People
Toronto Through The Eyes of Mayor David Miller
Mayor David Miller announced his intentions not to seek re-election back in September but just because he has less than a year left in office doesn't mean he's ready to kick up his feet.
After his recent trip to Copenhagen, our big blond mayor seems energized about his last year in office -- garbage strike detractors be damned. Here he weighs in on the current state of the city and his role in shaping it for the last seven years.
Some time has elapsed since you announced your decision not to seek another term as mayor. How do you feel about the decision?
I'm happy... it was the right decision. I pretty much made [the decision] after the last election, because when I first started running for mayor, my daughter was seven and my son five. If I ran again and won -- and I was absolutely certain that I would've won -- my daughter would be in university.
I grew up without a father and I always said I would never let my kids grow up without a father... and they virtually have now. Plus, I miss them.
It's such a privilege to be a mayor because you not only get to pass things at council, you actually get to see them happen on the streets in real time. But it's even more of a privilege to see your son and daughter blossom into a lovely young man and lovely young woman, respectively. It's time for me to spend more of my energy being dad, and less pursuing my own career.
How does it feel, now as a bystander, to watch other candidates throw their name into the ring?
I think the new candidates are going to have to answer a pretty powerful question: "Why?" None of them have [answered this question]. Not one. Go look at their remarks. When asked "What is it you want to do?" they can't articulate it. I've always thought that in politics you should run for office because there's something you want to accomplish... that you are uniquely in a place to accomplish.
I'm going to be in the interesting position in the next year of being the mayor, doing the right things, implementing my mandate, and telling people why. And the people who seek to be my successor are going to be held by Torontonians to the same very high standard.
You live in High Park. What is your favourite part of living in that neighbourhood?
I love it because it's so incredibly diverse, both from the perspective of residents' personal backgrounds and economically. [There are] people from all walks of life. You have people from working-class backgrounds, well-off people (although I don't spend too much time in that area), and you have middle class folks. It's a microcosm of Toronto, which is a microcosm of the world... which makes it exciting.
It's located close to Lake Ontario, and I like to run. I run down by the lake as often as I can -- four to five times a week (when I'm not nursing minor injuries). The neighbourhood is centered by High Park, so you've got beautiful, natural features. And it's within walking or a short transit distance from BMO Field at Exhibition Place, the home of Toronto FC, the best show in town.
What are some other favourite parts of the city for you?
I like the Danforth; it's vibrant, alive and interesting.
I really like Scarborough. Scarborough is a whole collection of neighbourhoods that are all quite distinct, with people who are really committed to making their neighbourhood stronger, including some people who live in fairly poor neighbourhoods who come together.
I'm drawn to the places where people are like my family when I grew up -- they don't have a lot, but are really trying to succeed. I'm drawn to places with a lot of newcomers because I'm a newcomer. People look at me as this big blond guy (almost 6'3"), but I am. If you've had that experience of being a newcomer, you've had the experience of being an outsider.
I love Gerrard India Bazaar. At Nucreation, people come from all over North America to get their wedding clothes. [It's] a fantastic little store in Toronto.
You just came back from Copenhagen. What are some of the things that Toronto can do to address the environmental issues facing us all?
The good news is that we're already leaders. We're one of the best cities in the world because we're doing everything.
Some cities like Johannesburg and Jakarta are improving public transit; they've got rapid projects similar to our LRTs, but using buses. Some cities are building retrofits; some are doing LED lights; some cities are doing electric cars, and in Toronto we're doing everything.
What I took back is that we've got all the right strategies, but now we've got to implement them. For example, we passed our energy strategy a couple of weeks ago at council. It says that our greenhouse emission goals are Kyoto plus -- i.e. Kyoto, and then 80% reduction by 2050. We can beat that -- in buildings, transportation, and energy. [For] buildings we've got a strategy like the Mayor's Tower Renewal, and if we can complete that strategy, in things like our green building code for new buildings, we can meet the goal for buildings.
For, transportation, Transit City is helping us meet our goals and is literally under construction -- the groundbreaking was Dec. 21. And energy... that's the key for the remainder. Our energy strategy puts conservation first, because if you conserve, you never need the energy in the first place. We also have demand management and green generation... for example wind, solar, and geothermal.
One of the things that I saw in Copenhagen was the scale to which cities are making efforts. We had cities representing about 700 million people in their regions there... that's one out of ten people in the world. Scale that up a bit with some partnerships with national governments, and you can make a huge impact on reducing our footprint on the planet and creating good jobs at the same time. And we can do it now. We don't have to wait for some theory. We don't even have to wait for an agreement.
What other lessons can Toronto draw from progressive international cities?
I think the big lesson is about taking action. We've got the right strategies. We're cautious here historically; we do a lot of pilot projects. It's about turning those good ideas into action. That's the lesson to take from other cities.
You have your fair share of detractors. Do you feel like you have to defend your record?
Well, I've got another year as mayor, and I think people will look and see. In any position like this, you've got critics, [but] on the other hand, I got nearly 60% of the vote last time. I must have been doing something right.
You've been part of some ambitious projects. Which ones are you the most proud of?
Transit City, our environmental initiatives, and our Community Safety Plan. We've reduced crime in every area, moving from what was already a safe city, to one that is much safer. [We] haven't completely grappled with the gun violence, coming from the drug trade, but our safety strategy was about a partnership with the police who are preventing crime, instead of just punishing people. Also [it's] about building on the strengths of neighbourhoods by focusing on young people to help make sure that they have real opportunity. I think that's the way you build a city.
What worried me about Toronto, and still worries me, is that there's more to do. Much more. We believe in social justice; we believe in everyone having a chance, and there thus shouldn't be neighbourhoods where people face barriers -- first of all because of their poverty or their parent's poverty, second of all because of their race, ethnicity or newcomer status.
A lot of the neighbourhoods where this tends to happen are those with a low level of public investment, and when there's a low level of public investment, we call them priority neighbourhoods. If you look historically at why there's a low level of public investment, it's often because those neighbourhoods were places where newcomers settled. What's true about every newcomer? They don't have a vote. If someone makes a commitment to Toronto by becoming a permanent resident, they should have a vote. We haven't gotten there yet, but I'm advocating for a change to a provincial law that needs to change.
What are the odds we're going to see you in furniture commercials when you're out of office?
Zero.
Photos by Gadjo Cardenas, WWF Canada and Mayor Miller on Flickr.


Discussion
30 Comments
Sort By Oldest First / Newest First
Subscribe
I think, generally, Torontonians want a mayor (and city council) that is progressive and forward-thinking BUT spends within their means and spends money appropriately. There's nothing worse to see than people crying that the city has no money when the collective leadership hasn't attempted to tackle the problems itself.
We like the idea of Transit City but practically know that Eglinton (for example) will be a disaster and should be a subway line. We like the idea of earning a decent wage and good living but get frustrated with unionized workers who snub their noses at us and get away with their actions because they have the city right where they want them. We like the idea of bike paths but practically we know there's always going to be a struggle between groups and in the winter time, it's somewhat impractical (cyclists, please let me know otherwise if I am incorrect). We like the idea of cultural attractions like art museums but then wonder what the rational is of putting one in Regent Park.
And what about the Pan-Am "games"? Why do we need a third-rate event to spur development? Why can't development be started and done in a P3 manner with help from the private sector?
I think the final thing, as pointed out above, that people find frustrating is the way in which the city has tried to raise revenues but with nothing to show for it. I think if people could see, for example, that $60 licence tax go towards bike lanes or something transit-related, it wouldn't be popular but there's something concrete to point to and say "this is where my money is going". Instead, it feels like money is being sucked into a large black hole/money pit.
Now to start the "Anyone But Smitherman" campaign.
While 60% of the electorate voted for the Mayor, of which you are a part of, there's 40% of us who didn't and are a bit disappointed and rightfully angry at the Mayor. So what you are telling me/us about yourself is that you voted for a guy who's vision (as pointed out above in other posts):
- was supposed to cancel the bridge and effectively kill the island airport - how's that going?
- was supposed to clean up city hall with the symbolic broom - where's the clean up?
- was supposed to improve relations with the unions which lead to wildcat strikes and a really long garbage strike
- was supposed to implement a Toronto-wide bike network - how far along are we?
It's perfectly fine if you are a fan of the Mayor but, and this is typical of a lot of Torontonians, don't dismiss criticism as crazy talk because you don't happen to agree with it. I don't agree with your viewpoint but I'm not dismissing it. I live in this city too, I want to know what is going on and why our leadership won't make the tough choices to put the city on track to be financially strong.
I agree in general with alot of the comments that Rob made of the lack of transparency in terms of fees and taxes, and inability to tackle the unions.
City violence is way too high including the increase in shootings around major public areas (outside of Yorkdale?? Eaton Centre???).
Crime on and around the TTC is also pretty bad.
(I will give him (some very minor) credit for riding the subway every morning- I saw him so many times on the subway, including a time when the train was stopped for 30 minutes..it was packed no one said anything to him, but you know that was probably the longest 30 minutes of his life)
In general I feel that he just lacked vision and was continually just babysitting city hall. He just went with the flow
Zero leadership.
Crack is a terrible drug, isn't it?
Keep quiet. Just a suggestion.
Simba, Mayor Miller has made some improvements in Scarborough and to my knowledge, has been there often (a lot more than I have) to maintain an understanding and relationship to that part of the city. So yeah, he likes Scarborough.
Is this what you clones are saying?
Miller's mayorality has seen fantastic city-sponsored events initiated (LuminaTO, Nuit Blanche, Summer- and Winterlicious events), the start of Transit City, *improvements* in TTC service (yes, we'll be getting an online route planner and text-messaging for next bus/streetcar arrival times soon and frequencies are up on many many routes) and infrastructure (yay, Flexity streetcars!), Green Roofs, Tower Renewal, Deep Water Cooling etc. etc. not to mention renewal of our cultural institutions, and significant progress on the waterfront. Under Miller, I feel that Toronto has moved beyond wanting to become world-class: it is.
And regarding the new City taxes, that is part of Toronto gaining extra powers from the province - didn't we want that? The implementation of the city's Land Transfer Tax did not cause a meltdown in the real estate market, as predicted hysterically by real estate agents (the market is pretty much at its highest level ever), and $60 bucks for the privilege of driving in the city is truly a pitance.
I remain a strong supporter of Mr. Miller. I think he has done a wonderful job for our City. The new taxes, which I regret, are not the "fault" of Mr. Miller or the City for that matter. They arise because Mr "Time for Change" McGinty has perpetuated the Harris policies and Toronto remains severely underfunded by the Province. Downloading took place over night and uploading is on a ten year creep. Higher levels of government - according to John Tory - raise 9 Billion Dollars a year in Toronto that they spend elsewhere. The Education tax remains crippling to the City and highly unfair - especially at the Commercial level. (Education tax goes to the Province.) Study after study has shown that there is NOT waste at City Hall and that programme spending rises at levels lower than the Federal or Provincial Governments. The rhetoric used to attack Mr. Miller is a fine thing - especially if one avoids letting the real facts get in the way.
Essential reading is the John Lorinc article in Saturday's Globe (TO Section) about the civic strike. It paints an entirely different picture than the populist accepted wisdom.
I remain a big Miller supporter and fan. I love living in the City and am proud to pay my taxes - municipal, provincial and federal. However, the Province needs to spend a little more of the money it raises in Toronto at a level so that citizens of Toronto will enjoy the same level of provincial support received by citizens elsewhere.
Sadly, biodegradable bags exist, but Miller was just politically incorrect. At no time have businesses offered a free alternative to the plastic bags, such as paper bags.
Remember Miller when he said that everybody should ride a bike? Seniors can't, people with disabilities can't. Try cycling in winter. How come biking is forbidden on the 401, DVP and the Gardiner Expressway?
Miller is a moron. I bet he really enjoyed his trip to Copenhagen. He should have stayed there, after all we got stuck for paying his expensive trip back as well.
Please quote your source as I and many others believe your statement to be untrue. Especially after reading the last budget the city presented.
Yes, you got 60% last time but how many of those people, including me, would vote for you again?
I believe you already know the answer by not running again.
Please leave as soon as possible.
Nonsense. My 90 year old grandfather rode a bike every single day until recently. Of course, he lives in Holland, where biking is an integral part of the culture. Here, people would rather drive two blocks to the corner store, even on a warm, sunny day.
I agree that Miller is not alone in dragging this city into the muck - there is plenty of blame to go around for that, but as long as the REAL issues in this city fail to be mentioned during elections and the usual suspects hijack the agenda (like bicycle lanes and building Taj Mahals for the 'homeless' are going to return this city to greatness!), then the majority are going to stay away from the polls in droves. A massive shrug during city elections: it's the same old spoon-fed Pablum from the likes who actually believe Consumers Reports and the Star print the truth.
December 21, 2009
Print-friendly version
Invest Toronto board appoints new CEO
The Board of Directors for Invest Toronto today gave unanimous support to the appointment of Renato Discenza as the agency’s Chief Executive Officer.
The website for Invest Toronto may not be up to date. The above is from a a press release from Invest Toronto. Ir was also in The Globe and Mail. My advice to my Right Wing pals is to spend more time in pursuit of real facts and less time fulminating.
@Nick
There is no need to pay $60.00 for the 'privilege' of driving in the city. The 905'ers do not pay the tax and they do plenty of driving in our city, no offense to the 905'ers of course.
It's simply a tax grab to fund the needless overspending taking place at city hall.
I think the plastic bag charge is brilliant. It's a lazy tax. It happened because it's the only way to get self-entitled, lazy people to change, knowing they won't want to part with any more of their money. And $60 tax for the privilege of driving in the city is a pittance. The fact that 905'ers do not pay this has nothing to do with Miller and everything to do with the Provincial Government failing to recognize Toronto's costs and value to the province. Aside from drivers, I see GoTrain riders come into the city and use our services and then take the GoTrain home and pay taxes elsewhere and it sucks, but blaming Miller for it is childish. Your expectations are unrealistic.
If you aren't happy with how things are run, then what are you doing to get involved?
I have lived in the city for 14 years and the past three years I have noticed a definite improvement and an energy that was missing during the Lastman years. People are opening businesses and tourism is up. Just look at the increase in BlogTO's posts in the past three years and you'll see how much more is happening in our city.