Saturday, May 26, 2012Mostly Cloudy 22°C
City

First Canadian Place gets a new skin

Posted by Matthew Harris / June 6, 2010

First Canadian PlaceWhen First Canadian Place was built in 1975, it was covered in blinding white Carrera marble. Over the years, the city's poor air quality has taken its toll. Rather than white, the building now appears to be a mottled grey colour. Even worse, some of the marble slabs have begun to loosen. In 2007, a slab from the building fell on the building's mezzanine level. Luckily nobody was hurt but clearly something needed to be done.

Possible Panels for FCP RecladdingBrookfield Properties, the current owner of the tower, has decided to replace the marble cladding. Starting from the top and working down, each one of the marble slabs on the faces of the building will be replaced with textured spandrel glass - essentially opaque panes of glass that will feature a triangular pattern to create visual depth.

An example of the possible choices and the condition of the existing marble are shown above. The recessed corners of the building, however, will be replaced with bronze sections to give the building a more vertical emphasis. A video of the before and after and a complete description of the process can be found here.

First Canadian Place Recladding RenderingThe good news is that after months of prep work, the actual recladding has begun. You might have noticed that the two-storeys worth of scaffolding has been moved to the top of the building. It's connected to the elevator which moves construction workers and materials to the top floor. The scaffolding will move down the building every two weeks, after the completion of two floors. To complete all of the building's 72 stories will take until the end of next year.
Detail of two-storey scaffolds on FCPThere are some people who are disappointed by the particular choice of recladding material. The AON Center in Chicago was built around the same time as First Canadian Place, and was similarly clad in Carrera marble. When pieces of that cladding started to fall off, that building was reclad in granite, rather than fritted glass. Why isn't FCP being reclad in a similar material? As the city`s tallest office tower and a major landmark, it should be visually impressive, and the concern is that the fritted glass will not be as striking.

And what is being done with all of the marble slabs? Brookfield Properties has not given full details, but you can inquire about snagging a slab or two. As part of the LEED certification process, the renovation gets points for repurposing the leftover marble. Environmentally sustainable projects, art installations and charities will likely be favored. If you have an appropriate project, it may be a great way to reuse a piece of Toronto`s history.

All images by Matthew Harris except for rendering of reclad FCP from Brookfield Properties.

Discussion

14 Comments

anon / June 6, 2010 at 12:02 pm
user-pic
nice post. I like the fact that the building now will be more reflective personally.
Darcy McGee / June 6, 2010 at 12:26 pm
user-pic
First Canadian Place has such horrible indoor air quality, I can't imagine it every passing any kind of LEED certification at all.
Johnny Leed / June 6, 2010 at 01:17 pm
user-pic
Nice to see the renos on FCP.
LEED is a crock of shit. Its a cash grab and total bullshit.............
matt / June 6, 2010 at 03:16 pm
user-pic
Funny, I could swear I read this article in The Globe a day or two ago...
Bethany replying to a comment from matt / June 6, 2010 at 04:25 pm
user-pic
The first place I remember seeing this story was at OpenFile, actully, a few weeks ago: http://openfile.ca/toronto-file/first-canadian-place-losing-its-marble
Torontonian / June 6, 2010 at 05:48 pm
user-pic
I remember the building under construction and the second shipment of marble was slightly off the colour of the lower floors. For a day or two, we were able to see the contrasting "stripe" on a part of one wall.

Several months later, the next shipment of marble cladding was able to be installed. This time the colour matched.
Jonathan replying to a comment from Bethany / June 6, 2010 at 07:31 pm
user-pic
It's been on urbantoronto for 3 years.
bob / June 6, 2010 at 08:58 pm
user-pic
Yeah... this story is ancient. How long has construction been happening there for?

But why is construction happening on so many other buildings in the Financial District?
bob / June 6, 2010 at 09:02 pm
user-pic
By the way... there are numerous complaints about how Toronto's Financial Distict resembles other cities' too much (although I don't think it does at all), why would it be a mistake to use a different material as the Aon Center? I think that this looks better anyway, and brings a really unique touch to a plain building.

On another note, what is happening with the podium? I hope the marble stays there, or it would be interesting to see the marble with a glass layer on top of it.
seanm replying to a comment from bob / June 6, 2010 at 10:11 pm
user-pic
A lot of the office buildings in the Financial District are approaching 40-50 years old, and need the first wave of repairs and revitalization. Half a century in our harsh climate takes a huge toll on a building.

On the note of touch ups, Commerce Court West really needs a good cleaning and polish of its stainless steel. It's looking a little messy these days.
Darcy McGee replying to a comment from Johnny Leed / June 7, 2010 at 02:17 am
user-pic
While I'm not a LEED fan, it's overly melodramatic to suggest that "LEED is a crock of shit."

The LEED standard has gaps problems, to be sure, but it is the standard that's gaining traction. The best thing we as a society can do now is to FIX the standard. That's going to be a lot easier than implementing a new standard in competition with the existing one.
Sean / June 7, 2010 at 02:50 pm
user-pic
They should have replaced the marble with solar panels and used the power for a nice outdood LED display or lighting up the lobby.
gymguy30 / September 23, 2010 at 01:53 pm
user-pic
First Canadian Place was built in 1975, at the time, it was the tallest building on Earth that wasn't in Chicago or New York City, it remained in the top 10 in the world until the mid 90s but for some reason Canada hasn't built anything taller since then and it's now barely in the top 50 in the world while remaining the tallest in Canada, we should build a taller one somewhere.
Daniel / October 13, 2010 at 07:40 pm
user-pic
http://www.theglobeandmail.com/video/first-canadian-place-makeover/article1593123/

This link from the Globe & Mail is great to watch. We can now see the lit BMO logo at the top of the building. I must say it looks awesome and I love the fact that they're making the corners of the building black with creates an great contrast to brighten the sides of the building and giving it a more modern look. Can't wait to see it completed.

Add a Comment

Other Cities: VancouverMontreal