sea witch toronto

Sea Witch Fish and Chips

Sea Witch on St. Clair West is all about the fish. A rather simple menu consists of five types - haddock, pacific cod, halibut, pickerel and arctic char. Patrons can choose to have their fish in one or two piece portions with chips, on a sandwich, or on its own.

Aside from the mains, they also offer fish cakes, chowder and a halibut poutine. If you're looking for a vegetable that isn't a fried potato, or something slawed or pickled, you've come to the wrong place.

Co-owner Kevin Kowalczyk mans the fish fry, having personally fried nearly every piece of fish since he and wife Jacki Strahl opened less than a month ago. Both have been in the food industry for over 10 years each and are realizing a dream in opening this new venture in their own neighbourhood, on St. Clair West east of Christie.

sea witch fish chips toronto

First out was the one-piece pacific cod and chips ($10). The large piece of fresh cod was perfectly cooked inside the crispy, golden, not-too-oily batter. The fish was served with a hefty portion of fresh cut chips, tartar sauce and a creamy coleslaw. A good portion size at only one piece, this was certainly enough to fill a big appetite.

sea witch fish and chips toronto

Next we tried the pickerel sandwich with fries ($14). The Lake Erie pickerel was prepared in the same way as it would be if ordered on its own, and served in a soft ciabatta-type bun. The sandwich featured another well-cooked piece of fish, topped with their house-made pickled onions and tartar sauce. While certainly a tasty sandwich, the bun felt like an unnecessary addition to an already heavy meal.

sea witch fish and chips toronto

The haddock and rings ($13) featured another great-tasting, tender filet. The rings were fried in the same batter as the fish; while delicious, they felt repetitious when eaten together. (The $3 surcharge to replace a plate full of fries for seven onion rings was also a little annoying.)

sea witch fish and chips toronto

We tried a sample of the halibut fish cakes which, like the chowder, onions, tartar sauce and coleslaw, were made in-house. The fish cake patties were heavy on chopped fish, mixed with potato and parsley, and dusted in spiced panko; they'd appeal for those looking for something with a lighter fry.

sea witch fish and chips toronto

All in all Sea Witch stacks up well to the fish and chips heavyweights of Toronto and makes a great option for lunch or dinner. Despite being on the pricier side for fish and chips, I'd bet this new mom-and-pop will soon emerge as a neighbourhood staple.

sea witch fish and chips toronto

Sea Witch has seating for nearly 30 in the family friendly and liquor license-free establishment. Most of their traffic appears to be take-out. They're open 11am-8pm Tuesday and Wednesday, 11am-9pm Thursday through Saturday, and 12pm-7pm on Sunday (closed on Mondays).

sea witch fish and chips toronto

Photos by Marni Wolf.


Sea Witch Fish and Chips

Leaflet | © Mapbox © OpenStreetMap Improve this map

Join the conversation Load comments

Sea Witch Fish and Chips

Latest Reviews

Baked on Brock

Tabriz Persian Cookhouse

Sugo

Uncle Mikey's

Bourbon Street Smokehouse

The Goodman Pub & Kitchen