Monday, February 13, 2012Partly Cloudy 1°C
City

Exploring What Remains Of Thomas Meredith House

Posted by Jonathan Castellino / October 14, 2009

Thomas Meredith HouseThere are few things in our built environment quite as sad as abandoned houses... such as downtown Toronto's George Street Thomas Meredith House.

Anyone familiar with the area around Thomas Meredith House is aware of its degeneration over the past few decades, and unlike some, I do not believe in revitalization in the form of poutine. Even so, this rough area is home to some truly hidden gems (no, not Filmore's).

Thomas Meredith HouseDerelict factories, de-commissioned power plants, even abandoned schools and churches seem less of a conundrum, as they speak more to a general societal change or evolution. But a home in this same state seems much more like a sad personal tale - and one worth remembering, if only through photographs.

This beautiful mid-19th century 2 1/2 story house is a wonderful example of Italianate styling, and was one of the first houses on the street. Thomas Meredith himself was a grain merchant, historically associated with his business dealings with the Gooderham and Worts Distillery South and East of the manor.

The house remained in the family until the early 20th century, and since then has passed through many hands. Certain key stylistic elements, such as the 'hipped' roof and facade detail led the site to be given heritage status in the mid thousands, but I have been following 'progress' on the property for some time now, visiting the place and speaking to some of the neighbours, and not until very recently has any significant work been attempted.

The interior is home to some of the most beautiful door frames and fire places I have ever seen...Thomas Meredith House

There is something undeniably eerie about the peeling paint, especially in the brighter rooms...Thomas Meredith House

Although each area seems to have a theme of sorts, much of it remains quite haphazard, due to the stagnation in progress regarding renovations.
Thomas Meredith House

Many of the fixtures remain, however, and hopefully will be salvaged.Thomas Meredith House

Thomas Meredith HouseStairways in older homes such as these are always, visually anyhow, the most spectacular elements, in my mind; the detail and craftsmanship seemed spectacular in Meredith House, even despite the decay.

Thomas Meredith House

Thomas Meredith House

Thomas Meredith HouseIt is a great hope of mine that this, and several other houses in the neighbourhood fall into the right hands and are eventually either saved, or converted to usable space. The idealist in me would love to see these spaces converted back to their original glory, while the realist understands that 'you can't save them all.' That said, virtually anything is better than seeing such beautiful historic places fall into the hands of slumlords, or worse still, rot and fall in on themselves (think, Walnut Hall, the last remaining Georgian Style Homes several blocks away, a few years back).

The urban planning disputes between land owners and city councils often drag on for so long, that these buildings end up giving up the ghost to demolition by neglect. Compromises and concessions, of course, are the only path to safeguard these historic landmarks. At least in this case, a house divided against itself cannot stand.

(To see the rest of the set of snaps, as well as high-res. versions of those above, you can check out my flickr slide-show below.)

Discussion

12 Comments

rick mcginnis / October 14, 2009 at 09:31 am
user-pic
Congratulations for braving George St., Jonathan - the street scared the bejeesus out of me years ago, when I lived nearby in the mid-'80s. I can't imagine how bad it's gotten now.
jack / October 14, 2009 at 09:57 am
user-pic
i hope someone is still paying property tax
a. / October 14, 2009 at 10:07 am
user-pic
hope someone can make this work
mr hate / October 14, 2009 at 11:05 am
user-pic
Toronto does not give a flying f*ck about its architectural history. It's embarrassing.
Peter / October 14, 2009 at 11:42 am
user-pic
I'm glad some vague work has been started to preserve the place, it looks like a treasure.
sunrised / October 14, 2009 at 04:45 pm
user-pic
Great photographs, as usual.
cocoa / October 14, 2009 at 06:37 pm
user-pic
The linked NP article is pretty interesting. I guess, in the time since, this area's been judged the city's most criminal. It's odd that so many points of interest for the homeless/mentally ill would be concentrated in one area, especially that area. You'd think it would have been successfully resisted by all of the affluent residents.

Nice pics. It's nice to see that work is being done on the house, but I guess it is impossible for it to return to being a single family residence. Toronto needs to do more to protect its old homes...nice old houses in the annex and high park are turned into multi-unit apartments and it ruins the neighbourhood because it's done on the cheap.
Lynn / October 14, 2009 at 08:17 pm
user-pic
I live nearby on Pembroke and am also a little weary of exploring George St.
Is one able to enter the house at random to explore?
Olga / October 15, 2009 at 11:16 am
user-pic
Who owns the house? Were you allowed in, or was this a sneaky expedition? Can I come next time? :)
Saddened and Frustrated / October 15, 2009 at 11:38 am
user-pic
I live on Seaton Street nearby. This stretch of George street is amongst the worst and most dangerous in the city. There is chronic and public drug use, prostitution and violent crime. It creates problems for the whole of the surrounding area. This strip is that way because of the high concentration of unsupervised homeless men with substance abuse problems and/or mental illness and the dealers who prey upon them. Troubles abound throughout what should be a desireable economically and ethnically diverse downtown neighborhood due to the concentration of social services into an 8 block radius. No one builds homeless shelters in Rosedale. There are at least four mega-shelters surrounding Moss Park. It is a ghetto.

Like the Dundas/Sherbourne All Saints Church, very little is done to deal with the issue created by this concentration of troubled individulas by either the "community activists" who run the shelter (and for the most part, don't live in the community on a permanent basis) or the police. A more or less constant presence by police officers over a sustained period of time would likely eradicate these issues, as would actual regular foot patrols by the same community officers (i.e. "beat cops") who would be ideally placed to deal with community issues with follow through and consistency. It's that simple.
A.R. replying to a comment from rick mcginnis / February 16, 2010 at 07:40 pm
user-pic
Rick: The 80s were a bad time for a lot of poor neighbourhoods. St. James Town became quite ugly with abandoned cars, but things look better today when compared with then. I don't know about the situation on George Street, though.
Morgan / December 15, 2010 at 03:00 am
user-pic
It's amusing that I went here at about 3am with two friends without having an inkling of this being the most dangerous area of TO. Nothing happened. Saw some crackheads on a corner dealing drugs or something, we didn't bother them, they didn't bother us...

Therefore: be smart about it, keep to yourself, no one will stab you.

Add a Comment

Other Cities: VancouverMontreal