City
Violence on Toronto streets for G20
Yesterday's G20 riots in Toronto were chaotic, to say the least. "I can't believe I was just tear gassed," Nadim Fetaih, 22, tells me after being pepper sprayed by riot police at Queen's Park. "This is Toronto. This is Canada. This shouldn't be happening." Nadim, his sister, Sherbuk, 27, were both pepper sprayed during the standoff at College and University, where hundreds of protesters were cornered off by hundreds of riot police, some on horseback, all in full riot gear.
Some two hours earlier a peaceful G20 protest turned into a riot.
The thousand-strong protest that in Queen's Park yesterday quickly degraded when the notorious anarchists, using the black bloc technique of absolute destruction, congregated and discarded their black clothing.
It is a day that will go down in Toronto's history. A day where over 400 people were arrested in Toronto's streets.
I followed the G20 protests yesterday from the peaceful, women-led beginnings in the early afternoon onwards until 11 p.m. I walked alongside thousands of protesters from myriad groups down University Ave. I listened as they chanted in unison, "Tell me what democracy looks like. This is what democracy looks like!" And then I ran behind the reported black bloc as they terrorized Queen and Yonge streets, smashing storefront windows and CBC vans.
I watched as they lit two police cars on fire at King and Bay Street. I questioned where police were during these two hours of all-out demolition. I watched riot police squeeze us into small sections at Queen's Park and physically beat others that wouldn't comply. (This was the case for Matthew King, 23, who after talking with me, was chased by plain clothed officers and hit with batons after he wouldn't pick up his pop can.) I watched when rubber bullets (or bean bags) were shot into crowds. And I witnessed when small, individual canisters of mace were deployed, albeit not the reported tear gas. I watched as horseback police officers ran at the crowd in "stun squads." I watched when Toronto became saddened by what it was watching.
And I listened as Wayne Adam, 45, said: "It's hard to believe this is Toronto."
I recently published a feature article in Spacing magazine's spring issue about the past decade of protests in Toronto. How far Toronto has come from the notorious OCAP protests in 2000 at Queen's Park, where Molotov cocktails were hurled. To the peaceful, thousands-strong anti-prorogue protest this past January at Dundas Square. I was wrong that Toronto is finished with its violent, police-clashing protests. At least a few aren't finished, anyway.
But let me clear the air. This wasn't all of Toronto. As I watched, followed, and, at times, hid from yesterday's protests, the destruction was done by approximately 60 members using black bloc tactics, donning full black get-ups, including black bandannas covering their faces. And they were violent towards anyone taking photos, especially members of the press. They would run, brandishing bricks and large sticks, smashing windows - first Starbucks and banks, and then any storefront along Yonge Street, including American Apparel, McDonald's, Urban Outfitters and Bell.
They spray painted walls with slogans like, "Bomb the banks." They surrounded and jumped on top of police cars before lighting them on fire. (Four cop cruisers in total.) And after making it back to Queen's Park, after they trashed another unmarked police van, they shed their black clothing and disappeared into the rest of the protesters.
All this time, it should be noted, there was no police presence. None. For about two hours from around 2 p.m. until 4 p.m. police didn't stop the anarchists running wild through Toronto's streets. It wasn't until protesters got back to Queen's Park that security forces started to cut off the protesters on all sides by slowly advancing riot police. By this time, however, the destruction-wreaking individuals were in plain clothes.
At this point, the riot police were merciless. If you came about five feet to the wall of police - all with riot helmets, batons and shields - they would yell at you to get back. If you didn't, which I witnessed on at least six occasions, they would swoop in on you, strike you with their batons, and pull you behind police lines. These take-downs are sudden and violent things to witness. You wouldn't see the individuals again.
This all occurred in the supposed protest-permitted area of Queen's Park, delegated specifically for protests, for freedom of speech. This wasn't the case. Eventually the police were able to move the protesters up to the Ontario Legislature building, dividing them into four sections. From there, they had horses run at protesters to disperse them. On the flanks, police, typically lined three deep, would stand their ground, occasionally beating their batons off their shields. This continued for about three hours until 8 p.m. when I left for another breaking protest.
I continued following the protests then on Yonge Street. Seemingly ad hoc, over 1,000 protesters made their way to the G20 fence, chanting, "Whose streets? Our streets!" and "To the fence!" Of no specific individual group, they moved quickly and peacefully until they made it to the fence at Bay St. There, police once again surrounded the protesters on King St., between Bay and York streets. Some more rubber bullets were fired, but protesters had a sit-in until the officers on Bay Street retreated, letting them through.
The protesters at this point continued to wind through the financial district until a smaller group made it to the Novotel hotel, where another confrontation took place. At this point, the protesters had lessened to around 150. The streets, as I left them, were riddled with roaming police officers in full riot gear.
It all started as a peaceful rally in Queen's Park where even children were in attendance. Thousands marched, chanting as they snaked down University to Queen St., waving their placards. And then chaos broke out when splinter groups using black bloc tactics wreaked havoc on the city. Four cop cars destroyed. A plethora of storefront windows smashed. Banks graffiti-laden with anti-capitalism slogans. Some 400 arrested. And, there's more to come today.
Writing by Ryan Bolton. Images by Louis Tam, Josh Sam and Duke 360.


Discussion
77 Comments
Sort By Oldest First / Newest First
Subscribe
WTF were you doing there in the first place?
The best idea would have been to have some Gentian violet on hand to spray on the Black block's f'ing faces as they tried to change so they could be easily identified by the cops. That purple shit doesn't come off for days no matter what you do.
It's incredible that nobody thought it suspicious that dozens of black clad assholes came into the crowd and suddenly started shedding their clothes.
The next G20 could easily squash these jackasses with a little foresight and planning.
http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0156729/
I was reminded of it instantly when I saw the images.
When the criminal activity was happenning, I asked myself "Where are the police?". In retrospect, the police succeeded in their priority of protecting the fence and I can appreciate the massive challenge in front of police. I compliment and thank the police for protecting our rights.
Going forward, as a Canadian, I support payment to businesses who lost money yesterday as a result of the riots. Also, I request new and tougher laws against the violent activities.
You make it sound like the police were wrong to yell "back" at anyone who came within five feet of the line. Why wouldn't you just get back? They weren't swarmng and assulting protesters, they were defending their position!
when you aren't actually protesting anything and are only there to act violent for the sake of chaos, that's basically terrorism.
also, in today's world with our current tech, why couldn't they save the absurd amounts of money spent, and hold this as a video conference ? would seem like the sensible and prudent thing to do. the organizers should be held partially responsible for this circle jerk as well.
It's understandable that someone at Queen's Park may have thought that that was the beginning of the violence, and at that location it probably was, but the looting and vandalism started much earlier (while the peaceful parade was still marching up Spadina, in fact).
After about 20 minutes at Peter Street the group decided to abandon that location and headed east.
For anyone who lives in Toronto, you should be sooo pissed off the Stephen Harper held this summit in Toronto. Ironiclly there are no Conservatives elected in Toronto. No constituates to listen to or report to. Mr. Harper hates this city that's why he didn't take the summit to his own riding of Calgary.
Stay safe to comrades!! Let's really talk about the issues
That's sorta the job of the the thousands of police being paid lots o money to be here.
Also, documentation--nothing wrong with that; sometimes even helpful. Or do you only read news with no images?
Remember Nelson Mandela was labelled a terrorist for 30+ years, perception is everything in this debate
It's also done a great job of drowning out the message of the peaceful groups (seen any media coverage of their messages over the last 24 hours?) and justifies future events will develop in exactly the same way and the average Canadian will care even less about the message of the protests.
You are so fu*king wrong.
Those as*holes were just getting their kicks trashing the place.
Nothing more, nothing less.
Generally speaking though I will say the police maintained a certain politeness as far as I was concerned. I found that when they were shouting at us to move, or yelling directions, if you asked a question about where you would be able to go in order to get home, they would answer you as best they could and told us to stay safe. I have no qualms against the police for confusing the hell out of everyone in stand-offs because the situation never should have happened in the first place.
One of the things that really pissed me off - WHAT THE HELL ARE ALL THESE PEOPLE DOING OUT WITH THEIR CELL PHONES AND DIGI CAMS? I didn't get home until at least 7pm and when I turned on the news there were images of about 4 dozen police in riot gear and on horseback, just sort of pushing back random morons with their iPhones? The only people left on the street when it was dark outside were photographers and random people who wanted to be included. Honestly, GO HOME. Protesting and looting and rioting was over, they were just there to take pictures of police. The police had more shit to do last night than follow around your lame asses trying to take pictures of them to upload to your facebook or flickr. No one cares that you were there, no one wants to see your blurry piece of shit cell phone pictures. Go home when everything is over, you're just making things worse and distracting away from the overall damage. Like I said, the police had better things to do last night than pushing back losers with their cell phones trying to get too close to a four-hours-earlier riot zone.
Keep your eyes on the ball, people.
"we don't take the weekend off unlike other channels"
"everyone is on twitter saying CP24 is the almost like being there"
gimme a break.
Harper is an out of touch fool if he thinks downtown TO was a good place.
If you thought the black bloc was bad - just imagine if they got closer to Royal Bank Plaza /TD Centre /Union Station /etc...
Hmm. Not according to media reports:
http://www.thestar.com/news/gta/torontog20summit/article/829238--tear-gas-fired-in-downtown-rampage
"Tear gas was used for the first time in Toronto's history, at Queen and Peter Sts., Toronto Police Chief Bill Blair said."
Wiki article you reference doesn't state that tear gas was used.
NYC has taken a stand!
The people of Toronto should demand the same.
What is the protest about?
Goabalism?
WTF?
Maybe an even better question would be, “Why were you still there after the Black Bloc tactics started to happen?” People should have said to themselves that it might be time to go back home because I don’t want to get mixed up with these people. The fact that you were even there only helped the Black Blocers as it gave them more people to hide behind after they changed clothes. You are as much to blame as anyone.
People complain about the way the Police acted… Tell me, if I put 2 people beside each other, would you be able to tell who was going to become violent? If you were down there, Police had to treat you like they would anyone else. They were doing things the way they were to protect themselves as much as others because there is no telling who could have been be carrying what (be it a knife, gun or a bomb). If a Police Officer tells you to get back, you know what… You get back.
I also laugh at the comments from the people coming out of the Detention Center. “We were in cages, only one bench, only feed us a sandwich in so many hours, only gave us 1 water to drink, it was dirty” and etc. Did you think it was going to be 5 Star accommodations? Remember, everyone is complaining about how much the G20 cost. Think how much more it would have cost if they fixed up the Detention Center for you.
I think the funniest thing that I saw happen out of all of this was watching a lady in a dress who was clearly out downtown for dinner getting loaded into a TTC bus to be taken to the Detention Center. She and her husband must have thought it was a good idea to go downtown for dinner in the middle of all this? O.O? But that leads back to, what I said before, the Police had to treat you like everyone else, because who it to say that lady wasn’t a Black Blocer trying a new tatic of looking “innocent” and then pulling something off, like a bomb out of her nice pink leather purse.
Oh Police, you are so mean.
The Black Bloc all looked as if they were Squeegee Kids, or kids that sit on the corner asking for spare change instead of going out and getting a job. What were they even protesting about?
It is funny that in a Multicultural city such as Toronto is, that 95% if not more of the protesters were White. Our city is a Multicultural one because people have left there own countries to come here for a better life. A lot of these protesters should realize that. There are a lot of multicultural people out there that are thankful for what they have found in Canada and Toronto.
I was working in a building one block from the traffic zone. The protesters were just trying to move past us; next to no one did anything to our property. King and Bay, where it got hairy, was the traffic zone.
If it were at the Ex, accordingly, the zones would have shifted south, and Queen would have been ignored, and most of the trouble would have been near Front. Likely, less damage overall because of the intense security measures the core took/would take. The Ex is better contained and would have been cheaper overall=more money for police and security.
Miller was right; Harper was an inconsiderate jerk who screwed us all, as people, and now refuses to clean up this mess.
The black clad black sheep march on our street and destroy our city fer equality in the workplace, the classes. Yet they destroy businesses and livelyhoods knowing our government will not give a penny to the owners.
It all goes through insurance. And insurance is the most shady part of our economy.
It amazes me how people can ruin an idea that stemmed from their last braincell. An idea destroyed altogether by sabotaging what they hate most about the economy, while hiding behind the people they claim to be fighting fer.
If other protestors witnessed this, and let alone did nothing, they should have walked away. It's not worth it. It's not worth putting yourself in line with them, even if you believe you have a legitimate arguement. I've heard countless people throw around the word free speech, but what about free-will?
This weekend the world saw a bunch of misguided children, left into the hands of older non-responsible role models. It was like some kind of new fad, the punx lost warped tour so this is their new venue.
When journalists interview them to know what they are protesting for, they don't have a clue what they are talking about, screaming phrases like "we are denunciating worldwide economy" and "f_ck capitalism", while wearing branded hoods and t-shirts...
Punks who are crying that they have been brutalized are the first to provoke the police. Anyone knows that if you want to get into troubles, this is the place to be, but don't complained afterward. When you see the photos of protesters with their fingers in the face of police officers, I have to admit that they are very tolerant.
I think that the population should take justice in their hand, as these young men between 15 and 30 years old are the ones who are destroying bus shelters, trains, trams, buses and draw graffiti all over. We are the ones working our asses off, day in, day out, paying taxes for these rats who are creating a very bad climate and environment for the rest of us, like the punks that they are.
Do we really have to tolerate them? How could we eradicate these nuisance once and for all?
Every person that was in that group would have had to of been stopped, not just 100 bubble gum punks. Everyone one of those peaceful protesters that were walking with in that group that contained the Black Blocers, every News Report and Curious Joe/Joan who was holding a camera phone, would have also had to of been stopped. Who is to say that people not wearing Black were going to stay peaceful if the Police went in to stop what was going on.
Think about it. It isn't safe for themselves to just to go rushing in and probably wouldn't have been safe for the peaceful protesters in the group either if they had. You think the Black Blocers would just have laid down on the ground? They could have caused harm to the peaceful protesters by trying to break free from the Police.
There is many factors that Police have to look at. Anyone of those people could have been carrying a gun and we all know what happens then, innocent people get killed because someone pulls a gun out and starts shooting in the middle of a crowd. Ask Jane Creba's family whose daughter died on the street for that exact same reason not to far away from where all this was happening.
People complain so much about how Police handled things; well I think they handled themselves quite well. If you're told to move back then you move back, if you don't then you are starting a confrontation and the Police were stopping it before it became worse or before the person pulled out a gun.
You can say there was no gun, but would you know that for sure if you were there? It was the Black Blocers that forced the Polices hands to become fists. The Black Blocers raised the level from Peaceful to Violent and Destructive, the Police only followed suit to match them and the peaceful protester and passerby got caught in the middle.
Can someone please explain the reasons behind all this? I've been googling, and still haven't found anything about why people are upset, aside from the $1.2B spent on security, which is ridiculous, but no reason to be stupid like this.
If you don't want to get a job, then go live in a tree.
Yeah there was some legitimacy going on but only within the the thoughts of some. A majority of those at the protest were under the age of what looked to be twenty. And those protesters aren't even there to protest. They are just there to destroy(or watch destruction) because they do not want to live in a corporate world.
If you are refferring to the fact that detainees were "mistrested", or that protested experienced a form of mild privacy infringement, take a little look at the situation.
Behind those gates were some of the most powerful people in the world(weather you agree with their use of power, that is what they are). Without security their lives were at risk. Now I don't agree with the money spent because clearly there could have been other ways, but it was what it was. Are the police and security supposed to say "hey, yeah, you teenagers, go right in and lecture men and women your senior with life lessons." ?
The bottom line is these protests create an obscure view of the protesters fer a valid reason. We all know g20 brings rioting, and we know some will try to protest peacefully. But why bother? Your word is not getting across to anyone amidst destruction. Hold a rally elsewhere. Show the people that you as well have common courtesy. That if the leaders can do it, so can the people.
There were only ever a few wise words spoken of Anarchism, but alike every other faction of the political spectrum, it has been misconstrued to this.
So before anyone claims innocence, or privacy infringement, explore other options.
If one can learn to methodize their situation and the situation's of those they care about , one can learn to live outside of the world that they have grown to hate. If one can learn to manipulate the situation within the confines of politics and law, one can properly learn to live outside of the institute, and the dogmas they feel have been brought upon them. Though if they choose not to observe, maintain and rise above, fer the simple fact that they don't believe they need to observe and maintain, the people can begin to question their passion. And the people will begin to realize that the protestor's voice is no longer legitimate. That the voice only carries a brain to see what is wrong, but not how to fix things.
http://lecanadian.com/2010/07/02/black-bloc-vandals-in-toronto-were-undercover-police-says-canadian-research-centre/
www.torontotourismboard.com