todmorden mills baking

Baking Over Coals at Todmorden Mills

You know what really says Super Bowl Sunday in my books? Baking Victorian sweets in a 19th century kitchen at Todmorden Mills Heritage Museum.

Granted, even after three and a half hours of manual labour we still finished well before the game. But being neither a football fan nor the kind of girl who makes seven-layer bean dip for the boys, I had no reason not to check this unique experience out.

todmorden mills

The Todmorden museum is a complex of several historic buildings that were once part of the small industrial community. The old school bake-a-thon was part of their Cast Iron Chef Historic Cooking Series, and along with five other people who enjoy cooking without the modern luxuries of electricity and running water, we baked four different Victorian era recipes.

todmorden mills

After having a hot tea and snacking on a heart-shaped custard chocolate cake, I grabbed what ended up being the easiest of the recipes - something called "Kisses." But not the kind that Hershey's makes; these were rather plain cakey bite-sized cookies that I tossed in confectioner's sugar. The recipe was from The Canadian Home Cook Book, circa 1877.

Before baking the last batch we experimented with thumbprint cookies by adding some home-grown and made crab apple and lemon thyme jelly. These were tasty.

todmorden mills toronto

We also made a fudge-like confection called simply "Chocolate Caramel Walnut" from Walter Baker & Co., circa 1909.

todmorden mills

The "Chocolate Puffs" were from The First Presbyterian Cook Book, circa 1873. They were meringue-based sweets that are reminiscent of macarons.

todmorden mills

The last thing that was made were "Almond Chocolate Creams", also from Walter Baker & Co. These were essentially two different iterations of pure sugar, and would satisfy any sweet tooth in one bite-sized piece.

todmorden mills

This was also the lengthiest and most involved recipe. Our hosts informed us that because of the labour and large amount of costly sugar needed, in the 19th century these would be a treat that you would only make when visiting someone of importance or wealth.

todmorden mills

While things were cooking in the fireplace and Dutch oven, I had a chance to look around the miller's home that we were cooking in.

todmorden mills

And then, bonus, we got to split up all the leftovers. I will admit that not everything turned out - and I blame it entirely on our reliance on modern baking tools like KitchenAid stand mixers and spatulas.

I came home reeking like smoke from being in front of the fire for several hours, but it was a good smell and reminder of how different life and tastes used to be 200 years ago. If you're interested in the Cast Iron Chef Historic Cooking Series, keep a look out for a tentative pudding class that happen around Easter.

Join the conversation Load comments

Latest in Eat & Drink

21 restaurants for Family Day brunch in Toronto

10 underground bars in Toronto that are hidden spots for late night drinks

The top wing night deals in Toronto by day of the week

The top 25 diners in Toronto by neighbourhood

10 restaurants for birthday dinner in Toronto that are good for large groups

Toronto is getting a Harry Potter-themed beer festival next month

Toronto bars will be open two hours later than usual this weekend

Toronto restaurant was still taking Valentine's reservations even though it closed last year