Tuesday, February 14, 2012Mostly Cloudy -1°C
Film

The Cineforum is dead

Posted by Robyn Urback / August 23, 2010

cineforum torontoCan you imagine a Toronto without posters advertising, "What I learned from LSD" and "Darkside of Oz"?

Well, it may soon become a reality.

Reg Hartt's Cineforum, which has been running at several venues since 1968, is being shut down for good. Run primarily out of Hartt's home, the Cineforum has been a place for Torontonians to watch private screenings of films and participate in discussions for $10 a day.

It was shut down for the first time back in the 1990s.

"The first time the Cineforum was shut down I sat here drinking beer, watching television, thinking about finding a venue where I could continue my programs and reflecting on how boring everything was going to be," Hartt said in an email to Mayor Miller. Luckily, it was resurrected with the help of Hartt's friend Jane Jacobs (see the bottom of the post for a fan latter from Jacobs to Hartt).

But of course, that wasn't the end. In the spring, Hartt received a notice of violation from the city's Licensing and Standards division for operating a theatre out of his home. According to NOW Magazine, it was likely that someone issued a complaint. "The city doesn't go rooting out people who are violating zoning," said Licensing and Standards chair Howard Moscoe.

Then, this past Friday, another individual came from Municipal Licensing and Standards and informed Hartt that a letter had been sent to his landlord threatening legal action unless the program was shut down. So it will be shut down.

"The Cineforum is dead. It is going to stay dead," Hartt wrote.

"There is someone who wanted it killed. They succeeded. They used the city has their knife but it was their hand that used it. I don't really care whose hand held the knife."

At the end of a long letter to Mayor David Miller, Harrt concludes with the following:

"What were you banned for?" I will be asked.

"For welcoming strangers into my house," I will reply.

Jane Jacobs letter

Lead photo by ampro of Flickr.

Discussion

34 Comments

agentsmith / August 23, 2010 at 12:09 pm
user-pic
I was always curious about those "Nosferatu/Radiohead" posters, but never checked it out. What was the place like inside?
Casey Jones / August 23, 2010 at 12:13 pm
user-pic
Good riddance. The fact that the man got away with charging absurd prices to screen movie torrents in his living room for so long disgusts me. The Cineforum will only be grieved by delusional film students and culture-hungry yuppies with cash to burn.
Weifuni / August 23, 2010 at 12:16 pm
user-pic
@agentsmith--It was the best place I ever lived: awesome tenant artwork, wacky posters, multilingual quotations, and some of the coolest people I've met in Toronto. It is very saddening to learn that it will be shutting down as a film venue.
John / August 23, 2010 at 12:17 pm
user-pic
Crummy. But with the Underground Cinema on Spadina and the wonderful resurrection of neighbourhood cinemas in the last few years, maybe the hole that Cineforum filled has now been filled by other players.
Mike replying to a comment from agentsmith / August 23, 2010 at 01:01 pm
user-pic
Same with me. I often saw posters that piqued my interest, but never got around to see anything.
Artjetset / August 23, 2010 at 01:27 pm
user-pic
It is really sad to see Cineforum shut down. Reg Hart is a Toronto cultural institution. I saw Metropolis at cineforum in the late 90s.

Admittedly paying money to watch films in someone's living room seems bizarre... but his pre-film monologues were insightful and the collective sense of community is rare and precious.
Community is something that doesn't exist in today's society. When was the last time you met your neighbour?!!

Bring back Cineforum!! Free Reg!
scottd / August 23, 2010 at 02:25 pm
user-pic
Now Reg can concentrate on paying all the royalties he owes since 1968.
bah / August 23, 2010 at 02:27 pm
user-pic
So much f'ing garbage produced by this guy over the years - thousands and thousands of posters for what - 8 people to watch a movie in his living room?

Of course, I'm sure he declared the admission income on his income taxes. Surrrrrrrrre he did.

Good riddance.

dnr / August 23, 2010 at 02:40 pm
user-pic
Cineforum was vital back in the early 80's when most people didn't even own VCR's but now with so many other venues and the internet I'm surprised he lasted this long.
Shirley Hughes / August 23, 2010 at 02:58 pm
user-pic
Reg Hartt has done more for film discussion in this city than anyone or anything. He leaves institutions like Cinematheque eating his dust. I'm not saying you have to love him or even like him but give him his due and respect. He was screening films and fostering discussion now for decades-it was never about just watching a film. No one was forced to go to him to watch films and scottd-he has had for years clearance from both the major distributors of film in this country to screen films, but I am sure you just made your remark for a reason not linked to fact. I do know this for fact.
For those who went there at his house, or different clubs or back at Mercer St or way back in time at Innis and gained from it all, this is a body blow, for those of you who never went for whatever reason,I am sad for you, you won't know what you've missed, for those who say good riddance-your opinion is yours but try to be less mean spirited.
Ryan Thomas / August 23, 2010 at 03:25 pm
user-pic
This is something unique and worth saving.
Reg, BlogTO - you have our swords.

http://www.switchvertising.com/
P Dot / August 23, 2010 at 04:13 pm
user-pic
Although I don't really agree with him going I must say it was a total ripoff. I remember going there with the 3 other people to see Nosferatu/Radiohead and couldn't wait to leave. His preaching before the show was what turned me off most. Later Reginald.
Bill Henderson / August 23, 2010 at 04:53 pm
user-pic
I heard Reg on the CBC but never heard of him before. Originals are indeed rare. I would come and have a beer and watch a movie with this guy. Reg says he is going to open a new home venue called "Public Enemy Number One" or something along those lines. Let's hope he does. Good post, Robyn.
APOW / August 23, 2010 at 06:06 pm
user-pic
yr gay


-


So much f'ing garbage produced by this guy over the years - thousands and thousands of posters for what - 8 people to watch a movie in his living room?

Of course, I'm sure he declared the admission income on his income taxes. Surrrrrrrrre he did.

Good riddance.
M / August 23, 2010 at 06:06 pm
user-pic
Reg, we are there for you!! I always said that I would make it out one time, and now am really regretting missing out on the opportunity in taking part in a uniquely Toronto experience.

You have many supporters in this city. If we can help in any way in reclaiming your theatre back, let us know.
Parker / August 23, 2010 at 06:30 pm
user-pic
However dodgy, the Cineforum is a Toronto landmark, like the Matador, that served the city's young and starving for culture and community. Too bad.
E.D. / August 23, 2010 at 06:56 pm
user-pic
I believe the saddest part about this story (and the following commentary) is the fact that one person running films from their basement to an audience numbering in the single digits is what constitutes a "cultural icon" in this city. I was born, raised and grew up in this city, and now being in my mid twenties, as I travel and discover more around me, I realize how little Toronto really has to offer. This is just another in a long line of confirmations of that fact.
n / August 23, 2010 at 07:07 pm
user-pic
I saw the posters but never went. I did not want to go to someone's house. Whatever he was or wasn't I am sure it's debatable. Yes, I did hear about his hitting on male patrons, but that would not have been a problem (as I am not gay). Whenever I thought about going it was the intros that prevented me and the absurd prices. Weird movies and weird intros.
I don't know I used to go to rep cinemas and I liked them as well. Until I got DVD. I also go to Cinematheque and a few other cinames, but Reg Hartt just never appealed to me. I don't know if I am sorry to see him go - maybe he belonged to some other era?
avatude / August 23, 2010 at 07:10 pm
user-pic
Very sad, lack of appreciation of etc, loss of great cultural etc, end of an era etc. Certainly.

That said, Hartt is a myopic, narcissistic "let me school you with my brilliant intellect" prick and I'll be glad when his insufferable posturing as an icon or an "institution" or a counter-cultural revolutionary martyr-sage is received by a vastly smaller audience of adoring film student guppies.

Dude's ego is bigger than a whale and has five times the blowholes, just saying.
mondayjane replying to a comment from Parker / August 23, 2010 at 07:14 pm
user-pic
right on the money, Parker.

As Toronto loses more and more of its charm with every passing day, things like "Cineforum" - agree with it or no - bring interest and artistic value to an otherwise increasingly corporate table.
Drunkenrantinthespiritofit / August 23, 2010 at 08:29 pm
user-pic
Went a couple of times, his intros are interesting, his library of prints is impressive.

If you don't like flyers go live in the suburbs, if you don't like strange characters, go live in the suburbs, if you don't like strange films, go live in the suburbs. If you hate other people, go live in a shack in the woods. Toronto needs more odd ball, but harmless citizens. Toronto is small but don't discount it, we have people like this guy, one of this guy with his craziness equals 20 people living in Nowhereville.
imshitfacedtoo replying to a comment from Drunkenrantinthespiritofit / August 23, 2010 at 10:24 pm
user-pic
life is delightfully replete with oddities, even in the suburbs. pick up a steven king novel, bucko.
Gabes / August 23, 2010 at 10:48 pm
user-pic
Is his name really Reg Hartt. So sick!!! The only thing better than that is Judge Reinhold!! For Real though Son!!!
Bryanna / August 24, 2010 at 08:14 am
user-pic
Holy, some of you people are so cynical -- does it make you feel good/more cool/wiser?

Christ, don't go to the damn thing if you don't like it.

Bryanna replying to a comment from mondayjane / August 24, 2010 at 08:16 am
user-pic
Agree with mondayjane
ArcAngel / August 24, 2010 at 08:21 am
user-pic
Way to rock the crazy person hand written letter.
valerieinto / August 24, 2010 at 05:50 pm
user-pic
I'd like to hear from the person who made the complaint that shut him down.

I went to one of his Looney Tunes nights when I was in university in the '80's. Dude was intense, but it was interesting stuff, and it's hard to fault someone that passionate about something.

What he was doing was sort of iconic for this town, but I'm not putting him on any pedestals. By the same token, he doesn't deserve people shitting on him either. He was just a guy wanting to share stuff with people that they probably wouldn't otherwise have had a chance to experience. These days, people have a little more of a chance, as internet video has advanced. He hardly made a ton of cash from the times he showed anything vaguely copyrighted, and I don't think he caused anyone any harm in general.

I'm hoping equally passionate people can utilize the Underground Cinema and the internet and who-knows-what-else to pick up the torch and share ideas they find cool. Maybe they'll even put up posters about it.
stedmond / August 26, 2010 at 09:35 pm
user-pic

Lol ! it's funny to read stale,cheesy,unoriginal
people talk shit about Reg Hartt, what have they ever done !
he has lived exactly what he tries to inspire
the people who attend his programs to do !
he has lived his own way, He is a true original !
He has put countless people on to films
they never would have seen otherwise, & he did
without funding from the government (like the Cinemathique) since the late 60's !
He does what he does for the love of cinema & art.
He has encouraged an abundance of young artists to
keep doing what they are doing.
I think what is being done to him now is pathetic.
Toronto needs more people like Reg Hartt.
BUt I am sure He will Keep Doing what he loves.
Fantomex replying to a comment from imshitfacedtoo / September 24, 2010 at 03:00 am
user-pic
Life in the suburbs is shit, that's why I moved to downtown. There is <i>NOTHING</i> there except more strip malls, plazas industrial sites, strip malls, plazas, subdivisions, parks, schools, more strip malls, more plazas....you get the message. That's all that suburbia is. No bars, restos, cafes, local shops, movie theaters spaces like Cineforum...anything you want has to be driven to, or you walk to the bus. And the local plaza/strip mall? Mostly a place where chain stores flourish, <i>and nothing else</i> (although the plaza where I grew up in the Willowdale section of North York at least had a few independent businesses. <i>These days</i>, most of the businesses in those suburban strip malls are independent, but that's mostly because they're Southeast Asian, the majority of the people who most likely now live in Willowdale.)

Other than that, what is there else to do? Go to a night club? Good luck, unless you want to go have a few beers at the Cloverdale Mall location of The Keg. Want to watch a movie other than blockbusters (not that there's anything wrong with that)? Sorry, got to get on the bus for the subway downtown! Want to go to a poetry reading? Same thing! Dancing? Ditto! Street festivals? Nothing doing (anything like that has to be held in a park, or in the parking lot of a mall!) And places like Cineforum? Affording a semi-detached house or house like I used to live in is hard; holding anything like a film screening is harder still. <i>That's why</i> suburbia sucks, and why I wish my parents had bought a house nearby around Parkdale in 1970 rather than move out to Willowdale <i>before they had a car</i>! Suburbia is now just going to end up like the inner city of most North American cities one day-looking like shit compared to downtown because of the white flight.

As it is, I will miss Cineforum, and hope that Reg takes up the offer made at NOW Magazines online forum to have him move to Montreal and set up there. Or any city where there's no bullshit law forbidding film screenings in a home.
Andreyas / December 26, 2010 at 04:19 am
user-pic
I interested in any method to be accessory cold hard cash on the internet. I include tried innumerable things and bear not been flourishing but I am not thriving to give up. It is today my pastime! I am amazed at the energy and dynamics of the internet marketing community.
Gennet / January 27, 2011 at 03:19 pm
user-pic
I'm new to Toronto and always looking for something fun and interesting to do. Although I wouldn't have spent $10 @the Cineforum, I definitely would've spent $5 to sit in someone's livingroom, watch a movie and be a part of an intimate lively debate before and/or after a movie.

Fantomex replying to a comment from Gennet / January 27, 2011 at 10:34 pm
user-pic
And now you can, because Reg is bag in business! Isn't life great?
Gennet / January 28, 2011 at 12:40 am
user-pic
O ... M ... G, THE SEX & VIOLENCE CARTOON FESTIVAL?!?!? I am sooo there! Thanks Fantomex!
KL replying to a comment from E.D. / January 28, 2011 at 09:19 am
user-pic
Right on.

Add a Comment

Other Cities: VancouverMontreal