be extended

This summer in Toronto won't be nearly as hot as last year

It's going to feel like 34 C in Toronto this week

Toronto might get a new cross-lake ferry to Niagara

Student gets $1,444 bill for chalking outside Queen's Park at Toronto protest

The Toronto Islands might get a new beach