Libertarian Public House

Libertarian Public House

Libertarian Public House, formerly Black Irish Whiskey Bar & Oyster Saloon, is a working man's canteen situated at the corner of Queen and Sherbourne. 

Partners Joey McGuirk, Kevin Wailoo, George Skopelanos, and chef Danvil Daley (formerly of Triple A ) clearly dig the tough neighbourhood vibe - the bar channels the notorious Five Points of 1800s New York for inspiration.

Black Irish Oyster Saloon Toronto

The address was most recently a Popeye's; before that, a Coffee Time. In its current incarnation, the comfortably rough-hewn 80-seat room consists of retro booths recast from the set of Bomb Girls , a skeletal upright piano and neon sIgns over a well-stocked bar.

Black Irish Oyster Saloon Toronto

The menu covers the types of dishes you'd expect of any pub - wings, nachos, quesadillas and curries - though you'll also find a serious selection of seafood. Lobster finds its way onto poutine ($15), nachos ($20) and housemade potato gnocchi ($24) that are pan-fried, then baked to puff up, before being tossed with fresh peas and roasted red peppers in a luscious brandy cream sauce.

Black Irish Toronto

Seafood starters include clam chowder ($8), shrimp cocktails ($12), steamed mussels ($12), and cajun grilled calamari ($12), while oysters from Rodney's sit in a bathtub of ice in easy reach behind the bar.

Black Irish Oyster Saloon Toronto

From 2pm to 7pm daily (except Saturdays) half shells are priced at $1.25, twenty-five cents of which are donated to Fuck Cancer, a charitable promo aptly dubbed "shuck & fuck".

Black Irish Oyster Saloon Toronto

The drinks list is illustrated and features straight-up classics; Tom Collins ($6.50), Singapore Sling ($7.50), and Old Fashioned ($7.50) cocktails. On draught there are 15 beers - mainly national brands, plus some more interesting taps like Steigl ($7) and the 8.5% Delirium ($7.50).

Black Irish Oyster Saloon Toronto

The kitchen is open daily from noon until midnight - except on Sundays, when the brunch menu (which features a lobster benny, BTW) starts at 11am.

Black Irish Oyster Saloon Toronto

Photos by

Jesse Milns

Latest Reviews


Sofra Istanbul

The BarBQ Factory

Fearless Meat

The Rose Rice Noodles and Snacks

The Loop Creamery