peanut butter jelly toronto

Peanut butter and jelly are given new spins at these Toronto businesses

April 2 is National Peanut Butter and Jelly Day, so what better time to sample some of Toronto's hottest takes on the household combination that's more creative than between two pieces of bread?

Here's where to find inventive iterations of this treat around Toronto.

Ernie's Icebox

What's better than a PB&J sandwich? An ice cream PB&J sandwich, naturally.

This beloved combo is one of the few flavours found on Ernie's menu year-round. It features two peanut butter cookies surrounding a slab of cinnamon toast ice cream with housemade raspberry jam.

Tom's Dairy Freeze

Alternatively, if you'd prefer to eat ice cream in a cone, there's Toms Dairy Freeze.

Here, the combination of peanut butter and jam can be created by rolling a blue raspberry-dipped cone in chopped peanuts, then drizzling it with peanut butter. Or top a peanut butter-dipped sundae with strawberry topping. Both are a little messy but it worked for us, at least.

Bake Code

This modern Euro-Asian bakery is a croissanterie that produces at least 20 variations of the pastry. Demonstrating that peanut butter and jelly also pairs well with puffy croissants, their mouthwatering cream-filled PB&J is one of their bestsellers.

Holy Chuck Burgers

Love milkshakes? You won't want to miss out on Holy Chuck's peanut butter and jelly icy treat. 

All the handspun drinks contain 95 per cent ice cream and 5 per cent whole milk. Plus, their burgers are pretty amazing too if you're looking for more to fill up on. 

Beaumont Kitchen

We'll take this PB&J ice cream-soaked French toast for brunch any day. This work of art by Beaumont Kitchen can be found on their brunch menu and features seasonal fruit compote, peanut butter mousse and maple syrup.

Kupfert & Kim

For anyone looking for a more nutritious healthy treat but with the same indulgent flavours of peanut butter and jelly, these mighty raw energy balls from Kupfert & Kim are a perfect choice.

Donning an attention-grabbing organic red dye, they contain raspberries, peanut butter, dates, raisins, almonds, organic lucuma and sea salt. 

Lead photo by

Fareen Karim

Latest Videos

Latest Videos

Join the conversation Load comments

Peanut butter and jelly are given new spins at these Toronto businesses

Leaflet | © Mapbox © OpenStreetMap Improve this map

Latest in Eat & Drink

Toronto sushi restaurant slammed with 10 infractions by health inspectors

Mexican restaurant permanently closes after 12 years in Toronto

Toronto woman claims sushi restaurant judged her for ordering 'too much' food

25 new patios in Toronto now open for the summer

Popular Toronto pub is temporarily closed and looking for a new location

Toronto bakery nailed with 16 infractions by health inspectors

My quest to find the best kid-friendly restaurants in Toronto that don't suck

Dairy Queen shut down by landlord in Toronto for owing almost $30k in rent