rectory cafe toronto

Rectory Cafe on Toronto Island closing its doors for good

Thanks to rising water levels and wide-spread flooding, the Toronto Island Park remains closed until further notice.

Some businesses are pushing through, despite restricted access to the Islands, including The Rectory Cafe, which remains open (including its sun-soaked lakeside patio) seven days a week.

After Thanksgiving, however, the Rectory will close its doors for good. "We decided not to exercise our right to renew our lease," says Ken McAuliffe, one of the restaurant's three owners.

One of the partners is pulling out of the popular Ward's Island spot, and McAuliffe says the remaining two won't buy out the stake. The ongoing flood hasn't helped business either, despite the Rectory remaining dry (for now).

Since fewer people are coming to the Islands, the Rectory's already been losing money, but it's decided to keep trucking and will keep its 57 employees on board until the fall.

"We are going hammer down," says McAuliffe. "We're not doing The Rectory light."

Lead photo by

Greg's Southern Ontario


Latest Videos



Latest Videos


Latest in Eat & Drink

Sponsored

Get tatted and enjoy tequila cocktails at this unique pop-up coming to Toronto

100 essential restaurants in Toronto you need to try at least once

A Toronto Chinese restaurant was just named the best in Canada

Michelin-starred Toronto sushi chef is opening a new noodle shop

Ice cream possibly containing gravel and plastic recalled across Canada

Toronto's food scene just got a major shoutout in the New York Times

All the new Ontario restaurants that were added to the Toronto Michelin Guide 2026

Here's every Toronto restaurant that made the Michelin Guide in 2026