Saturday, May 26, 2012Mostly Cloudy 21°C
City

Harolding in Mount Pleasant Cemetery

Posted by Derek Flack / December 21, 2009

Harolding Mt. Pleasant CemeteryHarolding involves spending one's time hanging around cemeteries taking in the ceremony of death. A neologism seemingly made for the Urban Dictionary, the term's etymology derives from the 1970s cult film Harold and Maude in which the protagonist's obsession with death leads him to frequent graveyards and attend the funerals of strangers.

My initial exposure to the term came courtesy of Douglas Coupland's 1996 collection of non-fiction Polaroids from the Dead, in which he shares his youthful experience harolding in B. C.'s Capilano View Cemetery.

Although the word was new to me, reading Coupland's narrative had quite the impact. For it was then that I realized that, for better or worse, harolding was something that I'd been doing for some time.

It started when I was given my first real bike. A snot-green Fuji with 21 gears, my mother thought that a little indulgence on this purchase might keep my activities clean over the impending -- and my first -- unregimented summer. Less a gift than an unspoken promise, the purchase of this bike was a pact between the two of us that I would keep my hands firmly affixed to the handlebars and not upon whatever other trouble presented itself.

So, as my friends headed north to summer camps, I was left city-bound and primed to explore the world at my wheels, the Toronto of a 12-year-old.

Living at Yonge and Davisville at the time -- and having a relatively limited geographic range -- I was drawn to Mt. Pleasant Cemetery. Not only was it an excellent place to hide from cars and other traffic, its many turns and undulations made it the perfect place to enjoy my bike.

Eaton MausoleumI spent the entire summer in the cemetery that year, getting to know more than just its roads. Although it may seem slightly odd now, it was a remarkable place to explore. From my early discovery of the Eaton family mausoleum to my later location of an entrance into the neighbouring ravine, there was a wealth of fascination to be had within and around the cemetery.

And, of course, there was also the occasional funeral.

One doesn't spend so much time in a graveyard without encountering a few of these silence-inducing ceremonies. The first time I happened upon one I was quite taken aback. I immediately felt like an intruder. The carefree "park" I had become accustomed to was, of course, no such thing.

The final resting place of more than 168,000 people, I now find it rather remarkable that I had been so cavalier about treading its grounds. Although I had spent day after day there, I was certainly not a harold.

Mt. Pleasant CemeteryBut even after witnessing the act of mourning a few times, I continued to return to Mt. Pleasant Cemetery. And though I still stuck to the roads, refusing to get off my bike and explore the areas off the beaten-track, I began to be captivated by the tombstones.

Mt. Pleasant CemeteryI had always been aware of them, but I had never really taken note of their meaning or significance. So as the summer neared its end, I started reading the epitaphs. Still so young, I'm quite sure that I was yet to understand the gravity of these inscriptions -- and yet I was intrigued by the lives and stories they summarized and gestured to.

As school resumed, I frequented the cemetery much less. Not only was I occupied by activities with my friends -- none of whom were big cemetery-dwellers -- but that entrance to the ravine I had found led to an obsession with mountain biking that would turn me off paved roads in general.

Mount Pleasant CemeteryIt was not until many years later that I returned to Mt. Pleasant Cemetery. I was in grad school and living on Woodlawn Ave. Suffering from bouts of anxiety at the time, I would walk in the ravine near my apartment to relieve stress. On one such walk, I found myself at the very entrance to the cemetery I had discovered so long ago.

Walking around the place as an adult was quite a different experience. Both familiar geographically and unfamiliar psychologically, the cemetery now engaged me as someone who spent a tad too much time considering my own mortality. But, being on foot, I only explored a small area of the grounds that day. This reacquaintance, however, lead me to return with a careful regularity. As much as I enjoyed my contemplative walks, I didn't want to indulge my harolding habit too much. Despite their calming effect, it was still easy to get depressed when spending significant amounts of time there.

So I spent the fall of that year studying modernist literature and harolding on the weekends. But, eventually this phase passed as well. Who knows if it was the onset of winter or simply the fact that I grew bored of my cemetery-dwelling -- either way, it was once again a long time until I returned.

My latest visit to Mt. Pleasant cemetery was made primarliy so that I could write this narrative. I happened to re-read Coupland's account of his harolding days, and decided that I wanted to take some of my own experiences down. Knowing that I would likely publish it here, I also decided that I would photograph the place for the first time.

Mt. Pleasant CemeteryThis was far more difficult than I expected. As I drove along the roads I still knew so well, I was hesitant to get out of the car and reveal myself and my camera. I once again had the feeling of being an intruder. Although I had used the cemetery for years, I had the profound sense that this was a private place not meant for photographs.

Mt. Pleasant CemeteryWho were these people, after all? George Pears? Captain Fluke? Intriguing and mysterious are the lives behind these monuments, but also so distant. Surrounded by tombstones bearing the names of strangers, there was something alarmingly voyeuristic about the act of snapping away.

Mackenzie King GraveIt was not until I happened upon the gravesite of former prime minister Mackenzie King that I started to become more comfortable with the camera in my hands. His grave is marked by an official government plaque and is obviously welcoming to those who wish to pay their respects.

Mackenzie King GraveWhile Mackenzie King's tomb can't be compared with Jim Morrison's, it nevertheless dawned on me that the majority of cemeteries aren't really private places at all. Sure, most are technically private properties that grant access to the public, but that's not what I mean. No, what I'm driving at is the fact that they are places of commemoration. Perhaps this is an obvious observation, but as I was trying to shoot the many tombstones I felt it come upon me as something of an epiphany.

There will always be a discomfort in capturing, once again, what is already a monument to fixity. But, that word -- monument -- it reveals so much. A tomb is a reminder, a record, a narrative condensed into a figure of the lived, now gone -- but not forgotten when looked upon, when witnessed.

So I must cast out my shyness, this fear of the shutter-trips.

I'm here.

And the act of sharing is a testament not just to those interred at Mt. Pleasant Cemetery, but to memory itself.

Discussion

24 Comments

Christopher / December 21, 2009 at 03:13 pm
user-pic
Good piece Derek. Captain Fluke, what a name. I wonder what the situation is with tombs like his (hers?)... is there a coffin inside, or just a body on a stone bed? Are the entombed holding swords and shields across their chests? Is it an expensive?
Harold / December 21, 2009 at 03:50 pm
user-pic
Awesome article. Thank you for this.
jen / December 21, 2009 at 04:09 pm
user-pic
What a great story. I always wished that I lived nearer to the cemetery so I could jog there. Great photos!
Fig / December 21, 2009 at 04:32 pm
user-pic
I recently spent a very enjoyable fall afternoon in the Mount Pleasant Cemetery. Years ago, I worked at Yonge and Balloil and would often take lunch-time walks there. Thanks for writing this. I'm quite fond of the place.
Z. / December 21, 2009 at 04:37 pm
user-pic
What an outstanding article. I have been planning for sometime to return here to photo-document these bits of history and reading this only strengthens that resolve.

Good stuff, Derek.
lucy / December 21, 2009 at 04:51 pm
user-pic
I believe Captain Fluke was a steamboat Captain. There is a book on Mount Pleasant available at the Library or at the office! I often walk there during my lunch break! It also has a number of interesting species of trees!
heymomo / December 21, 2009 at 06:02 pm
user-pic
The Mount Pleasant website has lots of great info, including a bio for Captain Fluke:
http://www.mountpleasantgroup.com/new/interest/filey/archives/fluke
Derek replying to a comment from heymomo / December 21, 2009 at 06:09 pm
user-pic
Wow. Their archives are fascinating. I didn't realize they were on the website. Thanks for the link!
saltspring / December 21, 2009 at 08:01 pm
user-pic
Terrific article, Derek. This cemetery is an oasis of meditative reflection that served me well as I was starting my family and renting in Leaside. Many weekends did I spend there with children in strollers, and then on bicycle. I understand your reticence to photograph, but if the dead (or their families) didn't want earthly recognition after their demise, then they wouldn't have built such monuments.

Nice work.
Anna / December 21, 2009 at 08:31 pm
user-pic
This was a fantastic article. Very interesting and thoughtfully written. Thank you for sharing.
Sean / December 21, 2009 at 10:18 pm
user-pic
I'd go but I don't see a Starbucks.
Adam Sobolak / December 21, 2009 at 10:20 pm
user-pic
One of the newest Harolding landmarks in Mount Pleasant is a memorial to Tyler Mulcahy, out in the NW where a pair of roads split...
jameson / December 22, 2009 at 12:04 am
user-pic
Having worked at a cemetary, you wouldn't ever get a negative reaction from taking a picture of a tombstone, you would get asked why, and then a very interesting story about the person who the stone is in memorial for. many, many crypts and columbariums have lost stories, but its an aspect of life.
lucy / December 22, 2009 at 08:59 am
user-pic
so he WASN'T a steam boat captain...oh well my fantasy of him being one still lives on!
lucy replying to a comment from Sean / December 22, 2009 at 09:00 am
user-pic
there's a starbucks just south of there on yonge, grab a coffee and go for a walk.
Riley / December 22, 2009 at 04:46 pm
user-pic
It's nice to see blogTO featuring a few more of these narrative style pieces. I know they're longer, but what an enjoyable read.
Matt / January 4, 2010 at 01:42 pm
user-pic
Interesting. I've been threatened by security for taking pictures in Mt. Pleasant in the past. Either the author got lucky, or they've changed their policy, I assume.
luucy / January 4, 2010 at 01:44 pm
user-pic
I've never been threatened nor have I ever seen security.
Security / January 4, 2010 at 02:08 pm
user-pic
Security has approached me, that photography in the cemetery is not allowed. But i have heard stories of security trying to take people camera's.
Lysa / April 17, 2011 at 11:02 am
user-pic
I have an interesting story about Mount Pleasant and Captain Fluke - would like to share with the author
Ella / October 14, 2011 at 09:47 pm
user-pic
I got loads of pictures on my cellphone. It's a beautiful place (I was recently in Toronto).

Nobody who saw me take pictures seemed to mind. People and kids walking, driving through, bikers, etc. Rather a busy place.
Ella / October 14, 2011 at 10:07 pm
user-pic
Is that first picture from section I looking down at section s? It looks like it, except I remember section s as being steeper.
John Oughton / November 14, 2011 at 05:36 pm
user-pic
Good article and photographs. I live just south of the cemetery and often go for walks with my camera (nobody has threatened me for taking pix yet). In the endclosest to the ravine entrace, you may find:
* the grave of Handsome Ned, with a beautiful quote from one of his songs
* a sculpture of kids dressed as firefighters climbing a ladder
* a joint tombstone for an out gay couple
* a toumbstone carved and titled as "the Book of Life."
I find myself constantly doing numbers -- how long, or short someone lived, how long they outlasted their spouses (or sadly, their children).
Chris B / April 22, 2012 at 06:31 pm
user-pic
As someone with a parent, grandparent and great-grandparents buried in Mt. Pleasant, I really appreciate the respect evident in your essay.

Add a Comment

Other Cities: VancouverMontreal