Shake Shack Toronto

Shake Shack in Toronto already getting slammed with one-star reviews

Just weeks after Toronto's first and only Shake Shack location opened, it's already drawing in one-star reviews from dissatisfied customers.

The excitement was palpable all around the city when news broke that the New York-based burger chain, Shake Shack, would officially be opening its first Canadian location in Toronto this past June.

While early reviews widely praised the burger joint, confirming that the burgers are well worth the long wait in line and the shakes worthy of having the entire chain named after them, it looks like not everyone's agreeing with the hype.

When scouring the restaurant's nearly 400 reviews (the majority of which, I would be remiss not to add, give the restaurant 5-stars), the charge against Shake Shack you'll come across most frequently is being overrated.

shake shack torontoA number of reviews suggest that Shake Shack's Toronto location simply doesn't live up to the hype built by its fans south of the border, or that the quality of the food doesn't match that served at U.S. locations.

shake shack torontoOther reviews claim that the Halal meats (beef and chicken) are cooked on the same surface as non-Halal meats, like bacon, thus rendering the entire meal non-Halal — though these allegations have not been confirmed.

shake shack torontoOthers complain that the amount of food received in an order — namely the size of the hamburgers and chicken burgers — aren't worthy of the price, which is noticably steeper than at other fast food chains.

shake shack torontoSome reviewers claim that, when they tried to visit the restaurant, they found it closed for seemingly no reason, without any sort of notification.

shake shack torontoThe most (and, perhaps, only) concerning reviews come in the form of those who claim their hamburgers arrived undercooked or "raw."

In spite of the many criticisms, Shake Shack Toronto continues to draw in a disproportionate number of positive reviews, praising the chain for their classic smash burgers, hand spun milkshakes and groovy interiors.

shake shack torontoSome even say that the food at the Toronto location is better than in the U.S., but hey, don't take my word for it — go try for yourself.

Shake Shack Toronto is located at 10 Dundas East.

Lead photo by

Fareen Karim


Latest Videos



Latest Videos


Latest in Eat & Drink

Ice cream possibly containing gravel and plastic recalled across Canada

Toronto's food scene just got a major shoutout in the New York Times

All the new Ontario restaurants that were added to the Toronto Michelin Guide 2026

Here's every Toronto restaurant that made the Michelin Guide in 2026

Toronto's best baguette and croissant to be crowned once and for all next month

Celebrities have been spotted at restaurants all over Ontario lately

Much-anticipated Toronto restaurant finally opens next week

Some of the best food in Toronto right now isn't coming out of restaurants