Saturday, May 26, 2012Mostly Cloudy 18°C
City

Students Rally to Lower Tuition Fees

Posted by Guest Contributor / November 5, 2008

tuition fees protestToday, all over the downtown core, students were seen banding together to make a difference. Students from post-secondary schools from all over central Ontario congregated at various rendez-vous points such as OCAD, UofT, and Queen's Park. They then all met in and around the UofT campus all for one central and common goal - to lower tuition fees across the nation and to offer affordable education to all.

My adventure started at OCAD's welcoming Butterfield Park, where eager students held small pep rallies began, which began with students from the OCAD Student Union speaking about the issues that were inflicting their lives and lowering their quality of education.

drop tuition fees
Eric Bear Ludwig, an industrial design international student of OCAD from Florida, speaks out to everyone about the issues he faces as an international student. Beyond having to find housing for himself completely without help from the school, he also faces the burden of having to pay tuition three times as much as domestic students pay. Eric urges the government to aim to lower all fees and not just domestic student fees, as they are extremely high.

Once UofT Mississauga had arrived the students of OCAD and Mississauga campus marched up to UofT to meet with fellow brothers and sisters of debt burdened lives. As energy heightened on the march up Beverley Street to UofT, passersby weren't able to ignore the students' presence, with loud chants that could be heard a kilometer away.

As our mob of dissatisfied students began to amalgamate with the other schools such as Ryerson, UofT St. George and Trent up at UofT. The slew of students then began to grow exponentially. At that moment York U arrived almost simultaneously and chants of anger at the government grew. If one looked across the vast green of King's College circle they could see the giant group of York students stretching across the road now dominated by students instead of cars.

The now massive and intimidating group of students all cheering for lower tuition fees and debt free education began to buzz and hum with anticipation of their great march around town to show the city and nation that they want something changed!

As the group followed the leading pied piper truck with activist students from Ryerson chanting as loud as they can, I managed to grab another student for some words. Denelle Kennedy, another OCAD photography student is appalled by the prices she and many other students across Canada have to pay. Even being a domestic student the average two term year costs over $5000 and on top of that there are art supplies which can sometimes amount to $1500-$2000.

When asked about some solutions to this crushing debt, she says, "I think free education; let's model after Europe. If we're supposed to be a country of Britain, why aren't we modeling after them?" Perhaps this is a solution. The idea is that the country should understand that taxes put in the right place can really help to heighten the quality of our country through education.

jack layton olivia chow
This brings me to my so savored opportunity to chat with Jack Layton and his partner Olivia Chow, who also made an appearance on the Ryerson bandwagon. As I was heading back home to edit the photographs I collected, I saw Jack and Olivia being interviewed by an independent newscaster and stopped to get some words in myself. I had asked Jack about some solutions he hopes to put forth in the House of Commons to lower this debt that is crushing many students dreams. He replied kindly that he is the opposition and does not always have the pull to make the changes, but that he hopes he can see some changes in the future regarding the student debt crisis.

I also asked him about raising taxes, much like how European countries have, to offer lower cost or free post-secondary education to our citizens. He stated that it just wouldn't work to raise taxes, because people just cannot afford it right now, but that relieving some other money spending issues, such as subsidies that are granted to banks should be withdrawn and put forth to much more important means such as education for the country. To have the opportunity to talk with him was a great insight to this issue and helped me see and hopefully spread the word that there are solutions to this issue.

It makes one wonder how crooked our economy has become to put more money into "businesses" that do not exist so much in our very own country, than to place it right in the hands of our fellow citizens who are here, learning to make changes and bring light to our futures. It would be nice, as a common student, to see tuition prices freeze, or even drop to manageable levels. I am hoping to see some more things change in my generation and to see those changes passed on and succeeded by other changes for the better. I also hope that this helps others, who are not so well informed about this issue, understand that there needs to be something done! Students' debt are just getting higher and higher and something needs to be done, so lets this be a beginning in a forwards step in educational funding in the great white north of Canada.

Above writing and photography by guest contributor Dillon Scheenaard.

Update: For even more photos of the rally, check out those taken by Miriam O.

Discussion

19 Comments

Joe Howell / November 5, 2008 at 09:39 pm
user-pic
I love the second photo - the trees give it a whimsical feel. The best part of the day was probably the students descending upon the entrance to Queen's Park while Rage's "Killing in the Name" boomed from the PA. If anyone is interested, you can read my account through my red name link...
Jeffrey Yap / November 5, 2008 at 09:40 pm
user-pic
Despite being a student myself, and probably paying more than any other undergrad in tuition, there's absolutely nothing about this article that I don't loathe, including the event itself.

- This is probably the worst written piece I've ever read on BlogTO and I can only hope that its author isn't an English major
- In what may be an attempt to sabotage her own cause, Dennelle Kennedy offers up this gem, "If we're supposed to be a country of Britain, why aren't we modeling after them?"
- Who can reasonably expect to be taken seriously by tying their event to Guy Fawkes Day/V for Vendetta?
- International Students will likely be the last to see their tuition drop if it ever does and I can only assume those protesting were misled or naive
- Crazies like Dennelle up there who want tuition fees scrapped are just giving a bad name to more sane individuals

I'm also curious to know (if anyone would like to inform me) where the money for signs and shirts comes from. If it's fund raising merchandise then fine, but if it's paid for with my student fees...
Epizephyrii / November 5, 2008 at 10:09 pm
user-pic
Unfortunately, through all this they didn't go the one place they really should have: The parliment building. It's not the Universities' fault that they aren't getting funding support from the government and are forced to raise tuition to cover costs. U of T is already going through a budget crunch internally and this doesn't help matters.
Joe Howell / November 5, 2008 at 10:39 pm
user-pic
Actually, Epizephyrii, the final destination of the march was Queen's Park. I do agree with you, though, that the students who are trying to lower fees by yelling at U of T's admin are a little misguided.
Epizephyrii / November 5, 2008 at 10:56 pm
user-pic
Joe:

I'm glad to hear that... when I last saw the crowd they were all grouped up at Simcoe Hall and looked like they had hunkered down for a long protest. Too bad that wasn't mentioned in the article.
denelle kennedy / November 5, 2008 at 11:57 pm
user-pic
I'm crazy because i think having free education for all (which is a right) is a good thing?
Miriam / November 6, 2008 at 12:32 am
user-pic
More photos of the event found here:

<a href="http://flickr.com/photos/10492305@N07/sets/72157608691601014/">http://flickr.com/photos/10492305@N07/sets/72157608691601014/</a>
Miriam / November 6, 2008 at 12:34 am
user-pic
P.S. My parents had free education when they were in school in Europe. Why not now and here in Canada? :)
Dave / November 6, 2008 at 12:40 am
user-pic
Because then people will treat it just like they do high school... Without respect. Most people need to have a stake in financial their education in order for them to truly appreciate how important it is. I can't count the number of people I went to university with who saw it as just something to do, didn't care about what they studied, didn't care about much of it in general.

I'm all for interest free loans, but to provide it for free just doesn't cut it for me.
Jerrold / November 6, 2008 at 12:54 am
user-pic
Students asking for lowered tuition and faculty striking over sub-par wages... sounds like the 90's all over again.
Jeffrey Yap / November 6, 2008 at 01:07 am
user-pic
@ Dennelle:
I called you crazy for: saying that 'free tuition' was a solution to student debt; that loopy quote (possibly misquoted and if so, apologies); and for attending that particular rally. On a side note, I'm fairly certain that you're mistaking British and European higher education as British universities are not free. I think some European countries have zero or close to it tuition, but then again there are catches.

I would say:
- Why protest on Nov. 5th specifically (I believe this is an annual thing as well?), especially given that there's not going to be a provincial election anytime soon and people are too worried about the economy to care about your free ride.
- Demanding 'free tuition' is pretty ballsy, even if your intention is to bargain down; at least a freeze is more amenable
- A bigger and better overseen OSAP is the way to go if you want to preserve meritocracy
Jeffrey Yap / November 6, 2008 at 01:14 am
user-pic
In my personal experience (highly biased I realize) most people who protest tuition fees are either: 'student union' types, whom I have little respect for at UofT; people who don't know how to manage their money and/or live within their means; or people who's abundant free time is better spent getting a part-time job.

I realize that there are plenty of people who genuinely need help, but protests like this are counter-productive. And on the lighter side of things: <a href>http://torontoist.com/2008/03/fees_find_faux_scrum.php<;/href>
Andrew Louis / November 6, 2008 at 02:19 am
user-pic
What a huge crowd. I arrived a bit later:

http://hyfen.net/out/quickies/2008-11/angry-students-on-the-march/
Canuck in UK / November 6, 2008 at 05:53 am
user-pic
@Jeffrey Yap and Dave:

Sorry, dudes, but you're - quite simply - dead wrong. Students DO NOT need a "financial stake" in university in order to "treat it seriously". PUHLEASE. What kind of values do you think regular folks have!? That we can only value something with monetary attachments?

I live in Scotland and guess what!? If you're Scottish and attend a Scottish university, it's FREE. Yes, free. No tuition fees AT ALL but alas, you still have to pay for books and living expenses. And guess what? Students STILL take their teaching seriously and work hard.
Cassandra / November 6, 2008 at 06:41 am
user-pic
When I'm finished school in April, I will have $34,000 in debt from a bank. OSAP offered me peanuts (about $1800/year) because my single dad makes too much money, but not enough to pay my $4800-$5600 tuition each year. The interest payments alone are already almost $300/month.

As post-secondary education becomes more and more out of reach for people, I think it's even more important to advocate for lower fees. It's not necessarily going to get rid of tuition altogether, and we might won't see the benefits of our actions during our university careers, but if it makes post-secondary education more attainable in general, and if my little brother might not have to start his life with a huge debt load like I do...I think it's worth making some signs and marking on Queen's Park.
Ryan L. / November 6, 2008 at 10:05 am
user-pic
I'm all for lower fees, I just question what the yearly, routine rallys will do to help.

They've become so routine that they are simply ignored.

Any help that might be gained by them is surely ruined by the handful of jackasses at the rally that ruin things for everyone for a variety of reasons (trying to start shit with a cop, treating it like a party, being generally anti-establishment and playing stuff like RATM. Oh yeah, and of course wearing masks like the stupid V for Vendetta one)

Nobody will take these rallies seriously as long as the anti establishment types keep using them as an excuse to protest 'the man'.
expat / November 6, 2008 at 12:03 pm
user-pic
As a Canadian currently living/working in NYC, I have to say that as Canadians, we should be counting our blessings that tuition is as low as it is. I looked into going to school here in the USA, and tuition ranged from $12,000 a year (for a state school, as a state resident - it'd be over $25k if I was not a resident) to $40,000 a year for a non-state school. We're talking $120,000 for a four year degree!! That is insanity. My partner graduated 8 years ago and he is still paying off his student "mortgage".

Thank goodness for Canada! I just applied to OISE at U of T for next year and I'm coming home to take advantage of the CHEAP education.

That said, I totally agree that a tuition freeze would be a good thing, because fees have gone up by almost $2000 since I was in my undergrad.
Mark / November 6, 2008 at 05:33 pm
user-pic
The issue raises a simple, political question: Does the provincial government in power believe they will get more votes by diverting funding from one program to post-secondary education, in order to raise the Basic Income Unit rate (i.e., the amount they give to a university per registered student as of November 1 each year). That is the only way tuition can be lowered. For the government, it is a balancing act. Do they take from health care? K-12 education? Law enforcement? Social welfare programs? Environment?

In practical terms, there is a relatively finite amount of money available to be divided up among all the things that the provincial government funds. They have to decide how to allocate those funds among everyone who would otherwise demonstrate outside Queen's Park for their own interest.

The BIU hasn't been raised in years; if I recall correctly, it's actually been slightly lowered over time, and certainly lower in "real terms" compared to when this funding model was instituted. The protest focus on "free tuition" is misguided and counterproductive, since it can easily be dismissed by the government and general public alike. However, a more strategic focus on more equitable funding in line with inflationary increases over the years, and comparable to K-12 education funding increases could have a possibility of being successful.

I am a graduate student at OISE at U of T, and I have been quite vocal in my disagreement over these "free tuition" initiatives by the Canadian Federation of Students, the CUPE locals, and the Graduate Students Union at U of T. Personally, I think they are wasting precious effort for something that has no chance of succeeding. For university students, I would think they would be a little smarter...
Mark / November 7, 2008 at 11:39 am
user-pic
"I'm crazy because i think having free education for all (which is a right) is a good thing?"

Yes. Well, at least deluded. "Free" education does not exist and cannot exist unless there's a army of volunteer professors, administrators, architects, builders, etc., out there I'm unaware of.

So this "right" you are demanding is really the right to have other people pay for your education. We have the right to free speech, the right to the property we earn, the right to our own lives, but we don't have a right to anything that requires other people to provide it to us.

Add a Comment

Other Cities: VancouverMontreal