Sports & Play
Toronto Police and Chilean Soccer Players Brawl
Those who watched last night's semi-final game between rivals Argentina and Chile in the FIFA under-20 tournament, regardless of their loyalties to any teams or players, would likely agree - the officiating was nothing less than brutal. The German referee was passing out yellow and red cards like coupons for free vacations that were about to expire, and the game play was affected.
Soccer fans at Toronto's BMO field were riled up with anger and disbelief, but when the same emotions began appearing on the field in the faces and actions of the Chilean players we knew that tensions were boiling. At one point, Toronto police officers had to come onto the field to settle the steaming Chilean players and staff down, as they approached the game officials en masse.
But it's what happened after the game that's making international headlines and putting our police force under close scrutiny. Accusations that Toronto police used excessive force are buzzing about. Early reports suggest that billy clubs, tazers, and pepper spray were used, and blood was spilled in violent clashes between the Chilean team and police. As many as 9 players were arrested and later released. It's a real shame, and it looks really bad on all involved.
More news is sure to follow, but here's what we know so far:
[CBC Newsworld clip - runs 5mins]
FIFA will hold a press conference later today.
--
And here's what they're saying on Chile's National TV network:


Discussion
128 Comments
Sort By Oldest First / Newest First
Subscribe
take the matter a lot more seriously by the pressure a pacifist reaction like this would create exposing them in a
much biger scale to deal with this situation</p>
that as all of this vanishes into the wind..
</strong>not long ago i remember in the news when the cops use force against some poor women protestors in howard st. they complaint about exessive force but because they were poor ,
a formal investigation would
never reach the light of
day. they wont be able
to cover their asses and
get away so easily with it for this one
Me parece muy feo que de esta forma se act?e en un pa?s que dice ser del primer mundo. Yo jam?s he visto que la polic?a trate a un deportista de esa forma en mi pa?s, Chile.
Ojal? los polic?as responsables paguen por lo que hicieron.
Me parece muy feo que de esta forma se actue en un pais que dice ser del primer mundo. Yo jamas he visto que la policia trate a un deportista de esa forma en mi pais, Chile.
Ojala los policias responsables paguen por lo que hicieron.
Ademas la policia de Toronto ya ha cambiado varias veces su version de los hechos, lo que claramente demuestra que han mentido. En cambio Chile, ha dado la misma version desde que ocurrieron los incidentes porque siempre han dicho la verdad.
Canada realizo un torneo sub 20 (U 20) y demostraron el racismo, la tortura, abuso de poder y ademas ser unos malos anfitriones.
Secondly, to those pointing out the fact that the Toronto police made a show of force: The whole purpose of police is to "enforce" compliance to the law and peace, "force" being the root of that word. Sure, police forces all over the world have the select few who choose to abuse their power however to state that Toronto police are any different is false.
Thirdly, those supporting Chile and condemming Toronto police as brutal are hypocrits. Take a look on the internet, there are literally dozens of videos depicting Chilean incidents with police involving brutality far surpassing some non-lethal tazers and hauling people away in handcuffs. Chilean police are feared by their own people, so don't get all offended when a foreign nation's officers do what is completely within their jurisdiction to attempt to dispell a situation. The outcome would have been the same if it had been the Canadian squad who started pushing female officers and busting out windows.
The only disgrace to this situation is that it had to come to world-wide attention.
avro201: Acabas de se?alar lo mismo que dice la policia de Toronto, que hubo una supuesta agresion a una mujer policia. Esa es una tremenda mentira. Ninguno de los Jugadores de La seleccion de Futbol de Chile ha dicho que ha golpeado a una policia. Es un invento de la policia de Toronto
La primera version de la policia de Toronto era una supuesta pelea entre jugadores de Chile y de Argentina, lo que al final fue mentira.
La segunda version de la policia de Toronto era una pelea entre un jugador de Chile y un hincha argentino, que tambien fue mentira.
La tercera version de la policia de Toronto era que los jugadores chilenos estaban con alcohol, incluso se dijo que estaban drogados, una nueva mentira
La cuarta version de la policia de Toronto era que los jugadores de Chile quer?an golpear al arbitro fuera del partido, otra mentira
La quinta version de la policia de Toronto es la mas fea de todas. Una supuesta agresion a una "mujer policia", osea para causar mayor sensibilidad y justificar la brutalidad policial dicen que la victima de todo este show fue una "mujer", es la quinta y la mas falsa de las mentiras.
Me podrias explicar ?Por que la policia de Toronto cambia tantas veces su version?
La Version de los jugadores de Chile, de los periodistas que estaban presentes y la de los hinchas que miraban es la misma. Los jugadores de Chile fueron golpeados brutalmente y de forma inhumana por esas bestias salvajes llamadas "policias de Toronto". La version de Chile, de los periodistas y de los hinchas ha sido siempre la misma y dicen que los jugadores de Chile fueron agredidos por saludar y firmar autografos a los hinchas presentes.
Es muy feo que Canada un pais que dice ser del primer mundo no solo trate de forma inhumana a una seleccion de futbol, sino que ademas claramente infringieron los derechos humanos aplicando descargas electricas y gases paralizadores, castigos absolutamente condenados por The Human Right Watch
"Human Rights Watch califico como "brutal" el operativo"
"A primera vista da la impresion de que se trata de una policia que recurre a la brutalidad como primer mecanismo de control" sostuvo Vivanco
"por lo que vi en las imagenes, me parecio abusivo"
Regarding the brawl, I was in Chile when this whole thing went on and the impact it had on Chileans in Chile was incredible. They even went and threw stuff at the Canadian embassy in Santiago. My uncle was actually helping out reporting and he saw everything that happened with his own eyes. Toronto Police simply did a horrific job that night. In chile, the players were being interviewed as they got back and they say most of it started when some Chilean players went to their fans to sign autographs and security wasn't letting them, they would ask them why and because their English was/is not that good, some security thought they said something innapropriate to them and began taking unnecessary actions against them. Since when can police just use a taser or use weapons on someone if they THOUGHT they said an inappropriate word. Then people go on to say that the Chilean players were destroying the bus because you know they're Spanish and they want to go destroy something because they're SO mad?? the real reason was that a female cop actually through those bombs that burn your eyes into the bus and doors were closed. They hadto smash the windows to get out because the doors wouldn't reopen. So later they're seen as these players that can't take losing so they destroy stuff and cause havoc? That's completely wrong. Some people have their opinion and I do too, but I'm not saying it because I'm Chilean, I try to think of stuff logically, without being biased. If it was the Argentian team that lost and that happened, I would look at it the same way. Although I'd be happy to see that Chile won, it would be unfair to omit the idea that they're being unjustly treated, like the Chilean team was.
Unfortunately, thanks to this situation, we probably won't be seeing big tournaments like these occur in Toronto, which is a shame because it is incredible to see so many people rooting for their players and countries. But, if they do decide to do something here again, then they should really see who they're choosing to decide the fate of a country's team's destiny, and to have security or police use a better form of protection. The Chilean players were not going to do anything to harm the well-being of people and if they did, they know that would look bad on them especially if they're in a country that is not theirs.
toronto police really needs to settle themselves and arrest or hurt people that are armed and that are a real harm to the community not defenceless players that are here just to represent their country.
third. There was an ault involved the coach of the chilean team who's an elderly man, he also got battered. There were brusies and tazer marks, perhaps you think this is tough love marks and nothing to be called battery. Apparently you expect a gunshot wound, hence what happened to the polish fellow at teh Vancouver airport?
Fourth these players were generally well behaved and not to be compared with other football hoolighans, as you can see that they had peformed very well and kept to themselves without a majour incident. You're just trying to make a case that soccer assoc football breeds savagery.
Fifth a responsible foreign diplomat official was on the scene as well as the national team coach
6th a google search constitues as popularity of a subject hence being complained about too many times to be discounted as a myth, which is why google features the feature to trace thepopularity of search results. which are especially useful for marketing.
7th despite what you think about south american soccer, the performance tehre is taken with pride at a juniour level because they're trying out for the adult league, one of the battered, Vial got hired by a german team, as Suazo got hired for the adultnational team, which wouldn't have happened if they were the irresponsible thugs that you said.
8th to the chileans that support the toronto police, you must love your jobs in canada too much and you must consider the players as subhuman, there's still a lot of social class struggle in Chile.
9th racism has been demonstrated in generalisations that saying that all chileans are :a, all south american football is b, based on a claim by witness c. Plus the pin the blame on the foreigner. A?slander raus?
10th however multicultural a city is , the population is considered endemic to the urban territory tehrefore culture in comparison to a foreign visiting socceer team. this in a society that uses F.O.B as a putdown.
Oh yeah let's all act like baby Bushes