Wednesday, May 22, 2013Cloudy 15°C
City

A brief history of the Margaret Eaton school in Toronto

Posted by Chris Bateman / January 16, 2012

Margaret Eaton's School Facade.jpgLooking like a relic from another land, the Margaret Eaton School of Literature and Expression with its Greek temple design, genie motif and cryptic motto never seemed quite at home sandwiched between two anonymous homes on North Street, just south of Bloor.

Designed by W. R. Mead in a Greek revival style, the school was financed by and named for Margaret Eaton, wife of Toronto retail magnate Timothy Eaton, as a home for the teachings of Emma Scott Raff, a pioneering University of Toronto women's teacher specializing in physical education and dramatic arts.

Under the inscribed motto of "Beauty and Fitness," Scott Raff wanted to educate a student "not so much ... who can stand on her head and perform with her feet, but the student who can stand on her feet and perform with her head," a philosophy that resonated with the Eaton family and many others in Canada's social elite at the time.

Margaret Eaton's School Side.jpgCompleted in 1906, the school taught literature, physical culture and rhetoric from the outset, quickly establishing itself as a landmark in the city. Its most significant contributions, however, were to Canada's performing arts scene.

Around the turn of the century female actors were often marginalised in the male-dominated theatre world. Scott Raff was among the first in Canada to produce new plays by Irish writers W. B. Yeats, J. M. Synge and Augusta, Lady Gregory to rapt audiences. The school also hosted guest lectures by big names such as Albert Grey, the 4th Earl Grey, Governor of Canada and namesake of the Grey Cup, Sir Johnston Forbes-Robertson, English actor and theatre manager, and Sir Frank Benson, a producer famous in the era for his Shakespeare plays.

While the curriculum was mostly limited to foreign authors, a few homegrown titles were taught to students. The school's final performance was When Half Gods Go by Canadian poet Norah Holland. Dora Mavor Moore, another trailblazer for Canadian theatre later in her life, was among the school's successful alumnae and the Dora Mavor Moore Awards, or Doras, are presented each year by the Toronto Alliance for the Performing Arts to the outstanding members of the local theatre scene.

Despite occasional difficulties of keeping the school in the black, Scott Raff guided the school until its closure and merger with Victoria College at University of Toronto in 1926. At the time of her death in 1940 Scott Raff's name was indelibly linked with the Little Theatre movement in Canada.

Margaret Eaton's School Moshers.jpgThe building, however, didn't fare as well. It had its portico removed when North Street, now Bay, was widened. Mosher's, a dance studio run by the brilliantly named Hiram and Pansy Mosher, owned the property during its final years before demolition as part of the reconfiguration of Bay Street. If the building were still standing today it would be opposite the Manulife Centre on the site of the brown brick high-rise at 1166 Bay.

Margaret Eaton's School Bay Diagram.jpgThanks to Canadian Shakespeares and Heritage Toronto.

Photos from the City of Toronto Archives

Discussion

5 Comments

bummer / January 16, 2012 at 09:54 am
user-pic
Beautiful building. So sad it's gone. Oh well. At least Old Montreal gives a crap about preserving history.
Kevo replying to a comment from bummer / January 16, 2012 at 11:08 am
user-pic
Uhh, in most cities around the world old buildings were torn down... do you think that Paris was built over 2000 years in it's current layout, that the Louvre was the original structure there, or that St. Peter's Basilica was the original church that sat on the site? It's only been in the last 50 years anyone's actually given a damn about old buildings. I am by no means against historical preservation, but preserving a building that was mangled beyond recognition because it's old is silly. Besides this, if Toronto didn't build in the core, the skyscrapers we now have would be in one of the boroughs and downtown would still be wooden structures with plank sidewalks. Protect what is important (socially, culturally, architecturally), but don't stop the need for change for the sake of a building being old.
Philamania replying to a comment from Kevo / January 16, 2012 at 12:18 pm
user-pic
Well said...
Adam Sobolak / January 16, 2012 at 07:26 pm
user-pic
And besides, "Old Montreal" *also* has a history of not giving a cr*p about so-called preserving its history. (For proof, look up the Van Horne Mansion. And that's just one emblematic example.)
Molly Hillary Wills / May 10, 2012 at 01:31 pm
user-pic
The Margaret Eaton School didn't close or merge with Victoria College in 1926. It did move out of the classically-styled building in 1926; Lady Eaton had withdrawn her sponsorship and the school changed its primary focus from Literature and Expression to Physical Education, and it moved its activities to a T. Eaton Company-owned former YMCA building at 415 Yonge St. The ancient aristocratic ideal of "the beautiful and the good" was captured in the Greek lettering on the original school's pediment and in its motto, "We strive for the good and the beautiful," which changed at the time of the move to "Beauty and fitness". In 1934 a co-operative arrangement with the University of Toronto began, and in 1942 the Margaret Eaton School amalgamated with the University of Toronto when the university began offering the first bachelor's degree in physical education in Canada.

Add a Comment

Other Cities: Montreal