Wednesday, October 14, 2015Mostly Cloudy 12°C

Gelato Pizza

Posted by Robyn Urback / Listed on November 19, 2012 / review policy

gelato pizza torontoGelato Pizza is in no way ambiguous about what it brings to the Parkdale community. "Everyone I talked to didn't like the name," says owner Giuseppe Petrella, who obviously isn't shy about sticking to his guns. "They thought it sounded like I was serving gelato on pizza."

gelato pizza torontoBut no, this new Parkale spot offers pizza and gelato as separate entities, developed through Giuseppe's years in the food industry. "My father was in the pizza business," he says as we chat in the new shop's salvage church pew seats. "And his father was in the pizza business, so for me, it came naturally."

Giuseppe tells me he's spent the last seven years running a pizza franchise, though he's always longed to branch off and do things his own way. "This is real Italian pizza," he says. "And real Italian gelato."

gelato pizza torontoWhile the pizza is made in-house, the gelato is sourced from Gelato Simply Italian which Giuseppe says he settled on after tasting about a dozen different Toronto options. There are currently about 16 flavours available at Gelato Pizza — the more traditional options including hazelnut chocolate, blood orange, pistachio, and lemon — and room for another 16 more when the mercury rises during the summer.

gelato pizza torontoPizza production (and consumption) is already in full swing here, with 22 specialty pies on the menu (all priced the same $12.95/$15.95/$18.95 or $4.40 per slice) and the option to create your own. They range from the basic "Ma" pizza with tomato sauce and mozzarella ("Just like my ma' made it when I was a kid," Giuseppe says) to the "A-Maize-Ing" pie with extra virgin olive oil, mozzarella, garlic, tomatoes, corn, parmesan, basil, and eggplant.

Each pie name comes with a thorough back story (just ask Giuseppe), and is made with fresh ingredients that are all prepared onsite. Available slices include three vegan options, and Gelato Pizza is working on developing its own gluten-free crust.

gelato pizza torontoThe Brad Pitt slice immediately catches my eye, and comes brimming with veal meatballs, dry-cured pepperoni, homemade sausage, and chunks of ham and bacon on top of mozzarella and tomato sauce. The crust is a modest thickness — more chewy than crispy — serving as foundation for the meat-heavy pie. In case it wasn't clear, this pie comes with a "carne" heading. This isn't one of those slices that's dripping with cheese (yeah, I'm looking at you, King Slice) or smothered only with pepperoni, but rather, comes with an equal presence of all of its protein-rich toppings in tow.

gelato pizza torontoWhile the pizza itself does win my affection, it's the homemade dipping sauce that has me swooning. Made with fresh sour cream, yogurt, garlic, and spices, this sauce is slightly less viscous than some of the other garlic dipping sauces around, giving it a more tempered taste rather than an overwhelming garlic "punch."

gelato pizza torontoGelato Pizza plans to roll out delivery in the coming weeks (delivery of pizza and gelato) and is planning on opening its second location (yes, already!) sometime in the new year. And it's good news for you east-enders; keep an eye on the old Ethel corner lot.

gelato pizza torontoPhotos by Jesse Milns



Jarvis Emerald / November 19, 2012 at 12:31 pm
I will have to check this place out. My How Parkdale is changing. The name of this place is confusing but appealing at the same time. i would stop in just to see what it is.
Jer / November 19, 2012 at 12:37 pm
I don't like the name personally but I will give the place a try.

Boreal Gelato a few doors down is also very good for gelato (they make it on site too from fresh ingredients).
justpete / November 19, 2012 at 12:38 pm
Apparently this is a chain that opens up next door to just-establishing gelato places to compete, offering a cheaper product at a lesser price in the hopes that the patrons in the area will prefer cheap to good. And really, who would eat either Pizza or Gelato from a place just called "Gelato Pizza"???
?? / November 19, 2012 at 12:40 pm
Any mention of the Leslieville Gelato Pizza opening?

The "Coming Soon" sign has been up on a vacant store front since the summer.
Leslievillian / November 19, 2012 at 12:46 pm
If they are a "real" Italian gelato place why don't they have a lid on all their tubs of gelato?
Kyle / November 19, 2012 at 12:47 pm
I don't see what's so confusing about it - when I go to Laser Hair Removal Burgers, I know that I can get my bikini line done and enjoy one of the best burgers in the city all in one stop.
jameson / November 19, 2012 at 12:48 pm
I only get pizza from Albany Pizza on Landsdowne, but this looks very interesting. Will have to try!
Lola / November 19, 2012 at 12:56 pm
Pizza is good! Gelato I will continue getting from Boreal next door, who makes it from scratch in house.
Scott / November 19, 2012 at 02:02 pm
Pizza is great, but I'm gonna keep going to Boreal right next door for my gelato fix.
sage / November 19, 2012 at 02:12 pm
the pizza does look good though old man pizza at queen/jameson is awesome and cheap. I will definitely continue to support Boreal next door, they make their gelato in-house and it is delicious!!
Matt / November 19, 2012 at 03:14 pm
go to Boreal instead.
Mike / November 19, 2012 at 04:45 pm
Hey! Nice to see another fan of Albany Pizza in the comments. Pepe makes awesome pizza!
me / November 19, 2012 at 06:53 pm
does anyone know if there's anywhere else to get gelato in the neighbourhood? i'm looking for something made in-house.
TheDuder / November 19, 2012 at 07:19 pm
Support Boreal Gelato. Their employees are smokin hot.
ChefAldea / November 19, 2012 at 08:12 pm
So glad Gord Perks put through the moratorium on Parkdale! I mean, Gelato Pizza and other independent business' are so dangerous and corrupt for this neighborhood, right?
Gabe / November 19, 2012 at 09:02 pm
mobo / November 19, 2012 at 09:21 pm
" Real Italian Pizza and Real Italian Gelato" huh?
The only thing real Italian is Giuseppes name. Lets start with the gelato. I have never had a more synthetic tasting pistacchio gelato ! Ever! Anywhere! There is fresh, authentic gelato REALLY close by. Real close.
I had a pepperoni slice and my friend had the hamburger slice( or something like that.) My pepperoni pizza reminded me of Pizza Pizza / 2-4-1 / Ginos etc.( dough,sauce, cheese) The hamburger pizza tasted like my slice with soggy sloppy joes on top. Not pleasant. Not very good. And not really Italian. Way better pizza options in the westend.
However it should do good biz on weekend nights after bars let out . For late nite munchies.
mobo / November 19, 2012 at 09:23 pm
OH ya. And whats with the wierd name?
Karina replying to a comment from mobo / November 20, 2012 at 01:16 am
HI I think that we must respect people who try to make a living and especially know something about food.
do we want to talk about names??? how about MOBO what kind of name is that??
and if you know a place that makes better pistacchio pleeeaseee let me know.
BeerForBreakfast / November 20, 2012 at 09:26 am
Ed's Real Scoop has thd best Pistacchio Gelato I have ever tried also in Leslieville
mike in parkdale / November 20, 2012 at 10:12 am
for my dollar, the best pizza in Parkdale is Amico's. I don't see this place taking any of their customers.
bob / November 20, 2012 at 11:13 am
I think I need to stop reading any comments on BlogTo. People can't wait to make stupid comments. It's a new business... there will be wrinkles to iron out, and for gods sake, try the food before making comments on where to get more "authentic". Geez.
gmo / November 20, 2012 at 11:50 am
umm... anyone else have a problem with them putting up an old British Petroleum sign in their shop?! WTF!?!
SAM / November 20, 2012 at 12:15 pm
Anyone have any info on what the 3 different vegan slice options are?
Sasha replying to a comment from gmo / November 20, 2012 at 02:15 pm
No problem with the BP sign here. Petroleum is fine - I use petroleum jelly everyday
ParkdaleGirl / November 20, 2012 at 02:41 pm
Not sure what this guy was thinking, moving in right next door to the most amazing gelato ever?!? Borel Gelato Company ( makes everything in house, from scratch using the best quality ingredients and is run by amazing people who care about the environment and the neighbourhood.
If this place was just about high-quality pizza, that would be awesome, but it's not. I won't be giving my money to someone who tries to 'compete' with local small businesses with lesser products, and I'm sure many people in the area feel the same way.

Maybe Boreal should start making pizza and just send this guy back from wherever he came from.
Giuseppe / November 20, 2012 at 03:57 pm
A lot of great feedback and its nice to know some people appreciate the quality of our menu. I probably can't please all the people of parkdale but I will try my best. Someone said about going back to wherever I came from, but considering I was born a few minutes from here ( St. Joseph Hospital ), I think some people don't know me or what the company is about. It's not a chain, this is the first store open barely two weeks so please get the facts right. I would love to sit down with each customer and tell them what we are all about over a complementary slice of pizza, and hope they can see what it is we do. We gave away free whole pizzas for two days to anyone who walked in and about 800 people did just that. Finally I respect all businesses and hope people to do the same. More of a good thing in a general area equals a greater variety of choices and will inevitably attract more customers to the area.
L. / November 20, 2012 at 05:43 pm
Really??? interesting.. cause I heard that Boreal doesn't pay their 'smokin hott' staff.
me / November 20, 2012 at 08:38 pm
for the people complaining about the location being too near to boreal gelato (and not about the quality of the product), i recommend reading up on (hotelling's model of) spatial competition, game theory, and/or nash equilibrium.

there are numerous examples of small businesses around toronto opening near each other (e.g., papa ceo's & cora's only have 1 or 2 storefronts in between them, both selling pizza).

something to watch for starters:
MC / November 20, 2012 at 08:56 pm
We live in the Parkdale area and have anxiously awaiting the opening of Gelato Pizza. We walked in a few weeks ago and they were giving away free pizzas AND gelato to anyone who walked in. I think that was a great gesture to show their delicious food to the area. We had a chance to talk with the owner who's passionate about his food. With regards to the gelato, just because it isn't made in house doesn't detract from the quality or variety of flavours. This is the real deal, authentic gelato made with premium ingredients the old Italian way - I can't wait until the summer when they'll have 32 fantastic flavours! Haters gonna hate. For the rest of you, try Gelato Pizza and come to your own conclusions.
Chris / November 21, 2012 at 10:24 am
Went here last night as I thought the pizza looked amazing in the pictures. It sadly didn't taste as good as it looked. The pizza is comparable to pizza pizza or a thicker pizzaiolo. It was decent but by no means worth my hour trek to check out the place. On the other hand, I went next door to Borel Gelato Company to see what all the buzz was about and wow. I had the apple sorbet and it tasted like an apple pie my ma used to make. My friend had the Tiramisu Gelato and said it was the best he'd ever had. I think Gelato Pizza is going to have a lot of trouble on the Gelato front, but they'll do fine with the pizza.
Jane Manning / November 21, 2012 at 06:29 pm
Robyn please correct your typo above: the gelato is sourced from .Gelato Simply Italian NOT G for Gelato!
mr. brown / November 22, 2012 at 12:32 am
There is no way 800 people got free pizza there last week.
I live right across the street and can see the place from my window. It was empty most of the time. Even with free pizza.
Karina / November 30, 2012 at 12:59 am
Hei mr Brown
Don't you have tv???
Mr. Brown replying to a comment from Karina / November 30, 2012 at 10:44 am
Karina, I would never watch tv.
It's petty stupid and full of ads.
I have a social life, a girlfriend and a band.
No need to be dumbed down by societys main stream.
Ralph from Maple / November 30, 2012 at 09:22 pm
So not sure what's wrong with opening a
Business close to others that may serve
the foods or services
It's not if it is a big player they are both a
mom and pop shop
One should not attack someone else only
because the other establishment may have a
better product and service
Pizza is out of this world (Rocco) is my favorite
the gelato ( not ice cream ) is also great
Keep up the good work
I will for sure come in at least once a week
for dinner and gelato
So that everybody in the family will have something to enjoy
Linda S. / December 1, 2012 at 12:04 am
Had the best experience when visiting this great new establishment. The staff and the owner Giuseppe were friendly, fast and very efficient. The menu offers a full variety of flavours that will please everyone's taste buds. The pizza was very tasteful and the crust was perfect!! The toppings was abundance and of course I always have move for dessert. I enjoyed pistachio and bacio ice cream!! The ice cream is very good!! Definitely will be returning with my family to enjoy our dinners.
Just wanted to also add that I find the comments about this restaurant opening next door to an ice shop quite disturbing because they are not the same concept and Toronto is such a big city that everybody should have a fair opportunity. Some people should really keep their comments to themselves !!
Karina / December 1, 2012 at 01:55 am
Hi Mr. Brown
Happy to hear about your social life but you probably didn't have any during that week cause you said that "the place was empty most of the time"
So that means you had nothing better to do then watch the opposite side of the street.
Anyway I have been in Gelato Pizza only once and I loved it!!!
So please Not more replay about me and Let's all say FORZA GIUSEPPE
you are doing a great job.
Ralph / December 3, 2012 at 12:24 pm
Linda S / December 4, 2012 at 12:22 pm
Forza Giuseppe
Mart replying to a comment from jameson / December 5, 2012 at 08:54 am
Albany pizza rocks
Mart replying to a comment from Mr. Brown / December 5, 2012 at 09:05 am
Ya mr. Brown keep on keepin' that intellect up on the edgy blogto comment boards!
R. replying to a comment from SAM / December 15, 2012 at 01:34 pm
Hey @Sam,

Here are the vegan pizzas:

ISOLA - olive oil, baby spinach, cherry tomatoes, artichoke hearts
BIANCA - extra virgin olive oil, rosemary, sea salt
LYNN Z LOW N - fresh tomato sauce, fresh garlic, fresh basil, dried black olives, eggplant molise

Vy / January 5, 2013 at 12:16 pm
My mom ordered a large pizza last night from Gelato... it was way too salty!! To think people actually enjoy salty pizza boggles my mind! Would never go back!
DB / January 29, 2013 at 10:51 pm
I love this place! Their pizza is very tasty. I wouldn't really say it's "authentic Italian pizza," (it's no Libretto) but they use fresh ingredients, homemade sauce & dough, and you can tell. They've got great veggie pizzas. Best dipping sauce. And a ton of drink options (san pal, glass bottle pops, plus the regulars).

And, come on, gotta give them credit for the guts to name this place "Gelato Pizza" in one of the most scrutinized neighbourhoods in Toronto. Lighten up about it. At least they stand out. Just try it!!
Justin / February 3, 2013 at 04:27 pm
I wanted to get a slice of pizza last friday after work and gelato pizza was on my way plus it looked kind of cool on the outside. I walked in and ordered a slice of the brad pitt and a slice of the deluxe and I have to say it was the worst pizza I have ever tasted. They have like 2 employees there, one older guy that makes pizza and this hot girl at the front that served me. When I tasted the deluxe first, it was stil cold. The dough was like a board and the cheese was hard, not stringy and melted. Their cheese pizza only has monzerella on it which is really bland too. My girlfriend also went and ordered the hamburger and said it was a waste of money and that the crust was thick and chewy and that it didn't have enough sauce. To get real authentic pizza, I guess you have to go to to a nice restaurant. Even pizza nova works. I think they use frozen ingredients on their pizzas cause everything is pretty saugy and tastes a day old, especially on the deluxe. As far as the Gelato goes, I haven't tried it, but I probably won't be back.
Katherine / February 6, 2013 at 05:19 pm
This pizza is so thick and doughy. After I ate it, I wished I had of just had pizza nova or something else. Its kind of cold and the slices are expensive. What a waste of money. Critics always hype about restaurants, probably because owners of restaurants pay them to get good critique and then pretend like they had nothing to do with it. ug I wish I could have my money back. I bought two slices and a sauce to go. The cheeseburger and the Brad pitt.
Darlene R / February 11, 2013 at 05:27 pm
Not great, not worth a trip out of your way
Sarah / February 17, 2013 at 08:52 pm
I just ordered a large personalized pizza from them and it was abso-fricking-lutely DELICIOUS. The best pizza from a delivery place that I have had in Toronto. Pizzaiolo comes a distant second. I ordered a thin crust pizza with roasted red peppers, pepperoni, feta cheese, green olives and fresh garlic and it was really, really great. I was in the mood for something salty and flavourful, and this totally fit the bill. I've now found my new pizza delivery place!
st louis pizza and wings fenton / February 23, 2013 at 06:11 am
Pizza is the main focus, with long-established, specialty and custom pizzas presented in an assortment of crust styles and toppings.
Thoughtful, practical, sustainable presents may require a little more creativity on your part, but they may also be thoroughly
enjoyed for their uniqueness and earth-friendly origins.
If you have pizza in India at a reputed brand outlet and have it
in another country in the same brand, you will positively
find a difference in the toppings.
Laura / March 2, 2013 at 07:54 am
The gluten free crust being developed the owner himself intrigued me. I would LOVE it if he could come up with an authentic Italian chewy gluten free crust. Please please please!!!
Danny / March 11, 2013 at 08:27 pm
Stopped in at Gelato Pizza let me tell you it's amazing and to have gelato after my slice just made it perfect. I have read some comments on here and haters will be haters... Can't please everyone especially the people who have no clue what quality food tastes like....great name for the place it stands out and great homemade dip!!! Can't go wrong there... Keep it up Gelato Pizza we shall see u soon...
Chris / April 27, 2013 at 01:01 pm
Just noticed that he is opening a 2nd location on Atlas Ave, a few blocks north of St. Clair West! Renovation of an old corner store is underway and there is a sign in the window advertising it as coming soon. I can't wait!
mike in parkdale replying to a comment from Vy / June 16, 2013 at 06:03 pm
"...ordered a large pizza last night from Gelato... it was way too salty!! To think people actually enjoy salty pizza boggles my mind!"

prepare to have your mind boggled - I'm about to order the Sapore Di Sale (aka Taste of Salt) pizza from Gelato because they make one of the best salty pizzas out there. I actually LOVE anchovies on my pizza, along with black olives, feta, capers, onions.... and Gelato makes a really good salty pizza. In fact, I could call any pizza shop in the area right now, but I'm calling Gelato just because the sapore di mare was so damn good.

And I still order from Amico's when the girl is home and we're ordering something more traditional.
Mr. Brown / June 28, 2014 at 12:01 am
Looks like they are closing. Out of business. Not surprising. They serve chapmans ice cream anyway, not gelato. I have seen the staff unloading the large chapmans containers into their gelato freezer. Guess that's what happens when you lie to people.

Add a Comment


Find a restaurant

Or use the options below to assist you in locating a restaurant in Toronto.

Search Results

Please select criteria from the dropdown menus above to start your search.


Recent Reviews

Refine the list using the categories below:

Other Cities: Montreal