home for sale in caledon

Ontario home sold at nearly $600k loss after 4 failed attempts to sell

Although the average selling price for homes in the GTA continued to edge upward through the first quarter of 2024, a home sold well below its listing price near Caledon last month demonstrates how unpredictable prices in the region tend to be. 

The one-storey residence, located at 9918 Old Church Rd., sprawls across 2.93 acres and includes a 700-square-foot extension, 14-foot high ceilings, a gourmet kitchen, a walkout basement, a wine cellar, and a secluded pond.

The lavish property was originally sold for a staggering $2.56 million in April 2022. Over the next few months, the home was listed and re-listed at consistently declining price points. 

In October 2023, the home was listed twice, once for $2,599,999, and then $2,349,000 just over a week later. In January 2024, the property knocked several hundred thousand dollars off of its price tag and was re-listed for $1,970,000. 

Eleven days later, the home was re-listed at $2,225,000. After sitting on the market for approximately a month, the home was re-listed for $2,198,888 in February 2024 and sold in March for $2 million flat — exactly $560,000 less than it sold for just two years earlier. 

This property isn't the only Ontario home to be sold at a significant loss in 2024. Last month, a home in Burlington's affluent LaSalle neighbourhood was sold for $700,000 less than it was originally purchased for just two years earlier. 

Despite these cases, a Toronto Regional Real Estate Board (TRREB) report released on Wednesday reveals that tighter market conditions in the region will push selling prices higher. 

"We have seen a gradual improvement in market conditions over the past quarter. More buyers have adjusted to the higher interest rate environment. At the same time, homeowners may be anticipating an improvement in market conditions in the spring, which helps explain the marked increase in new listings so far this year," said TRREB President Jennifer Pearce.

According to the report, the MLS Home Price Index composite benchmark was up 0.3 per cent year-over-year, with the average selling price increasing by 1.3 per cent to $1,121,615. 

"The average selling price edged up in comparison to last year as we moved through the first quarter of 2024. Price growth is expected to accelerate during the spring and even more so in the second half of the year, as sales growth catches up with listings growth and sellers' market conditions start to emerge in many neighbourhoods," said TRREB Chief Market Analyst Jason Mercer.

"Lower borrowing costs in the months ahead will help fuel increased demand for ownership housing." 

Lead photo by

Analyst Realty Inc., Brokerage


Latest Videos



Latest Videos


Join the conversation Load comments

Latest in Real Estate

You could live in this 19th-century Ontario schoolhouse for $3M

Here are the best places where you can still buy a house for under $1 million in the GTA

Canadian tenants share the wildest things landlords have told them

Toronto's next cluster of waterfront skyscrapers is moving closer to reality

Ontario landlord blasted for sketchy rental where tenants aren't allowed to use kitchen

Building at Toronto megaproject 'The Well' wins international design award

This $3M Toronto home has a circular stone fortress in the middle

Demolition begins for final blocks of Toronto's original Regent Park neighbourhood