toronto scarborough rt

Scarborough to get a new subway but only if Feds help

Subways, subways, subways, folks. Scarborough is getting subways. After a marathon and sometimes confused debate, city council has voted 28-16 to extend the Bloor-Danforth line three stops east to Sheppard Ave. via Scarborough Centre and nix plans for a fully-funded LRT.

The decision means the existing RT, which is approaching the end of its working life, will continue to operate beyond the planned 2015 shutdown date until the 7.6-kilometre subway extension is finished in the early 2020s. It also means the 48-month shuttle bus period that would have been necessary with the LRT will also be avoided.

There are still numerous question marks around exactly how the subway will be funded. The now-dead 7-stop LRT had already cleared many of the planning hurdles that now face the subway, including environmental assessments and financial agreements between the local, provincial, and federal governments.

An amendment by Cllr. Joe Mihevc makes the extension contingent on the province chipping in $1.8 billion (in 2010 money) and the federal government agreeing to cover half the net capital costs. It also stipulates that no money be taken from the Sheppard, Finch, and Eglinton LRT projects.

toronto scarborough LRT

Another potentially critical caveat added by Cllr. Paula Fletcher means the other levels of government will have to commit funds by 30 September or have the line revert back to an LRT. TTC Chair Karen Stintz originally estimated a decision would come in January at the earliest.

"Scarborough residents don't feel their voices have been heard," Stintz said before the vote. "Now for the first time have a plan in front of us that is a subway that can be funded."

Rob Ford had hoped to limit the city's financial contribution to money gathered from a 0.25% annual increase in property taxes but that motion was defeated 21-23. It's not clear yet exactly where the city's contribution will come from.

Yesterday's debate was marked by one particularly lively exchange between Cllr. Josh Matlow and Rob Ford in which the mayor appeared not to know how the proposed light rail line would be situated. "It does rip out traffic lanes," Ford said of the grade separated route. "LRTs go down the middle of a road, they tear up your roads," he said to incredulous jeers from the chamber.

What do you think of the decision? Is a subway to Scarborough the best result even if it costs more and takes longer to implement? Are you concerned about the delay?

Chris Bateman is a staff writer at blogTO. Follow him on Twitter at @chrisbateman.

Image: PLTam/blogTO Flickr pool, City of Toronto.


Join the conversation Load comments

Latest in City

Toronto cyclist nears end of 46-day ride for George Floyd

Uber takes swift action against driver after woman alleges racial slur in Toronto

Founder and CEO of the Drake Hotel in Toronto steps down amid racism controversy

Here's what the weather forecast looks like for the rest of summer in Toronto

Doug Ford says Ontario is close to Stage 3 reopening and here's what that would include

Toronto isn't going to do anything about overcrowding at city beaches

Ripley's Aquarium in Toronto changes policy after complaints about reopening plans

Toronto street named after slaveowner will soon be called something else