trees queen leslie toronto

Outrage after Toronto trees 'butchered' by chainsaw-wielding city workers

A row of Toronto street trees looks barren and depressing after a City-ordered pruning went too far on Thursday, leaving one local arborist at his "wit's end."

Todd Irvine, a Toronto arborist, shared a series of photos of the defoliated trees on Queen Street East near Leslie Street after attempting to intervene against the chainsaw-equipped crew, who explained to him they were sent by the City.

The images, posted to X (formerly Twitter), look like they could be used in the set design for a 1990s Tim Burton flick: spindly, twisting branches with limbs hacked away and dicey odds at survival.

The City maintains stringent tree pruning guidelines that govern how such situations should be handled, though they appear not to have been followed in this instance.

Irvine tells blogTO that "the City, in their own pruning standards on their website, says that their objective is to not prune more than 20 per cent of the living canopy in any growing season. And in this instance, they're pruning 50 to 70 per cent of the live growth: it's hard to say exactly how much but those pictures are pretty damning."

"It's just hard to watch," says Irvine, who stresses that "it's causing injury" to the trees, and worries "those trees may eventually die."

"Not to mention, they just look ridiculous," he adds.

Tree canopies often take a very long time to develop, and this hack-and-slash style of pruning undoes years of growth in a matter of minutes.

"The cuts they're making, some of those branches have been there for most of the life of the tree," says Irvine. "So 15, 20 years. And now, today, have decided that they were a problem, but for 15 years, they weren't.

Irvine calls out the City for spending money "to plant these trees in quite hostile growing environments, spend years caring for them, make them reach maturity or a size where they provide some benefit to a city street," only to "go in and prune them, way beyond their own standards to the point where they're on the verge of dying."

blogTO has reached out to local councillor Paula Fletcher, who commented on the aggressive pruning on X, calling it "troubling." Fletcher was not available to provide immediate comment in time for this article's publication.

Irvine calls the problem a cultural one, with Toronto's infrastructure investments often taking precedence over the health of city streets.

"It's a cultural thing," he says. Having travelled to several other major North American cities, he is baffled by Toronto's tendency to "prune more aggressively than other places that I've visited."

Adding insult to injury, this is not a new issue at all, even on this stretch of Queen. Irvine vented his frustration by quote-tweeting his own photo from May 2022 of a similarly over-pruned tree, noting that "nothing seems to have changed."

While the local councillor's office has not provided details about the tree pruning, many on social media have been quick to assume that the trees were pruned to accommodate raised power lines.

Irvine is not convinced, however, noting that the before photos show most branches "cut off or below the power lines, they are really not in a place where they're in major conflict."

Even if there was a conflict, Irvine argues that workers "could provide the clearance with a much smaller pruning cut. If you're pruning trees with a chainsaw, you've usually failed that tree."

Lead photo by

Todd Irvine


Latest Videos



Latest Videos


Join the conversation Load comments

Latest in City

Toronto could soon be getting Ferris wheels just for cars

Honda Canada recalls hundreds of thousands of vehicles due to risk of crash

Toronto's human-made river is about to cross its biggest milestone to date

University of Toronto ranks among top 50 universities in the world

An almost 5-kilometre stretch of TTC subway will shut down this entire weekend

Toronto just smashed yet another very concerning weather record

What's open and closed on Thanksgiving Monday 2024 in Toronto

Ontario's record-breaking $6.4B border bridge just crossed another big milestone