pizza scarborough

The Best Pizza in Scarborough

The best pizza in Scarborough is saucy and savoury, gooey and rich, whether it's served as an epic slice or a loaded whole pie. A satisfying snack or crowd-pleasing meal, it's a dish that's spectacular when done just right.

Here is the best pizza in Scarborough.


Mark's Pizzas
1

Mark's Pizzas

Old Kingston Road is home to this simple spot, where Roman slices tease from the counter and the team is primed to whip up any whole pie you want. Tired of the same old? Go for the roasted corn with tomatoes, creamy mozz and lemon basil olive oil.

Lamanna's Bakery
2

Lamanna's Bakery

Skip the ridiculously portioned slices and go for the regular pies and slices at this Italian bakery on Kingston Road. Each pizza is a gooey good combo of tasty ingredients, whether you opt for the Americano or the Quattro Formaggio.


Pizza On Fire
3

Pizza On Fire

At this family-owned spot on Ellesmere Road, hefty pies are served hot and fresh, in minutes. The menu includes all the familiar faves, with smoked salmon, tandoori chicken and Philly steak spicing up a selection of gourmet pies.

Pizza Fiamma
4

Pizza Fiamma

Butter Chicken and Shahi Paneer pizzas eclipse more pedestrian offerings at this Indian fusion chain, with a location in Scarborough. Pop in for a slice or, better yet, shuttle a party tray back home and devour it among friends.


Fratelli's
5

Fratelli's

At this cozy restaurant on Old Kingston Road, the wine flows, the service is warm and the pizzas bronze and bubble in a wood-fired oven that lends the entire space an inviting glow. Choose a spicy Diavola, bacon-studded Fratelli or create your own gourmet combo from the wealth of available ingredients.


Calabria Bakery
6

Calabria Bakery

Stop in at this bakery's Scarborough location for made-to-order pizzas cooked in a wood-fired oven. From a team that specializes in bread, every slice is tender and crisp, scented by yeast and smoke, whether you order the veggie-forward Ortolana or a meaty Calabria pie.

Big Brothers Gourmet Pizza
7

Big Brothers Gourmet Pizza

From deep dish and vegan pies to options loaded with gourmet toppings, the menu at this take-out spot covers a wide swathe of pizza cravings. Read through the lengthy list — which jumps from a burger pizza to a plant-based Yukon gold — or play it safe with a classic.


Mamajoun
8

Mamajoun

Traditional Armenian pizzas and flatbreads attract diners to this bright spot on Ellesmere Road. Light and thin, made fresh, hand-made pies range from the Caesar and Greek to the soujouk-laden Armenian.

Mario's Pizza Kitchen
9

Mario's Pizza Kitchen

A passion for fresh — not frozen — food inspires a wealth of saucy, gooey dishes at this restaurant on Pitfield Road. Stone-oven pizzas take centre stage on the substantial menu, with Chicken Carbonara, Inferno and Butter Chicken jumping out from a tempting list of options.

Lead photo by

Fareen Karim at Mark's Pizza. Additional photos of Calabria Bakery by @jeffkcw


Latest Videos



Latest Videos


Join the conversation Load comments

The Best Pizza in Scarborough

Leaflet | © Mapbox © OpenStreetMap Improve this map

Latest in Best of Toronto

The Best Splurge Sushi in Toronto

The Best Kitchen Supply Stores in Toronto

The Best Challah in Toronto

The Best Late Night Burgers in Toronto

The Best Falafel in Toronto

The Best Shawarma in Toronto

The Best Vegan and Plant-Based Restaurants in Toronto

The Best Health Food Stores in Toronto