on third thought toronto

On Third Thought

On Third Thought is a combination gelato and wine bar that serves scoops, pints and wines, as well as gelato with alcohol-infused flavours like Aperol spritz and mojito.

The spot has plenty of neighbourhood feel tucked away on a quieter side street just off Queen West. 

on third thought torontoLongtime vegan Jade Lalonde and her boyfriend Joey Ottaviano started On Third Thought, which is also vegan with no dairy, eggs, gluten, nuts or soy.

on third thought torontoOttaviano is the one who whips up the gelato in small batches every night using rice milk to still achieve optimal creaminess for flavours like cookies 'n' cream and strawberry shortcake (they say both sell out every day). 

on third thought torontoThe fruitier options – strawberry, mango and coconut – are prepared with only sugar, water and fresh fruit. We're talking real strawberries, mango and coconut pulp to achieve an extremely refreshing sorbet. 

on third thought torontoThree boozy options also come on the menu. Aperol spritz comes with orange sorbet and Aperol while mojito (made with mint they grow themselves) and pina colada are made with rum. Lalonde recommends combining either the mojito or pina colada with a scoop of strawberry. 

on third thought torontoThe mojito will have you puckering your lips, with the sour lime and mint tastes balanced out nicely by the sweeter and equally refreshing strawberry (single: $5, double: $8). 

on third thought torontoRotating flavours influenced by Lalonde's Caribbean or Ottaviano's Italian backgrounds join the others every once and a while. The affogato ($7.50) is the marriage of two Italian staples: gelato and espresso. 

on third thought torontoThe fresh shot of espresso can be paired with any one of the creamier flavours but classic French vanilla is the typical choice. 

on third thought torontoThere's also a freezer full of pints ($12.99), if that's how you prefer your gelato. 

The wine bar side of the shop includes a list of flat and bubbly wines and proseccos, and each has been paired up with one of the gelatos on offer, so you can grab a pint and bottle to go. 

on third thought toronto The tropical notes of Misty Cove sauvignon blanc match the mango and Santome Sanrichard sparkling red and a pint of chocolate is said to make for an indulgently decadent experience. But Lalonde's favourite is Lodi chardonnay with pina colada. 

on third thought torontoIf a drink is all you're after, they offer that too. Red sangria, mimosa and Aperol spritz ($10) with two shots of prosecco, one-shot of Aperol and some soda are all options. 

Head outside to pose with your drink, or gelato before it melts, in front of the colourful wall mural to fully commemorate a hot summer day. 

on third thought toronto

Photos by

Fareen Karim 

Latest Videos

On Third Thought

Leaflet | © Mapbox © OpenStreetMap Improve this map

Join the conversation Load comments

On Third Thought

Latest Reviews

La Bella Sangweech

Ghoroaa Restaurant

Bao Mama

DaHu Hotpot

Sad Songs Cantina

Leslie's Sandwich Room