City
Lower Sherbourne might be home to huge development
The area of Front and Lower Sherbourne Street is currently a skyscraper free zone. There are plenty of tall towers nearby, of course, but the immediate area remains one of relatively low (literally and figuratively) development despite its valuable location. That might change, however, if the City approves the Pemberton Group's large-scale development proposal.
That proposal calls for the overhaul of an entire city block, which will stretch from Front Street to the north, Lower Sherbourne to the west, Princess Street to the east, and The Esplanade to the south. Currently under review by the City of Toronto, the project will include two residential towers of 34 and 33 storeys, connected to 13- and 17-storey base buildings. In its current incarnation, the proposal also includes plans for an underground garage accommodating 913 parking spots, as well as retail or commercial spaces at ground level.
The area in question (177 - 197 Front Street East) is currently occupied by a Sobey's grocery store and an Acura dealership — not exactly beacons of urban development. But to say this proposal will bring new life to the area is undoubtedly a gross understatement. Count 'em — a whopping 1,663 units will occupy the spot if approved, with 795 units in the first tower and 868 in the second. That means this block — which currently only sees the odd ILX shopper or commuter picking up milk on the way home from work — will see a massive increase in activity. It will also see new heights that are pretty substantial for the immediate area.
Nevertheless, there are obvious kinks that need to be worked out before this project wins approval. Current zoning requirements call for 1,140 parking spaces for the area; this project includes 913. Drafts also reflect two towers with only one- and two-bedroom units, and we all know three-bedroom suites (with families!) make for healthier communities (right Adam Vaughan?).
The tiered architecture does lend itself to plenty of green roofs (which is better than the grey surface parking lot there now), but it also looks a little... prison-esque? Uber-commercial? Uninspired? I'm not sure. But a spot sandwiched between the Distillery and St. Lawrence Market ought to dance with a little character, and (from up here on my inflated high horse) it doesn't seem like Pemberton is playing with a whole lot. The real question, though, is whether Front and Lower Sherbourne can handle a project of such massive scale. Will it be a much-needed area overhaul, or simply overwhelm?
Discussion
33 Comments
Sort By Oldest First / Newest First
Subscribe
But they won't, so it's a moot point.
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2139914/A-rare-insight-Kowloon-Walled-City.html
That's an incredibly dismissive take on what happens in the neighbourhood, as if the block itself was completely isolated. The Sobey's is a big grocery store, not some 7-11 convenience store for 'commuters' to get milk. The block is surrounded by mid-rise residential buildings, including 3 schools. The Esplanade along the site's southern edge bustles with families taking their kids to school. These are primarily low income folks, which perhaps explains why the streetscape isn't overflowing with trendy Ossington-like activity. Adulation for this kind of project seems to suggest that the natural progression of a neighbourhood should be one of gentrification.
The only real blight is the Acura dealership.
Also, FWIW, Pam McConnell has spoken eloquently and forcefully against a series of tall 1-2 bedroom King-west style condo projects in the neighbourhood. Residents aren't against development, but the official plan calls for mid-rise residential projects that fit in with their neighbours, not 30+ story profit machines.
This could be a perfectly good fabric building without too much work. Add a healthy amount of three bedroom units, and ensure that it has an active street level with retail & community spaces (require a subsidized space for daycare use as a section 37 benefit) instead of the all-too-common long blank walls/windows (with the condo's amenity area and garage access). Then step back the podium a bit on the north and south sides, and take a few storeys off the towers & shift them south a bit to greatly decrease shadow impacts.
I ask again-why can't all of these buildings be built in Scarborough, North York, East York, Etobicoke, and the 'Saug? Also, why cant they build this to a reasonable level like a couple of the newer ones already built in downtown Toronto and Richmond Hill?