gerties toronto

Toronto's newest bakery only makes peanut butter pies

Toronto's latest bakery to pop up makes one magical thing only: peanut butter pies.

Called Gertie's, the project comes to us from Ryan Campbell (Il Covo) and Sara Steep.

It's an homage to a woman named Gerda or "Gertie," recreating her old school pie recipe of graham wheat and peanut crust, whipped mascarpone cream with fresh lemon, all-natural peanut butter mousse, honey roasted peanuts and a peanut caramel. 

Of course, the pies are designed to be a pandemic-friendly individual size.

"Our goal? To make a few bucks, to open a new business and home, to create jobs for the beautiful hospitality people of Canada, to search and destroy every peanut product out there. Just kidding, sort of," reads the description on the Gertie's website.

"We're just peanut butter lovers like the rest of you and want to share what we believe is a tasty and fun treat to enjoy, every day. With a coffee for breakfast, as an after-school snack, in place of supper, for dessert, or as a late night gluttony with four fingers of gout-infused Amaro."

The pies are currently available wholesale at Grow Gather & Co.Barocco x Nino, Woodward MeatsMcEwan, Salt Gourmet Foods and Butchers of Distinction, and they're currently working on partnering with more retailers.

Lead photo by

Gertie's


Latest Videos



Latest Videos


Latest in Eat & Drink

Ice cream possibly containing gravel and plastic recalled across Canada

Toronto's food scene just got a major shoutout in the New York Times

All the new Ontario restaurants that were added to the Toronto Michelin Guide 2026

Here's every Toronto restaurant that made the Michelin Guide in 2026

Toronto's best baguette and croissant to be crowned once and for all next month

Celebrities have been spotted at restaurants all over Ontario lately

Much-anticipated Toronto restaurant finally opens next week

Some of the best food in Toronto right now isn't coming out of restaurants