Oak Island Toronto

Oak Island

Oak Island seeks to reinvent seventies and eighties cocktail culture. Bottled coolers, garish Fruitopia-like sodas, and technicolour ingredients like blue curacao are given the craft treatment here.

They’re giving the reverence associated with cool prohibition-era-style faux speakeasy cocktails like bold Manhattans and potent Old Fashioneds to drinks from what are known as the dark ages of mixology, bringing them into the light of the 21st century.

Oak Island Toronto

This is exemplified by ultra-stylish decor, which gives a nod to seventies and eighties theming without overdoing it or being too gimmicky.

This most means lots of pastels and neons, rounded edges, and vintage glassware. It’s quite the transformation from The Well, which had more of that dim prohibition look.

Oak Island Toronto

It’s owned by Jennifer Langen and Brett Watterton, from events and bartending backgrounds respectively. Watterton mixes us up a pisco punch from the $13 “coolers” portion of the menu.

Oak Island Toronto

It’s made simply with pisco, pineapple gomme (a sweet syrup) and citrus, and mostly tastes tart with hints of brandy, grapefruit and pineapple.

Oak Island Toronto

A bottled cooler that really pays homage to those horribly sweet cheap wine coolers is the Snake Oil, tasting strongly of smoky tequila with a tart edge of house cordial, mixed with mezcal, Lillet Blanc, curacao, absinthe and Boker’s bitters.

oak island torontoShooters ($7) offer that recognizable sickly colour, like the Kamikaze. This simple mix of vodka, house cordial, and house blue curacao made using cointreau and blue food colouring goes down easy while still delivering a little sour kick and will have you ready to go dancing in some platforms.

Oak Island Toronto

Unique non-alcoholic sodas ($5) are on offer here, though there is a suggested alcohol to be mixed with each should you want to spice it up. The strawberry kiwi brings me back to my Fruitopia days with its syrupy sweet fruity flavours.

Oak Island TorontoMusings on possible ideas for the place involve old school foot-long brisket subs available during the daytime.

Oak Island Toronto

Watterton is also affiliated with local charity party organization Dudebox. He’s using these connections to bring in regular DJs, as well as throwing hype community parties that should mostly be free featuring such names as Daniel Caesar and Bad Bad Not Good’s Chester Hansen. A house soul band featuring Marlon James plays twice a month.

Oak Island Toronto

They’re really bringing in local creators to give their space an edge, and make it a community hub on Ossington. While I was there art by local Justin Broadbent lined the wall, and a mural by James Kirkpatrick can be found near the back.Oak Island Toronto

Photos by

Jesse Milns

Latest Reviews

Deer Lady


Decoy Bar

Offworld Bar

Black Pearl