Cinephile Report: Marie Antoinette Directed by Sophia Coppola

20061029_marie.jpgSo far 2006 is turning out to be a most bizarre year for films and their critical acceptance. Almost all of my favorite flicks this year are loved by one half the critics and considered career blunders by the other half.

I'm a fan of Lost In Translation but I wasn't sure if it was Bill Murray or Sophia Coppola who made the magic happen in that match up.

But thanks to her past films I was immediately interested to see what Sophia Coppola would do with a punk rock, modern reference laced retelling of the story of famed monarch, Marie Antoinette, especially after hearing it was boo'd at it's premiere in Cannes.

The film is slow but we are rewarded for our time with some really sumptuous visuals, great costumes and the true beauty of the Palace of Versailles. (Trivia: It was the first film production given permission to shoot inside the palace.)

Kirsten Dunst gives her best performance since Interview With A Vampire as the teenage girl thrown into a political marriage with the prince of France. Marie struggles to seduce her awkward husband so she can produce a son and solidify her place and her country's place in the French Royal family and it's in this fight where the meat of the role lies .

Dunst, in a strong and subtle performance plays her as a sensible young women levelheaded against the catty gossip of the aristocracy while still being innocent and distracted.

Historians have been cruel to the film and it's performances but I feel they are missing the point and perspective of Coppola's vision entirely.

The film, complete with a few modern 80's punk soundtrack choices, zeros in on the mind set of Marie Antoinette. She is simply a teenage girl thrown into circumstances that result in her becoming the Queen during a time of opulence where there is a dangerous ignorance to the world outside the palace walls.

Coppola completely eliminates the stuffy constrictions of period films and gives us real teenagers who get drunk, like to shop, have crushes and who, despite their social rank, think the rituals of the monarchy are a bit much. She never takes this relaxed structure too far and it always seems to support her characters and situations.

It's about time someone injected some life into the tired Euro-period film genre. Coppola allows us to finally connect with the characters in a period piece and takes them out of a staunch historical framework and makes them into living, breathing people.

The film suffers a bit of pacing issues but make strong choices especially with it's simple understated ending. I never found the modern references anything but exciting and essential to the realistic teenage wavelength that the film rides on.

Pretty, punchy and poignant, this film may not be everyone's cup of tea but it's certainly unique and beautiful.

Go ahead, eat the cake. It's pretty damn good.

Reader Reviews and Comments

Submit a Review or Comment

Hi ... I don't want to come off as uptight and whiny, although I probably would ... but Matt, you might have liked to have someone skim through this before posting. There are lots of omitted commas, a few long rambling sentences, and some strange sentence construction.

I know blog material should be cut some slack, but this isn't a personal journal; it's fairly prominent (voted best blog by NOW!) with lots of contributors and should have some tighter standards.

It's nice to hear you enjoyed the film though! I've been looking forward to see just the visuals myself, and I'm not too worried about historical or political issues.

Thanks!

Posted by: Gloria at October 28, 2006 11:30 PM

HAHAHA
Thanks for the heads up
Without it I wouldn't have noticed I posted my draft by accident :)
This probably isn't too much better it's been a long night I shoot my first big budget short film tommorow and I'm all mush...but do go see it, it's a very different take and I love things that are different even if they aren't perfect at least they are trying something.

Posted by: MattThomas at October 29, 2006 1:12 AM

I'm a guy - didn't like this film too much. My wife liked this film quite a bit.

So, I think...
- Marie Antoinette appeals to women
- Lost in Translation appeals to men

Discuss?

Posted by: RandomTangent at October 29, 2006 1:45 PM

I enjoyed LiT and haven't seen Marie Antoinette yet, but I'd hazard a stab:

LiT: Opens with Scarlett Johansson's meshnet-panty-clad behind and contains Japanese strippers.

Marie Antoinette: Not so much, but substitutes fancy cakes and shopping.

I think you're right!

Posted by: Gloria at October 29, 2006 4:18 PM

Does BlogTO have a copy editor or some other means of quality control? This post made me cranky.

Posted by: James at October 29, 2006 6:12 PM

I am, last time I checked, a man to the core, and I loved Marie Antoinette. Of course, I liked LiT better, but I do feel that the visual cornucopia that MA featured was a delight to the eyes and kept me engaged the entire way through.

Posted by: Sameer Vasta at October 30, 2006 8:45 AM

My husband and I enjoyed both films. There's a real melancholy to MA that we found moving and thoughtful. Like LiT, it's the kind of film that sticks with you.

Posted by: Miranda at October 30, 2006 10:21 AM

Post a comment

Remember Me?

Email This Entry

Email 'Cinephile Report: Marie Antoinette Directed by Sophia Coppola' to: Message (optional):
Your email address:

Please type the verification code displayed in the image:

By forwarding this entry to a friend, we do not opt you or your friend into
receiving any additional mailings from blogTO. We hate spam too.
Disclaimer: Comments and blog entries represent the viewpoints of the individual and no one else.