Saturday, May 26, 2012Mostly Cloudy 20°C
City

Law Firm Closing is Canada's Largest

Posted by Eugene / May 5, 2007

20070505_Torontodominion.jpgNormally an article about a law firm closing doesn't interest me that much. But a story on the closure of Goodman and Carr LLP in the Globe and Mail yesterday caught my attention for a couple of reasons.

First, this particular closure is a big deal in the legal profession - Goodman and Carr LLP was the largest law firm closing to date. Its decision to close last Tuesday is another sign of Canadian mid-size firms failing because of much larger foreign lawyer shops.

The second reason, which is even more interesting, comes at the end of the G&M article which mentions the previous largest law firm to collapse in Canada. Holden Day Wilson LLP, based in Toronto, was closed in 1996 to some extent because of an incident that has become part of Toronto lore and is a story that every Torontonian should know.

This is for the few people that have not heard this 14 year-old story: Gary Hoy, a partner at the firm, would periodically throw himself against the window of high-up floors in the Toronto-Dominion Centre to show that the glass was extremely strong. At an evening party, he did this trick again and succeeded. On his second attempt, however, he crashed through the window of the 24th floor, falling 72 meters to his death.

The firm, then dealing with merger woes, also had to deal with this controversial and public death. They closed soon afterwards amidst unpaid bills and compensation.
For anyone who has heard that story but wasn't sure if it was true, Hoy even won the Darwin Award for that year.

There, now you know some weird Toronto trivia that you can impress your friends with.

Thanks to Smudge for pointing out the G & M article and reminding me about this bizarre story.

Photo: Image from Brendan Lynch from the blogTO Flickr pool.

Discussion

6 Comments

JamesA / May 5, 2007 at 10:44 pm
user-pic
The headline is misleading and incorrect. Goodman and Carr was not Canadas largest law firm. The correct rankings can be found here:

http://www.lexpert.ca/directory/files/The%2030%20Largest%20Law%20Firms%20in%20Canada-2007.pdf
pedantic / May 6, 2007 at 12:13 am
user-pic
Eugene appears to have mis-parsed the specific text from the source article, which reads "...marking what is believed to be Canada's largest law firm closing."

Meaning the largest closing of a law firm to date. Not the closing of the largest law firm.
Rob Hyndman / May 6, 2007 at 11:05 am
user-pic
I was at ground level, about 100 yards away, the day that Mr. Hoy fell so tragically to his death. It was a shocking, stunning moment that left many in utter disbelief.

I will never forget the sounds of that moment - I was with a group of people standing at street level (the mall area where he fell is raised about street level somewhat) and all of us looked down the street, the noise being so loud that we all believed we'd just heard a bus or a truck accident. It was a terrible moment.
Eugene (author) / May 6, 2007 at 11:32 am
user-pic
James A and pedantic - sorry about the confusion y'all. You are correct - this is the largest closing of a law firm in Canada to date - not the largest firm to close(I've changed the title to "Law Firm Closing is Canada's Largest" to avoid further confusion. Thanks for pointing out the error.
JamesA / May 6, 2007 at 03:31 pm
user-pic
The story of the tragic death of Mr. Hoy still circulates among the residents in the tower (especially in the law firms), and in the Toronto legal community.
Mark / December 4, 2009 at 11:34 pm
user-pic
The tragic aspect of Mr Hoy's demise is that he paid a heavy penalty for his mistake, and I personally wouldn't want to see that too often. After all, who doesn't make mistakes?

On the other hand, I have to say that Mr Hoy definitely deserved the Darwin Award. I think even a 4 year would see the foolhardiness of Mr Hoy's actions.

Virtually every lawyer I have ever met oozes arrogance, and that is what I believe led to Mr Hoy's tragic demise.

Add a Comment

Other Cities: VancouverMontreal