19 plymbridge crescent toronto

Gorgeous Toronto home demolished just two months after city tried to save it

Toronto has lost another historic property in illegal demolition just after it was deemed a heritage property.

The home at 19 Plymbridge Crescent in Hogg's Hollow was torn down on the May long weekend.

The home follows a few recent losses for the city. A stone cottage in Mimico built around 1920 was torn down days before a heritage meeting for the home. Work to demolish historic foundry buildings was stopped after an outcry. Other buildings are still at risk of demolition.

19 plymbridge crescent toronto

The home at 19 Plymbridge Crescent sat on a beautifully treed property in Hogg's Hollow. 

Toronto Councillor Jaye Robinson called the demolition of the Hogg's Hollow home brazen.

"This work was undertaken without a permit," Robinson said in an email to the community.

19 plymbridge crescent toronto

The living room looks dated in these 2019 photos but still in good condition.

The property owners, listed on an application to build a new home, declined to speak to blogTO. They requested to nearly double the size of the building envelope back in December of 2020. The request was denied.

The four-bedroom home was sold in August 2019 for $4.3 million, according to Zoocasa.

19 plymbridge crescent toronto

There was a fireplace in the living room.

Robinson said while the demolition was occurring on May 22 several of the neighbours rushed out to the site but their pleas were ignored and the demolition was substantially completed within an hour.

19 plymbridge crescent toronto

The kitchen had views of the treed lot.

"By the time I was alerted and began driving to the property, the historic building that had been standing on the site for more than a century had already been reduced to a pile of rubble," Robinson said.

19 plymbridge crescent toronto

There was a formal dining room in the home that was built around 1912.

The two-storey stucco-clad house built around 1912 and designed in the Tudor Revival style, City of Toronto Heritage documents state.

19 plymbridge crescent toronto

The primary bedroom had a balcony.

"The building is a rare and unique example of a converted stables building within the neighbourhood," the documents state. The home is a remnant of the former Boultbee family estate, The Hollow, representing an early period in the historical land development of the area.

19 plymbridge crescent toronto

There was also a traditional-style study or office area.

A former owner of the home sent a heritage property nomination to Heritage Planning in March 2013.

19 plymbridge crescent toronto

There was also a beautiful pool.

The home did finally meet the criteria required to pursue a heritage designation and it was added to City's Heritage Register on March 10 this year.

19 plymbridge crescent toronto

The home was built as a stable for horses and was later converted.

It is unclear what penalties will be imposed on the property owner. Robinson indicated the city solicitor will have the final say on the actions pursued under the Ontario Heritage Act, Planning Act, and Ontario Building Code, and maximum penalties could include imprisonment.

"If it were up to me, the builder would be required to reconstruct the house brick-by-brick until it matched the exact design and footprint of what existed just a few short days ago," Robinson wrote.

Photos by

Thea Menagh


Join the conversation Load comments

Latest in Real Estate

This sprawling 100-year-old house in Toronto has its own private beach for $7 million

Toronto building that just went up for sale comes with an indoor rock-climbing wall

This beautiful Toronto house was built 21 years ago and no one has ever lived in it

$20 million house in Ontario looks like a cross between a castle and a log cabin

This $13 million mansion in Vaughan comes with a walk-in closet the size of a shoe store

This $10 million mansion north of Toronto has its own river running through it

This $10 million French castle in Vaughan comes with a 16-foot waterfall

Gorgeous Toronto home demolished just two months after city tried to save it