casa tamayo toronto

Toronto pizza joint that was also a variety store shuts down

After nearly two years, Casa Tamayo on Pape Street has shuttered for good. 

It's unclear why longtime resident Leticia Tamayo-Diaz has closed her pizzeria at 581 Pape Ave.

Aside from its white board menu of pizza toppings, the local favourite at the corner of Wroxeter Avenue was also a convenience and grocery store.

Tamayo-Diaz graduated from baking at George Brown College shortly before deciding to take over the former space of Pape Pizza and Variety in January 2019, transforming it into Casa Tamayo.

The restaurant was accepting phone orders and offered delivery through Uber Eats during the pandemic.

Tamayo-Diaz could not be reached at the time of publishing, so the exact reason for the closure is unknown.

It joins a slew of pizzerias in the city like Dino's Pizza on Dundas West, Brass Taps and the Garfield pizza joint to close permanently in 2020. 

One Night Only Pizza is scheduled to open in its place in early 2021.

Lead photo by

Anik Watts

Join the conversation Load comments

Latest in Eat & Drink

Toronto bar apologizes for political donation to white nationalist

Global fried chicken chain opening its first Canadian location in Mississauga

Secret pop-up dinner service in Toronto is about to open a permanent restaurant

Chinese restaurants in Toronto team up to celebrate Lunar New Year and fight stigma

Toronto business gets creative with pickup after it's forced to renovate front window

Toronto restaurant surprises its chef with a congratulatory billboard

Huge lineups outside new Toronto chicken restaurant despite stay-at-home orders

Toronto's bacon-themed restaurant has permanently closed