Virgin Music Festival 2009 Day 2
The 2009 Virgin Music Festival in Toronto suffered somewhat from poor turnout on Day 1, and Day 2 got off to a similarly worrisome slow start.
But with the help of darlings Our Lady Peace, and the significant allure of Nine Inch Nails' last Canadian festival hurrah on the main stage later in the day, the festival's last day ramped up to an awesome high note.


A cold weather forecast seemed to keep many festival goers home until mid-afternoon. Even as Mute Math took the stage, the Amphitheatre stands were looking barren. Trouble Andrew, Data Rock, and Mew all had to work with the crowds they were given, but thankfully the seats began to fill as Mute Math took the stage.


Mute Math are one of my favourite returning Vfest acts, and this year they were given the main stage treatment they deserve. The band has a new album out, Armistice but played a diverse set of older and newer material. I'm a much bigger fan of their older, harder sounds, and was blown away by the band's constant stage energy and solid presence.

Mute Math's drummer, Darren King (known for going postal on the drum kit), decided to bring on the crazy skills, blasting a solo so hard he needed duct tape to hold his headphones on. The band's live performance always seems to outshine their recorded tracks, but they are known for their reliable stage skills and are definitely worth checking out when they come back on tour.
The D'Ubervilles and Our Lady Peace both took their music to the street so to speak, with the lead singers jumping into the crowds with mics in hand. N.E.R.D. also got the audience involved, by inviting pit crowds up on to the main stage to dance - much to the feigned delight of the security guards.
Along with thrilling the crowds with an up close and personal "Raine storm," OLP seemed to really get the crowd going. It helped that by the time of their evening set, the audience was beginning to fill in nicely. OLP always seem to rouse festival crowds in the best way, and although I'm not the biggest fan I will admit that they seriously turned up the excitement.



Getting away from the big names on the main stage bill, I was pleased to see the smaller Boardwalk stage packed with amazing smaller acts working the intimacy of the crowds. Silverstarling was completely new to me, and blended soft melodic rock and wandering instrumental touches into a great performance. Fans responded in kind to the D'Ubervilles, whose energy and interaction kept the crowds hot while the temperature began to drop.
Out of Montreal, Plants and Animals have been getting a lot of attention across North America for their powerful rural rock sounds. I had a chance to speak with the band, who were somewhat dismayed about being billed on the Boardwalk stage; so instead, they took their music to the street and played outside under the stars. Having been on Festival tours all summer, these boys seemed like seasoned professionals despite the relatively small stage, chatting up the audience and breaking out the guitar solos with ease. They are also currently working on new material in studio, with plans for a release in the new year. They're a band I'll be watching closely as they continue to gain momentum.

Finally, The Pet Shop Boys claimed their place as the official eye candy at this year's Vfest. Their blinding stage effects and pop flavoured visuals, including dancers and a lot of cubic building blocks, were if nothing else an absolute spectacle. It's hard to argue over the influence this group had on progressive pop, but it really seemed out of place at this particular festival. The audience had a lot of mixed reactions, namely because the seats were filling up for NIN who are about as far different in genre from the Pet Shop Boys as possible. However it was 'neat' to see such a dramatic stage presence on the bill, hearkening back to the glory days of Toronto Vfest which boasted acts like the Flaming Lips and Bjork.


Finally, Nine Inch Nails - the crown jewel of this year's Vfest and frankly, the only act that saved the ticket sales - took the stage. Without exaggeration, I can safely say that nearly every seat was packed for Trent's final Canadian show with NIN. Bringing Robin Finck along, the group put on a blistering show of Nails anthems, long instrumental solos, and a creativity energy that far outshined NIN's last show at the Amphitheatre with Jane's Addiction earlier this year.
Nine Inch Nails - Virgin Festival 2009 - Toronto from Corina Writer on Vimeo.
Without question, this was the reason most people came out for Day 2, and Reznor didn't hold back or disappoint. Thankfully the sound problems that seemed to affect most of the Amphitheatre acts were completely gone for NIN. The band sounded amazing and despite an apparently sick Reznor apologizing for his voice, I thought he was in top form. It's sad to think that we'll never see this group on stage again, but this was an absolute vindication for this year's Vfest.
Performer photos and slideshow by Roger Cullman, with supplementary festival shots by Jerrold.
Comments (20)
the singers with their mouths open should be careful, because a bee could fly in and sting 'em.
It's Robin Finck, not Robert Fink.
"The audience had a lot of mixed reactions, namely because the seats were filling up for NIN who are about as far different in genre from the Pet Shop Boys as possible."
Um, really? Have you heard Pretty Hate Machine? NIN's sound got harder over the years but Trent's definitely a synthpop geek. One of PSB's songs at the concert (probably newer, I didn't recognize it) sounded absolutely early-NIN'esque. I wouldn't be surprised if Reznor considered them an influence. Sure, they were the super-gay act vs. NIN's performance aggression but musically, not so far apart.
"Bringing Robert Fink along..."
Who's Robert Fink? Were you referring to Robin Finck or...?
OLP were terrible. NERD got the crowd pumped, but Raine brought everyone right back down with an hour of third-rate, washed up Canadian Bono-isms. The shining light of the set though had to be him walking through the crowd saying 'I know you're all here for Trent Reznor, but you will stand up for OLP' and then accosting a man who would rather enjoy his beer. Few could blur the line between faded rock star and schizophrenic hobo quite so succinctly.
Ah thanks for pointing out the type-o, an oversight :)
As for PSB vs. NIN, I agree the technical composition of the music has similarities... but I wouldn't saw they have the same attitude or following. Pretty Hate Machine is my favourite NIN album, but I can't think of too many PSB enthusiasts who love NIN.
Many artists consider PSB an influence, even though they don't love the band. Plants and Animals has a lot to say on the nostalgia of PSB music, for example. I still don't think synthpop can be so generally classified as to put NIN and PSB into the same basket :)
I'm also going to have to argue that NERD was actually the act that amped up the crowd on Sunday. From where I was sitting near the rear of the lawn, a fair number of people seemed to actually clear out of the amphitheatre as Our Lady Peace came on in search of more interesting fare. I tried to give OLP a chance, but was surprised to discover Raine Maida's vocals sounded even more nasal live than on album. Luckily, I gave up on them in time to catch the Von Bondies on the Boardwalk stage, who were great, and are strangely absent from mention in this review altogether.
True, NIN were undeniably the highlight of the weekend, and behind a lot of ticket sales, but the reviewer may be surprised to know that by about a third of the way into Nine Inch Nails' set, a shocking number of concert-goers back on the lawn had already left, suggesting that maybe acts like the Pet Shop Boys were a bigger draw to the festival than you're giving them credit for. Again, from where I was sitting, PSB appeared to be quite the crowd-pleasers with plenty up and dancing, especially to some of their re-worked classics.
It still says "Robert" rather than Robin.
I know quite a few people who like both PSB and NIN, actually, including an old friend I discovered was sitting right in front of me during the show. He also likes Depeche Mode, Yazoo and Erasure. If you go to a goth club you'll hear everything from the really poppy European stuff to downright industrial and they will all fill the dancefloor...fanwise, there's a lot more crossover between the lighter and heavier stuff than you may be thinking, with EBM falling somewhere in the middle.
Based on all the reviews I've read from various sources, seems like no one at all liked OLP, lol.
Why hasn't anyone mentioned Hyper Crush, the Scooter-esque 80's nostalgia hipsters who MC'd and wore Key-tars as fashion accessories. Yup. :P
I checked out Hypercrush and thought they were fun, and had cool Nintendo related sounds/accessories, but wasn't overly impressed. I did think the scooter-look was pretty entertaining, but the vocals... erm.
And ROBIN lol confusion came from my lazy copy/past off of http://www.mygnr.com/members/finck.html hehe...
As for PSB, I said I can't think of *too many* enthusiasts who love NIN; I didn't say there weren't any! The lawns did seem a lot more full for PSB than NIN... but the stands were packed when Reznor took the stage.
I do wonder if the Virgin media release is accurate - did 29,000 people really attend this year's Festival? Seems like a gross exaggeration... I wonder what the numbers would've been like at Burl's Creek?
Agreed! The Von Bondies were fantastic on the Boardwalk stage, one of my favourites of the day!
Corina, there was an NIN fan beside me, who after PSB finished their set, turned to his friend and said 'I cant believe Im going ot say this, but any band would have a hard time following THAT set, even NIN'.
And for the record, Im also a NIN and a PSB fan. We do exist.
I absolutely loved it. Sure it was a bit chilly, kinda grey and a little quiet in the afternoon, but come evening the skies cleared, the winds disappeared and the stage acts exploded. I'm glad i was part of it.
I thought Reznor's voice sounded like crap. When did he get those muscles - anabolic steroids.
No one can touch NIN. Absolutely amazing. This wasn't really a festival, it was a NIN show with 10 random opening acts.
Mutemath and Mew were pretty damn good, though.
-Dan Contogiannis














RSS