One of Toronto's oldest homes hits the market for $4 million

Toronto has no shortage of old houses, but few have the historical pedigree of 171 Old Forest Hill Rd.

Known as the William Moore House, this rare Regency-style cottage is one of the last surviving examples of its kind in the city and one of the oldest homes still standing in Toronto.

"When this house was built Old Forest Hill Rd. didn't even exist. It was a horse path," realtor Russell Willer shared with blogTO. 

The foyer. 

Originally built for War of 1812 veteran William Moore, this architectural gem dates back as far as 1826, depending on who you ask.

A bedroom or home office. 

The City of Toronto's Heritage Register pegs it at circa 1840, while The Globe and Mail once reported the home was constructed in stages between 1826 and 1835.

You can see tons of the original millwork in the main hallway. 

Whichever date you choose, one thing's for sure: this house has serious historical chops.

The kitchen. 

But don't let the age fool you—this isn't a creaky relic stuck in the past.

The primary bedroom ensuite. 

The home has been masterfully restored and thoughtfully upgraded to meet modern standards without sacrificing its heritage charm.

The primary bedroom is located on the main floor. 

Inside, you'll find six bedrooms, four bathrooms, and a warm, refined interior that blends old-world character with upscale contemporary comforts.

The dining room. 

There are warm hardwood floors, high baseboards and ceilings, custom lighting, cozy fireplaces and more —all working together to create spaces that are both elegant and inviting.

The living room. 

Designed by Canadian artist Erin Rothstein, the home is also something of a creative sanctuary.

The library. 

The bright and airy library was used by Rothstein herself as an art studio, and it's where many of her most well-known pieces came to life.

A bedroom. 

In fact, every room in this house was designed with an artist's eye—each space feels like a perfectly curated canvas.

A side entrance. 

According to realtors Russell and Karen Willer, guests often comment on the gallery-like quality of the interiors, but this home isn't just for show. It's built for real living.

The laundry room. 

The kitchen is outfitted with top-tier appliances, the laundry room is built for the chaos of kids, pets, and daily messes, and the fully finished lower level offers a bonus bedroom and bathroom—perfect for in-laws, a nanny, or overnight guests.

The basement with the wine cellar. 

And yes, there's a temperature-controlled wine cellar for your finest Pinots and Chardonnays.

The backyard. 

Outside, the private backyard is complete with a wood-fire oven that'll make you the go-to host for pizza nights and garden parties.

The bedroom in the basement. 

Whether you're a history buff, an art lover, or just someone looking for a one-of-a-kind home with serious personality, this Regency cottage delivers. 

The gardens. 

Currently listed at $4,150,000, 171 Old Forest Hill Rd. recently dropped nearly $1 million from its original $5.1 million asking price.