Thursday, October 20, 2016Light Rain 13°C

That time when Citytv had a pulse

Posted by Ed Conroy / September 24, 2012

citytv news historyAccording to Gord Martineau, it was former Toronto Mayor and all around Citytv fanatic David Crombie who once said in deference to the CityPulse news team's cramped studio space at 99 Queen Street East, "the city is your newsroom." The program had debuted in May of 1977 with its own striking subtitle — a day in the life of Toronto — and a very strict remit from Citytv's visionary man upstairs Moses Znaimer: "You can decide that news is 24 discrete mini-events delivered with the voice of doom, or you can say, as we do, that it's the daily soap opera of Toronto."

If CityPulse was the daily soap opera of Toronto, then Martineau is its Victor Newman. He recently celebrated 35 years at the helm looking roughly the same as he did when he started, even as everything around him has changed fundamentally. But change is paramount to the Citytv success story. "There is no alternative to growing up" Znaimer told NOW magazine in 1982 while discussing Citytv's 10th Anniversary. "There is nothing as necessary as biology. The biology of a television station is no different from the biology of a person. You can be nostalgic about the days when you were young and pimply, when things seemed to matter more and less at the same time. But if you contrive to remain a child when you should be an adolescent and an adolescent when you should be an adult, you're just a failure."

From its very first anarchic transmission on September 28th, 1972, the crown jewel in Citytv's schedule was The City Show, fronted at first by the pensive chain-smoking Warner Troyer, a nightly 2 ½ hour marathon of in-depth discussion of local events, public affairs and news which at the time was a welcome antidote to Toronto's thirty or sixty minute news programs which aped the U.S. model. The City Show was more indebted to CBC's house style, unsurprising as Znaimer cut his teeth at the Mother Corp in the 1960s.

Unfortunately this gutsy but ponderous approach did not result in a sustainable serial, although it ran for half a decade and marked Citytv's first bold attempt to remould the stolid institution of news. The station then sought help from "news doctor" Jacques de Suze, a U.S. based consultant who proposed a series of revolutionary tweaks to the format based on his due diligence (rumour has it that upon being summoned, he holed up in a hotel room and watched nothing but Toronto area news for weeks on end). Filtered through Znaimer's Marshall McLuhan inspired temperament, and wunderkind Ivan Fecan's toiling, a new kind of news style came alive, a Frankenstein's monster crafted of equal parts music video, performance art, Hollywood sheen, and carnivalistic sideshow. This was the pulse.

While some saw the slick rebranding a betrayal of Citytv's earlier earnest commitment to hardboiled, old school journalism, CityPulse was in fact the most progressive and prophetic form of news gathering and telling ever broadcast. No surprise it's formula would go on to transform news reportage around the world, as well as confound and then reshape viewer's expectations. One of Znaimer's commandments at the time was "let the actual sound and visuals tell the story."

Clocking in initially at a whopping 90 minutes length, CityPulse soon settled into a fast paced 60 minute edition at 6 P.M., followed by another at 10 P.M., later known as CityPulse Tonight. The after-dark broadcast used the jazzy grooves of Grover Washington Junior's "Masterpiece" to soundtrack stories of our city, later Graham Shaw's mighty "Pentatus" while the 6 P.M. show deployed "Gonna Fly Now" (Rocky's Theme) to great effect, with assignment editor Glen Cole's introductory holler sounding like that of a wrestling announcer.

Znaimer populated his soap opera with real people, not reporters. Not only that, the people he enlisted actually reflected multicultural Toronto. It all seems so utterly Martian now, but at the time most major Toronto news outlets were anchored by silver haired, grandfatherly males, most of whom smoked pipes and wore un-ironic elbow patches. Citytv's diversity not only led to better quality news reportage, but better business as well, and by the mid-1980s CityPulse was close to slaying stodgy old dragons CFTO (CTV) and CBLT (CBC).

With a shrewd casting instinct to rival that of Robert Altman, Znaimer and company assembled a large and varied cadre of characters who established a bedrock of trust with viewers and became celebrities in their own right. Martineau was the very first, lured away from CFTO (where he had been forbidden to use his full surname), complimented by now legendary folks like Dini Petty, JoJo Chintoh, Brian Linehan, Bill Cameron, ex-Maple Leaf Jim McKenney, Peter Gross, Mary Garfalo, Jim Tatti, Kathy Kastner, Lorne Honickman, former provincial NDP leader Stephen Lewis, Toronto alderman Colin Vaughn, consumer affairs advocate Peter Silverman, athlete Debbie Van Kiekebelt, The Honourable David Onley, Anne Mroczkowski, Greg Rist, Jeanne Beker and later J.D Roberts, Monika Deol, Ann Rohmer , John Burgess, Terilyn Joe, Teresa Roncon, Bob Hunter, Libby Znaimer, Ben Chin, Harold Hosein, John Saunders, Laura Di Battista, Pam Seatle, Thalia Assuras, Denise Donlan, Lance Chilton, Dwight Drummond, Kathryn Humphreys and John Gallagher, to name but a few.

Another pivotal hire was ex-RCMP officer Glen Cole, who later shepherded former policeman Mark Dailey into the CityPulse family. Both men brought with them strong ties to law enforcement, invaluable for covering every nuance of crime in the city, and both elevated awareness of organizations such as Crime Stoppers and many other charitable causes. Both are also sadly deceased. Dailey passed away after battling cancer in 2010, sparking a public outpouring of grief for the much loved "Voice" of Toronto. It is a testament to Dailey's enduring iconic status that Citytv still hosts their moving tribute to him at

Over the years CityPulse ushered in many new technological advances, but few were as prized or ultimately important as those which granted the ability to accurately predict the state of the atmosphere.

In May 1987, CityPulse moved into a new home base at 299 Queen Street West. The bright orange set remained, but the static anchors and crash zooms were gone. The newsroom became electric with a new found sense of space where anchors walked around and interacted with one another in the midst of their messy technology. The guts of a modern studio were purposely exposed and celebrated, but there was no "studio" per se. This was also the age of the Videographer, lone wolf cameramen who shot, reported and edited their own stories. Pioneered by Dominic Sciullo, this style of reporting spilled over to other broadcasters before becoming standardized. Nowadays, anyone with a smartphone and a YouTube account is a Videographer.

Adding to the mythological stature of the brave CityPulse cameraman whose "eyes were on the beat of Toronto" was the fleet of CityPulse cars and trucks which tore around the city with wild abandon, beating their rivals to the drop on political scandals, car accidents, rowdy picket lines or murders. They were everywhere! After years of hard service in the field, dust ups with streetcars and various fender benders, the original Live Eye truck was retired, shipped off as junk then rescued from a scrapyard near Gladstone moments before it was to be crushed into a cube. Built to last and wired to the gills by technical boffin Ron Reid, the original Live Eye truck became the ultimate Citytv objet d'art, immortalized forever as a Toronto landmark on the side of 299 Queen Street East. The new owners of the building have since repainted the truck with the colours and branding of CP24, causing understandable umbrage amongst original Pulse personal at such a vulgar act of revisionism. Long live the original CityPulse Live Eye!

As with CNN, Citytv's coverage of the Gulf War in 1991 was a catalyst for major innovation in the upcoming decade. While other stations were off air, the anchor-less assignment desk scrolled news updates throughout the night, eventually using night owl Kevin Frankish to host spots which bled smoothly into Breakfast Television. By 1998, the CityPulse team had refined their technique to the point they were ready to give Toronto its very own 24-hour news channel, something which Znaimer had envisioned creating as far back as the 1960s: CityPulse 24 (later CP24, and now controlled by Bell Media (

The 2000s proved to be a tumultuous decade for CityPulse, with the departure of Znaimer, ownership of the station flipping thrice (from Chum to CTV then finally to Rogers), a name change to the less immediate CityNews, the death of Mark Dailey and Bob Hunter, and most damaging, a near ruinous gutting of the news division (this sordid moment is covered brilliantly by Lindsey Aubin in her piece "No Pulse left at Citytv". Reflecting back over 35 years, one can't help but feel the whole enterprise has been defanged in response to a stifling advertising and corporate climate. Has the punch up the bracket, crusading style of journalism shuffled away indefinitely from the homogenized universe of broadcast television and into the scrappier, more street savvy realm of blogs and social media?

Would contemporary CityNews ever deliver something as taboo as when Dini Petty gave birth on camera? Or as emotionally devastating and raw as Dan Petkovsek's report on Toronto skid row alcoholics "Raymond - No Fixed Address"? Or even want to help in toppling a sitting Mayor, as CityPulse did in 1980 when Colin Vaughn exposed John Sewell's canard about why he skipped out on a policeman's funeral?

If anyone understands the need to stay true to the CityPulse roots, it's first man in, last man standing Gord Martineau. After 35 years on the Hogtown beat he still considers the murder of Toronto police officer Michael Sweet the most shocking story he has had to cover (Mark Dailey used to say the same thing). He is a consummate professional with a deft sense of humour, as evidenced by his cameo roles in The Last Polka (1985) with John Candy and Eugene Levy, and Dirty Work (1998) with Norm McDonald and Artie Lang, and the countless years he MC'd the Citytv New Year's Bash. In the early 1980s he hosted a variety show for the Cash for Life lottery, and even cheekily defected to Global News for a short while ("A coffee break" as he describes it now).

After being booted from 299 Queen Street West, Martineau recalled David Crombie's sublime description of CityPulse when he passionately argued the case to Ted Rogers that Citytv absolutely must relocate to the Olympic Spirit building at Dundas Square, as opposed to selling out completely and absconding to posher digs in the north end favored by bean counting MBAs with no understanding of the streetwise stuff CityNews, nee Pulse, was once upon a time made from. "Ted drove down there, looked at it with his wife, and wrote the cheque". No matter what else may change, the Pulse legacy is safe with Gord.

Gord Martineau 1980sCitytv will be celebrating its 40th anniversary with the airing of Citytv: 40 and Fab, a 5-part news special airing next Monday, September 24 through Friday, September 28 during CityNews at Five, CityNews at Six and online at It promises a no holds barred look at the good old days, with interviews from many of the classic Citytv personal. Colour us intrigued.

Retrontario plumbs the seedy depths of Toronto flea markets, flooded basements, thrift shops and garage sales, mining old VHS and Betamax tapes that less than often contain incredible moments of history that were accidentally recorded but somehow survived the ravages of time. You can find more amazing discoveries at



Ben / September 24, 2012 at 09:47 am
Fantastic article. This is a really good read--albeit a vaguely depressing one given that it brings into sharp focus the void that currently exists in our local news scene.
Fig / September 24, 2012 at 10:42 am
Great post!
David / September 24, 2012 at 10:55 am
Freaking fantastic! Grew up watching CityPulse and still stick with CityTV News & Breakfast Television. Miss a lot of the old generation but I still enjoy the product that gets put out.
Liztomania / September 24, 2012 at 10:57 am
Why did everything go to shit in the 2000s?
Pope / September 24, 2012 at 10:57 am
Is there a vote for article of the year... If so... This should be the best article of 2012!!!

Way to go Ed! Keep up the great work.
Philamania / September 24, 2012 at 11:35 am
Keep these coming!
Sean / September 24, 2012 at 11:42 am
Great article and it's nice to see all those clips too!

Ok, you could have added a clip of those baby blue movies. HA HA

City-tv has come a long way.
Rick / September 24, 2012 at 12:16 pm
Great job on this!
j-rock replying to a comment from Ben / September 24, 2012 at 12:20 pm
I have the same reaction to these features. While I enjoy the nostalgia, it makes you realize how dire the current situation has become, and that, at least in this respect, we had things a lot better 20 years ago.
rick mcginnis replying to a comment from Liztomania / September 24, 2012 at 12:42 pm
Well, I don't know about "going to shit," but if you want to know what major shift happened in the media that changed everything, and caused a lot of panic and disruption, well, you're reading it right now - it's called the internet.
Randy / September 24, 2012 at 02:23 pm
Excellent post!
BCTV / September 24, 2012 at 02:28 pm
Great title!

/Finding it highly amusing that Blog To has so far had better coverage of City Tv's anniversary than City Tv itself
McRib / September 24, 2012 at 04:08 pm
do i ever hate Gord Martineau, but nevermind that.

RIP City-TV in the 1980s, what a station it was then and what a piece of crap it is now. These videos are wonderful.
TV watcher / September 24, 2012 at 09:10 pm
Just like there is now a radio station at 88.1 for indy music
we need a new indy TV station... Like City use to be.
Junior Chicken replying to a comment from McRib / September 24, 2012 at 11:17 pm
Gord is a true definition of a douchebag. Go on YouTube and search gord martineau bloopers.
S / September 25, 2012 at 04:28 am
@ TV watcher: You are so correct.
Matt / September 25, 2012 at 08:18 am
I would love to see someone write an "Oral History" of CHUM-CITY-MUCH's heyday, like the "Live From New York" and "I Want My MTV" books. So many great stories.
M / September 25, 2012 at 10:45 am
Fantastic article. Thank you for writing this.
Mark / September 25, 2012 at 10:48 pm
Great article, a few years back cp24 played "rewind" which aired old broadcast (early 80's) eps of city news. It would come on 2am Saturday morning and I would make a point to watch it every weekend. Sad they took it off, right about when Ctv bought them out.
Sharon Martineau replying to a comment from McRib / September 25, 2012 at 11:13 pm
How could anyone "hate" Gord Martineau? All that charity work for those poor Herbie kids, all the fundraising he does for local charities like the Kids Breakfast Club and the Kids Helpline--AND unlike certain other local news people, he doesn't charge an appearance fee at these events which he emcees like the pro he is. He genuinely loves the city--no pretense from this guy!
Stephen replying to a comment from Sharon Martineau / September 25, 2012 at 11:48 pm
Gord Martineau = legend
Joshua / September 27, 2012 at 01:06 am
Even though, this is a strictly "Retro" review, if anyone could record that new CityTV documentary this week for posterity?
Daniel / September 29, 2012 at 01:35 pm
So...if Gord was 45 years old in '92, that makes him 65 this year, now that City's celebrating 40 years. Wow...he honestly doesn't look a day over 55!
Daniel / September 30, 2012 at 04:08 am
On another note, I think it's fair to say that the Pulse legacy is safe not only with Gord, but also with the others who got to work under Moses' tenure and are STILL with City. There's a good handful of them--on-air people like Kevin Frankish, Pam Seatle, Cynthia Mulligan, Kathryn Humphreys, Hugh Burrill and Jennifer Valentyne, long-time 6:00pm director Katia Del Col, maybe some other people behind the scenes, even the likes of Avery Haines and Roger Petersen who both came to City in the late '90s/early 2000s, left for other endeavours then returned to City in recent years. The spirit of the old "Newserials" can probably be seen on Haines' "Inside Story" (a regular feature on the 6:00 edition), which has done some pretty brave stories since it started earlier this year (such as one on the controversial "bath salts" drug, and another on female genital mutilation in some cultures). Also, there's the recent expansion of the weekend 6 and 11pm newscasts as well as the 11pm weeknight broadcast to a full hour. Among a few other things. Sure, CityPulse as most long-time Torontonians knew it is gone, but I think that not all was lost within this current CityNews team. There are still some things that even the corporate switch-up of recent years hasn't taken away from them.
Wayward T / November 15, 2012 at 03:16 pm
Does anyone have a copy of Raymond: No Fixed address with all its parts?

I'd love to get a copy of it in it's entirety! It would mean a lot to me.

Raymond was my friend. He did enjoy 15 years of sobriety and clear thinking working for my family. He has since past on and this series would be a great keep sake for me. :)
Quality / July 26, 2013 at 02:53 am
Wow, this article is good, my younger sister is analyzing such things,
thus I am going to tell her.
Matthew Lausmann / November 7, 2013 at 05:27 pm
Nice Done Ed Conroy!
Znaimer is Great TV / October 1, 2014 at 11:43 am
CITY-TV stinks under Robbers management. Remember when it was Movies, Music and News and they made a pledge of no informercials. Now it is so sad with Robbers formula filled with garbage infomercials and Shopping Channel junk.

CP 24 should be rejoined to City TV. It is nothing but a CTV-Bell Telephone Booth wasteland. Thought they were supposed to be distinct when the licenses were granted.
Gone But Not Forgotten / October 1, 2014 at 12:27 pm
Sadly Bill Cameron isn't with us anymore either. He did a great job on the CityPulse late edition and then went on to the CBC to host The Journal for many years after Barbara Frum. While Gord and Dini got all the publicity, Bill worked away in his low-key style. A real professional, dedicated to his work all the way.
Lowrez / March 15, 2015 at 09:40 pm
Many would argue that BlogTO has suffered the same fate as brutally corporatized CityTV.
Max Renn / March 15, 2015 at 10:12 pm
CIVIC-TV was a better station.
Bruce McNab / April 19, 2016 at 08:40 am
Not one word about the incredible people who actually made CityPulse work... The writers, show producers, tape editors, field cameramen and studio crew. This just perpetuates the myth that the on-air talent was all that mattered. Meh. Piece of fluff.
Other Cities: Montreal