LCBO gets New, Larger Paper Bags

It's good to know they're making a comeback! Let's hope that there's a great switchover to paper in the next months.

That said, I'd rather see more people bring their own bags when they shop.

I've noticed that more customers at the Dominion across the street from me bring their own.

And not just the Dominion. It's all over the Yonge/College area. People with their own bags--what a concept!

I like the idea, though I've always thought that the LCBO has the best plastic bags.

They're so durable that I find myself reusing them frequently and for extended periods of time. They're much better than plastic bags from most grocery stores, which are only suitable to be reused once (usually as garbage bags.)

The LCBO plastic bags are great (for their size and durability), and most certainly are reusable, but I'm willing to bet the vast majority of them get one use and go to landfill pretty quickly.

Same here, Rick. My dad's been taking his spare shirts to work in the rattiest LCBO bag. The U of T bookstore also gave out really sturdy plastic bags, and recently has switched to degradeable ones.

"more environmentally sound paper bag"

Where do you get that insane idea? environmentally sound paper bag is like a "green SUV"

Years ago when the wastefulness of the plastic bags of the day first hit the news Pollution Probe and other groups successfully lobbied Canadian Grocery Stores to keep paper bags out of the stores (unlike in the US) in favour of thin film plastic because counter-intuitively thin film plastic is actually greener than paper.

Here's why MEC chose to go to cornstarch plastic, quoting from their site:

"Paper Bags Are Not the Answer

At first glance, paper bags seem to be the solution: they're made from a renewable resource, and they're biodegradable and recyclable. But paper bags consume many times more energy to create and transport than plastic bags. Manufacturing paper also puts out a considerable amount of air pollution and consumes a lot of water. In addition, paper bags are not as durable as plastic in wet weather."

While I don't necessarily agree that cornstarch plastic is as good as it looks I think you'll have to dig pretty deep to find someone informed in the environmental movement that would advocate for paper bags.

for god sake, stuff a few supermarket bags in your pockets, people. am i the only person in the world doing this? they're also free garbage bags!

A lot of LCBOs also have stickers at the tills that remind shoppers that they don't have to go plastic and give all the options they have to go bagless, including the paper bags.

There has been little reportage of this, but T&T Supermarket's plastic bags are biodegradable, or at least that's what it says on them. They don't feel the same as MEC's cornstarch plastic, but definitely not the same as traditional bags.

When I lived in Montreal, I always felt like the TV character - all major grocery stores give you a choice btw paper and plastic. I always chose paper and re-used it for my recycling and for general storage need around the house.

Nowadays I carry my own bags...

Chester:

By "more environmentally sound" I meant compared to cheap, non-biodegradable plastic. At the rate at which we're producing and filling landfill, I'm inclined to think that ANY reusable/recyclable container is better than one that will not go away.

how about not using ANY DISPOSABLE BAG and just using your messenger bag or backpack?

anything DISPOSABLE is wrong. try harder/

Don't know if it was just the lighting or what, but when I went to an LCBO in Oakville on Saturday, the plastic bag they handed me seemed to be tinted slightly green rather than the normal tone of off-white. Don't know if there's any change made to those too?

is paper really better for the environment?
doesn't paper come from... umm... trees?

i have to say that i don't like the plastic, it's way to hard to carry, but yes, it makes me feel like i'm in a movie... i just need some celery sticking up out the top and i'm there

my distrust of the paper will make me bring my own bags, so this is a good thing i guess

Ok, so maybe I need to do a little backpaddling here...

A friend of mine went to the LCBO and bought 2 bottles of wine. The clerk put one bottle in the small paper bag, then put it and the second bottle in the larger paper bag, then put that in the large plastic bag.

WTF!!!!!!!!!!????????

Jerrold wrote:
The clerk put one bottle in the small paper bag, then put it and the second bottle in the larger paper bag, then put that in the large plastic bag.

WTF!!!!!!!!!!????????

The clerks usually try to put at least one glass bottle in a slim paper bag in an effort to not have glass bottles clang together and then break.

Maybe the clerk also either thought that the larger paper bag wouldn't hold, or that the bottle could just use some extra padding.

what do you think of the bag it back program as an government environmental initiative?

What's worse:

2 bottles, one with a plastic collar thingy, in a plastic bag

or

2 bottles, one in a small paper bag, both in a larger paper bag, and that in a plastic bag

?