Saturday, May 26, 2012Mostly Cloudy 24°C
Fashion & Style

Tavi Gevinson, Style Rookie

Posted by Kevin Naulls / June 21, 2010

Tavi GevinsonWhen I was 14 years of age, the internet was bright, shiny and new. I remember creating a fan website for the WB series Roswell, which was my foray into the world of online journalism. It was a Geocities website, and unlike today -- with the importance of Google ad revenue -- my love was free.

A similar comparison can be made to Tavi Gevinson, a 14 year old Style Rookie who spoke at Moses Znaimer's ideaCity last week. For those who may not know, ideaCity is a conference held annually that brings together bright minds and young talent - essentially, it's a collection of inspirational discussions, in addition to a geek love-in, with catered eats and a bevy of "social media experts." There, I said it.

Tavi GevinsonIs Tavi a social media expert? No, not really. Is she a fashion expert? Not quite, but I doubt she would claim to be. Her method is not to play up her age, her awkward yet humbling speaking voice, or even the fact that she is wearing Miu Miu, a brand that is coveted by girls and women around the world. She writes about fashion because she's interested and it just so happens, so are her 1.5 million monthly unique visitors to her blog. Despite the endless criticism she receives for being young in what "should" be an "adult" industry, Tavi ignores the nay-sayers and real world trolls who attempt to criticize what she says is "just joining the conversation."

Awkward...

Moses Znaimer brazenly asked the sprite-like Tavi, "who are these people you hang out with?" A natural question for a media mogul and a man who is successful because of the question "who do you know?" Tavi could not have been more reluctant, but can you blame her? Tavi is unlike the average celebrity-consumed ne'er-do-well, and as such, was not interested in broadcasting her seemingly important friends. She graciously forfeited the opportunity to name drop, which was the exact moment I decided she was the real deal.

Style RookieI spoke to Tavi about authenticity, elitism, thrifting and the foolhardy debate of editor vs blogger:

You're often criticized as being a novelty of the fashion industry, given your age. How do you respond your critics?

I don't. I am not willing to step outside of myself to consider myself a novelty. Sometimes, without reading, there is the impression that I am a rich, Upper East Side, Gossip Girl type, but I always wonder, did you even read my blog? Because... if you did... That sounds snobby, but whatever.

Not at all. A lot of people will make assumptions about others, especially if they are younger and garnering some level of success greater than their own. Do you ever pander to your followers? Are there ever moments where you write specifically for your audience instead of yourself?

The reason why people come to my blog is because I try to do what I want. Blogging is democratic, so people can, like, choose to read what they want. Everyone wants their writing to be read.

Tavi GevinsonIs there ever a moment where you feel there is too much information being dispensed? Bloggers are endlessly criticized for their impact on the journalism industry - where do you stand?

There is never too much information. I don't like elitism, so I believe that people should read and write whatever they want. Like, people are not going to stop reading Vogue because I am writing a blog.

Right. The arguments are always so completely unfounded. So-called blogger captured market statistics are untested, unproven. Age can't really be a factor either, since you are freely sharing your opinion on fashion, not advocating the demise of print journalism.

Yeah, it's like, I love magazines. I spend all my money on more magazines. I don't think that my views are going to take away from their success.

It all seems to relate to fear...

I agree. Paranoia, fear, and ego.

A conversation can't destroy the industry.

Exactly. It is more democratic, and each review or blog adds to the conversation. Everyone has an opinion. Everyone adds their own critique to my comments, which shows that people want in on the conversation. This all comes from print.

Especially considering that your site includes inspirations which are regularly derived from editorials you have seen. The same magazines that fear extinction.

Tavi GevinsonI don't want to bombard you with blogging questions, so lets change it up. Before you were mixing designer (Rodarte, Miu Miu) with thrifted finds, I remember your outfits were predominantly vintage. Are you a hunter, or do you go in and out of stores, with a specific piece in mind each time you go shopping?

I like both, but I am more interested in digging through piles of clothes. There is more of a challenge to looking through. When you hunt, you find the cooler clothes.

---

Much like Tavi hunts for the ideal find, she too was spotted amongst a growing population of bloggers. Her hook may be that she was only 13 years old, but she continues to succeed as a voice of a younger generation of eloquent speakers.

At ideaCity, Tavi had her fan girl moment for 90s publication Sassy Magazine, a glossy that was lauded as the anti-teen girl mag. Her speech seemed more pitchy than informative, as she was discussing her interest in creating a new Sassy.

Tavi believes it will be a publication that addresses politics in the form of Third Wave feminism, with emphasis on indie music and fashion for the sake of fashion. It is tough to say whether there is room for her vision of a magazine for womyn, but that has more to do with the current state of print media then her ability to pitch a magazine concept.

In the mean time, Tavi says, "I want to do everything. I want to do so many things" when I asked her if the blog could be a catalyst for bigger and better opportunities. Sassy seems to be the one big thing on her mind, which is a project she says "is really important" because "[she] always starts things and then forgets about them. [She] can't stop thinking about this and wants to make something happen."

You may be on the fence about a young girl who is sharing her unfiltered critique of fashion and culture, but pick your battles wisely. If you care more about her age, she won't listen. She sees nothing novel in something she finds so captivating, so your concerns will fall on deaf ears. However, if you would like to join a growing global discussion, the internet is ready for you and so is Tavi.

New student? Here are some Toronto-based bloggers to keep it homegrown:

Difficult Daughters

Final Fashion

I Want I Got

Dressed for Dinner

Textstyles

photos by Angela Y Martin

Discussion

26 Comments

dolce / June 21, 2010 at 09:48 am
user-pic
Ugh, she is so annoying. Her personal sense of style is awful, her blog is a poor read and the only novelty thing about it is how young she is. There are so many more amazing fashion bloggers out there, with style and knowledge of fashion that surpasses her pseudo-intellectual fourteen-year-old mentality about couture. I applaud her for keeping strong and continuing writing even under criticism, but I quite frankly would rather read a Teen Beat magazine than read anything she writes about "fashion".
Sharp / June 21, 2010 at 10:15 am
user-pic
Where's her neck?
Crystal / June 21, 2010 at 12:50 pm
user-pic
Are you kidding me?
It's so refreshing that Tavi doesn't bother with the people that are against her. While everyone's opinions are valid - I think her blog and the way she presents herself is beyond her years - she has so much poise and promise.
Her style is hers - and that's what fashion is - a reflection of her personality.
I'm not sure how she seems pseudo intellectual based on her responses from this interview alone.
Team Tavi!
lahv / June 21, 2010 at 02:38 pm
user-pic
She is a total brat, hands down.
Serah-Marie McMahon / June 21, 2010 at 03:24 pm
user-pic
Clearly, these negative comments are left by people who have 1) never met her (possibly have not even have read her blog) or 2) don't know much about fashion. Or both. She is a sweet, humble, whip-smart girl, and many of you would do well to remember she's a REAL person - I believe in criticizing culture, but there is no need for these harsh and frankly immature comments. Especially since there are completely unfounded. Don't type anything you wouldn't say to the face of a 14 year old kid and her mother.
Anupa / June 21, 2010 at 04:31 pm
user-pic
@Dolce

Her blog is a poor read? I know it's been cited many times in the past month, but HAVE you actually read/digested this?
http://www.thestylerookie.com/2010/05/can-i-just-say.html

And sure there're a lot of amazing style/fashion bloggers (by using the term blogger I'm assuming you're excluding magazine/newspaper journalists) that take awesome photos and have a great eye—but there actually aren't that many who can WRITE and formulate a real (non-sponsored) opinion, as well as Tavi.
dolce replying to a comment from Serah-Marie McMahon / June 21, 2010 at 05:55 pm
user-pic
@ Serah Yes, I have read her blog. She may be articulate, but she still reads like a fourteen year old. I don't find anything particularly interesting about her viewpoint and trust me, I know quite a bit about couture. "Whip smart"? She writes like any other marginally intelligent pre-pubescent teenager with a blog, except her's is focused on fashion. I didn't realize fourteen year olds were precious, unspoiled flowers who haven't been tainted be society. If she's old enough to actually speak at IdeaCity (which I find ridiculous, there are far more apt candidates), then she is old enough to take "big girl criticism".

Her opinions are poorly regurgitated viewpoints of about a hundred other people and nothing about her writing is "fresh" and "new". She is a novelty: plain and simple. And the only reason why she is a novelty is because of how young she really is.

@Anupa: I disagree, there are plenty of people in the blogosphere who can write and formulate "real" opinions. To say that Tavi, of all people, is one of the few is a little naive.
dolce replying to a comment from Serah-Marie McMahon / June 21, 2010 at 06:02 pm
user-pic
@Anupa: Also, regarding her Terry Richardson call out, I have read it. I'm happy she is not on the "Terry Richardson fan train" but there are a thousand other people who hate everything Terry Richardson stands for, including me. I've been involved in rigorous debates on this subject alone on many other communities, public forums, etc. I never said Tavi was some sort of awful person who sucks at life and should give up blogging, I just don't think she is as spectacular as people make her out to be. I see her as an overrated novelty that will probably fade away sooner or later.
Serah-Marie McMahon / June 21, 2010 at 08:18 pm
user-pic
@dolce Last time I checked, "she's so annoying" and "She's a total brat" is not big girl criticism, it's immature name calling. (I know you didn't say the last one, but my initial comment referenced it also) Those are the kinds of comments people throw around thinking it doesn't actually apply to an real person on the other end. They are not thoughtful, well-considered or accurate, which is what I look for in critical commentary. In fact, I'd go as far as to say I've never read a single critical analysis of her work that was thoughtful an didn't revolve around pot shots.

Yes, she is 14. And yes, that is why she is getting attention. But should we really be shaming young girls into silence, telling them they don't deserve attention for voicing their opinion? And because they are young, they are not good enough to be accomplishing what they are striving to?

I'd argue Tavi's was one of the most important voices at Idea City. Yes she delivered her speech like a 14-year-old. A 14-year-old who understands the difference between waves of feminism, and had the optimism to assumed the audience did too. Who rallied a cry for a change in the way beauty and identity is being presented to young girls, and one who takes ownership in working towards that change on a personal level.

Fashion is world in which billions of young girls are made to feel small, and she is one small girl behaving big, and putting her name behind it. You don't even have the guts to put your real name or link on a blogto comment. We should do everything in our power to encourage her.
Liza / June 21, 2010 at 09:54 pm
user-pic
Serah-Marie: I agree with you 100%. Well said.

My two cents: Tavi's blog is thoughtful and smart and often quite funny and sweet as well (I really don't see the "total brat" dismissal - strange comment, and a little Clueless/Mean Girls for my taste). So she sees the world through a young fashion-loving 3rd-wave feminist girl's eye? Great. It's inspiring and invigorating to hear from a still very young woman with real, interesting perspectives and enthusiasms - and any young woman who serves as an outspoken, strong, and opinionated role model for other teenaged girls is a good thing.
piccola / June 22, 2010 at 09:25 pm
user-pic
I don't know much about Tavi, except that she's clearly full of initiative and a pretty sharp girl. She should be given a fair chance, not attacked (or worse, patronized) because she's precocious.

Still, we have to recognize that a lot of her success has to do with her socio-economic background. That she has access to blogging tools (computer, Internet, a decent camera, etc) -- not to mention to couture -- and has parents who encourage her to pursue her interests, gives her advantages that others might not have.

Of course, plenty of kids have the same advantages and do nothing with them, so she's not without credit.
Fo real.....?!!? / June 23, 2010 at 11:18 pm
user-pic
Did you really link to your own blog as a top Toronto blog in your OWN article? Does BlogTO promote your self-promotion?

It was a nice interview but you lost me at the end with that.
reh reh / June 24, 2010 at 12:03 am
user-pic
i heart difficult daughters!
oh, and Tavi too!
kevinn replying to a comment from Fo real.....?!!? / June 24, 2010 at 12:20 am
user-pic
Hey, I hear you wo/man. I had this conversation with a friend tonight (re: shameless self-promotion).

I don't cover the same demo that BlogTO does and I don't really mind being called out on my effort to showcase some more fashion, outside of Toronto. I spoke with Tim when I was first picked up as a writer for BlogTO and he said he did not mind linking to my blog (for additional content). Thanks for the kudos on the interview and as far as I am concerned, this shit is definitely "fo real."
Marc / June 24, 2010 at 12:38 pm
user-pic
Sorry, but that title is a complete opposite of the truth. That's not style, that's a costume. It's not even original, it's more like the more flamboyant-bordering tacky/silly segment of people (how they dress) found in Tokyo. So she's not original as well, if you want to go in that direction, which she seems like she's trying to do.
LacyLeathers / June 24, 2010 at 07:12 pm
user-pic
BLOGGING...BLOGGING?....where is ~Spencer~ when we need him....I just love love love every thing about ~TAVI ~ even her worst outfit makes me laugh smile and get happy. She is like Irish Spring bar soap & Spearmint toothpaste ~ She can do no wrong ~ (except praising obummer ~ that's took major wind from MY SAILS. This sunshine kid has a future to knock the BALL out of the PARK ~ I see the stars, moon & space welcoming her for eternity..... and that's a good sign.
Stay true to 2~U & show us them tricks up your sleeves ~ ~GO TAVI ~ I CAN'T WAIT~
dolce replying to a comment from Serah-Marie McMahon / June 24, 2010 at 08:29 pm
user-pic
Please tell me where I said, or even hinted, towards shaming her into never voicing her opinion again. I simply don't like her blog, her viewpoints and the hype surrounding her. Imo, she's like the fashion world's Justin Bieber: marginally interesting, but oversaturated and not as great as people make her out to be.

I'm not going to fall on my hands and knees in praise because some upper-class white girl has an opinion on couture and blogs about it online articulately, thanks to her expensive educated upbringing. Sorry.
Online casino bonus / July 1, 2010 at 02:20 am
user-pic
This is my first time i visit here. I found so many interesting stuff in your blog especially its discussion. From the tons of comments on your articles, I guess I am not the only one having all the enjoyment here! keep up the good work.
Xspot / July 7, 2010 at 05:54 am
user-pic
Well when you come from a wealthy family ...you basically can get whatever you want.
I mean the media leaves out her status of living as in her family is rich and all to help her out with starting her career....good example ...Katrine Tuttle she comes from a wealth family who can pay for her fashion shows and sewers to complete her collection but the media doesn't mention that on her bio except she is a self thought designer..blah blah...started her own collection by the age of 20 blah blah.But in the other hand Tevi loves fashion passionately and that is the end of that story.Give the girl credit she is nice and talkative...her style might not be your taste but she at least takes risks to try something new and bold.
liz replying to a comment from dolce / September 4, 2010 at 05:32 pm
user-pic
Those who criticize Tavi in any way are missing the point of her free sprit, independent thinking and articulate creativity. You go girl!
(hey, whats your kid doing? I mean WHAT are they doing with themselves? Are they using their beautiful mind and senses?)
EMILY Conner / October 1, 2010 at 03:39 pm
user-pic
CAN WE PLEASE DISCUSS YOUR FAN WEBSITE FOR ROSWELL!? WE MAY HAVE NOTES TO COMPARE.
Eloise / October 3, 2010 at 09:01 am
user-pic
You guys are just jealous, end of story.
Laurie / November 2, 2010 at 04:06 pm
user-pic
Everyone who is against is closed minded and jealous. End of story, stop picking a 14 year old girl doing what she enjoys. People should be happy for her, she is probably the happiest little girl out there lol Get a gold of yourselves.
Laurie / November 2, 2010 at 04:06 pm
user-pic
get a hold* of yourselves.
Killy replying to a comment from dolce / December 5, 2010 at 04:19 am
user-pic
Fashion bitches come out to play...

Leave her alone! She's extremely smart, inspiring, and creative. I think about myself at that age and I was too overcome with "drama" to get anything done. Now I'm 20 and wish I had gotten to blogging sooner.
Me / April 16, 2011 at 01:32 pm
user-pic
What 14 year old can afford the brand names she wears? Prada? Miu Miu? I'd be more interested to read about a normal 14 year old who makes the most of her Wal Mart shopping sprees then Miu MIu.

Add a Comment

Other Cities: VancouverMontreal