ttc altercation

Charges laid after violent altercation with TTC officers caught on camera

Concerning video footage from what was meant to be a routine fare inspection aboard a TTC vehicle last week has resulted in charges of assault and uttering threats for a 34-year-old Toronto man.

The man in question, a streetcar passenger, was approached by TTC special constables on the 501 Queen route Friday morning around 7:30 a.m., according to witnesses.

A Twitter user who filmed part of the resulting altercation said that two officers asked the man to provide proof of payment, but that he "blew them off."

In a now-viral 12-second-long video clip, one officer can be seen striking the man repeatedly while another sprays some sort of white substance from a cannister in the passenger's face.

A third TTC officer wearing a "fare inspector" vest can be seen near the end of the video, trying to stop the Twitter user from filming.

The widely-shared video sparked not only a Toronto Police investigation, but another wave of intense criticism against TTC fare inspectors and their notoriously heavy-handed techniques.

This, just days after two TTC documents were published containing plans for cracking down on fare evaders even harder — with the controversial use of plainclothes officers on vehicles, among other tactics.

"This is unequivocally the wrong way to handle fare evasion," wrote city councillor Brad Bradford on Twitter of the clip from Friday morning.

"Another example of why we need to improve the training and recruitment processes for fare inspectors. Officers need to de-escalate these situations, not resort to force."

"The actual offence, if any, doesn't even matter anymore," wrote councillor Kristyn Wong-Tam similarly.

"This is not how the TTC should be treating riders. There needs to be a full investigation into this use of force, which is never acceptable."

"No incident on the TTC in an ideal world should end in any kind of violence or anything even close to that," said Toronto Mayor John Tory on Sunday.

"However, we haven't seen everything and I think we need to see everything. That’s why I’m very heartened that the first reaction of Rick Leary, the CEO of the TTC, was to refer this out to the Toronto police — outside of the TTC for a full investigation, which is now underway."

Toronto Police revealed on Sunday evening that the passenger, 34-year-old Steven Thackaberry, was arrested following the altercation and that he has since been charged with two counts each of uttering threats and assaulting a peace officer.

Police did not say if the investigation has concluded, or if any further charges are expected.

Neither police nor TTC officials have spoken as to what the substance sprayed at the passenger was, but the TTC's customer service account did confirm on Twitter that special constables carry pepper spray with them.

The Twitter user who posted the original video did say that the passenger was possibly "intoxicated" or "just belligerent" and that he "had kicked his shoes off and was randomly yelling at people" before fare inspectors boarded the streetcar.

Toronto Police also said in a statement to CBC News that the man had been "acting aggressive and violent." 

CUPE 5089, the union representing TTC fare inspectors and special constables, is asking TTC officials to release CCTV video of the entire incident in an effort to give the public a better understanding of what happened.

"It is unacceptable and unprofessional for [city leaders] to rush judgement over a 12-second video," said a union rep to CTV.

"Their careless, self-serving comments have driven the forum away from independent public opinion and taken away the facts and issues of the incident."

Lead photo by


Join the conversation Load comments

Latest in City

Canada's new miniature village is opening up in Toronto next month

Toronto's Pearson Airport goes back on policy to divide travelers by vaccination status

City of Toronto nabs dozens of cyclists for speeding in blitz that some say is unfair

Doug Ford says he'll hop into a school bus and drive kids to class this fall if he has to

People have started installing anti-City of Toronto signs in parks

Special weather alert issued for Toronto due to some of the worst air quality in the world

Vote for your favourites in 30 new best of categories

Toronto neighbourhood still shaken by long lockdown in Ontario