The Wedding Cake Shoppe

859 College Street       Website
Phone: 416.916.2253

Profile Map
Posted by Dar Mustafa
June 19, 2009

Rating: 3.7/5 (23 votes cast)

20090623_wedding_lead2.jpgOn our way to the Wedding Cake Shoppe, Melissa muses, "imagine one of us was going to pick out our wedding cake right now?"

The thought is more jarring to me than it probably should be. I thought we were just going to get some cupcakes. But it does serve the purpose reminding me that our destination is actually wedding cakes first, cupcakes second, which would be evident to most people (though I have a very selective consciousness) in the moniker.

20090623_wedding_01.jpgAnd what cakes they are! Many examples of these works of art dot the store, light up the window display and peek out from behind rows of the fresh-baked personal-size versions I am so fixated upon. Some impossibly ornate, some with modern patterns and colours that I have always wanted in my food, but nature wasn't kind enough to give me.

But it (nature) did allow this bright and lovely place to practically land on my doorstep a few months back, sneaking its way into my not infrequent moments of "weakness"- or, as I prefer "(in desperate need of) sweetness". The second I saw the signage go up, I knew that this was exactly what my neighbourhood and I needed.

Wedding Cake Shoppe
Wedding Cake ShoppeThe array of buttercreams is breathtaking; colourful and comprehensive, it's hard to narrow down a choice- even when taking home a half-dozen. I have done this more than once, and yes, I do share them with others; people like my roommate who literally exclaimed, "they're so light!" with his first bite. Mm-hmm.

Wedding Cake ShoppeThe cake is miraculously moist, living up to the expectation that the purveyors truly know what they are doing and can work a brand of magic that is impossible in your mortal kitchen. This happens less often than you may think.

So this is why my coconut cupcake enjoyed on this Friday afternoon is the third- yes, third- that I have had this week. I lament my lack of imagination to Melissa, "I keep coming back to the coconut," as though it were out of my control. Melissa says, "if it ain't broke..."

Wedding Cake ShoppeMs. Coelho, owner and cake artist extraordinaire, overhears and now knows that her establishment and I go way back. She seems pleased, and I seem sheepish, which seems right. The coconut proceeds to work its chewy voodoo on me, while Melissa (predictably) goes for the Chocolate Toffee, like a pro.

Wedding Cake ShoppeMelissa digs in, "wow, it's so light." Indeed they are; light like happiness.

Wedding Cake ShoppeAlmost as if answering my subconscious toffee jealousy, we are suddenly presented with a sample of cookies and chocolates provided by Christina of Les Fetes Sweets, sold here as well.

Tiny toffee cookies melt in my mouth so divinely, that know I have to try the chocolate-chip specimen, the base of which is so perfect to me (chewy, nutty and oat-y), that I accidentally consume some of the chocolate and don't even mind (I have a life-long, uncorrectable aversion to chocolate, for which I am very sorry). Our Americanos from I Deal Coffee give our table of sweet things the balance it needs.

Wedding Cake ShoppeSomehow, my dietary concerns are serendipitously taken care of, as the chocolate treat I am given is of the white variety. This is good news.

Wedding Cake ShoppeBy this time, I am convinced that a wedding is just an awesomely huge party with an awesomely huge cake. A cake more beautiful than any of my possessions and guarded by action figures. I could get into this.

Wedding Cake Shoppe
Wedding Cake Shoppe

Jennifer north on May 13, 2009 at 1:51 PM

I love this place! Best cupcakes ever.

Daniela on May 30, 2009 at 2:56 PM

Mmm...I'm getting hungry just thinking about this. The Wedding Cake Shoppe is right by my house and every time I walk by it I have to stop and stare, it's a beautiful store and the cakes look incredible!

Marnie on June 19, 2009 at 6:10 PM

Loveliest cupcakes in the city - and believe me, I've tried them all. The cake is dense and moist, the icing is fluffy and creamy. Mmmmm...!

Penny on June 23, 2009 at 9:48 AM

great article and pictures! I really need to go here now!!

Matt@BlogTO on June 23, 2009 at 10:01 AM

I've passed by this place so many times, and just salivate as I walk by. I may just have to make my way in one of these days.

Christina on June 23, 2009 at 10:29 AM

The angry couple topper is hilarious. For a divorce party right? Jon & Kate should get one each. Ooo...too soon... :\

Christina on June 23, 2009 at 10:33 AM

I'm looking at teh website and I'm confused. Where exactly is this shop? BlogTO is saying it's on College, but the website is saying the studio is at Eglinton West and the Allen AND/OR Queen West.
Unless there are more than one location??

Facebook

Tim on June 23, 2009 at 12:07 PM

They just moved to College. I guess they haven't updated their web site yet

Johnny Awesome on June 23, 2009 at 1:03 PM

We ordered our cake for our Wedding in September from here last month!
We got to taste test the different flavored cupcakes to decide on which filling we want. Cookies n' Cream it is!!
Couldnt agree more, they are so moist it was amazing.
Finally a reason to look forward to my wedding. hahaha.

Andrea on June 23, 2009 at 1:15 PM

I've never had of their cupcakes but I've been in twice (now realizing that it was pretty much criminal for me NOT to order something). I recently discovered this place after a trip to Pantry, one block over and across the street (College and Dovercourt).

I appreciated the cultural diversity in wedding cake toppers, as indicated in one of the photos above. In addition to traditional caucasian bride and groom, toppers included pregnant caucasian bride and groom, bride and groom with baby, groom and groom and non-white couple and more that were diverse and whimsical. The wedding cake toppers more accurately reflect the diversity of Toronto.

Next time I will try the cupcakes!

apetimberlake on June 23, 2009 at 2:37 PM , replying to a comment from Johnny Awesome

Be prepaired for an amazing cake.

We had our wedding at the Drake last summer and ordered form the wedding cake shoppe.

We ordered Strawberry Butter Cream and Vanilla cake.

EVERYONE including the Drake staff that were lucky enough to try a slice loved it!

Johnny Awesome on June 23, 2009 at 3:07 PM , replying to a comment from apetimberlake

Ya, we are really looking forward to the cake.
Would it be wrong to start the dinner with the cake, then move onto the main course?!!

Anne Welles on June 23, 2009 at 6:25 PM

Cute girls + yummy cupcakes + good music = Good Times!

Jennifer North on June 24, 2009 at 12:12 AM

mmm a feast for the eyes and the palate!

Jennifer North on June 24, 2009 at 12:13 AM

mmm a feast for the eyes and the palate!

Ashley on June 24, 2009 at 12:23 AM

mmm the cupcakes their are delish and too die for!

Martha K on June 24, 2009 at 9:15 AM

Best cookies in the city.

Crankypants on June 24, 2009 at 2:54 PM

Yes, the cupcakes are light, moist and, to be honest, happily NOT what I've been used to over the years. The cookies I've had are great, too! Extensive variety, great coffee, clean, cool and lovely shoppe – certainly far better than stopping in for donuts or crowding into a pushy café.

As well, the cake designs are incredible, and I've seen everyone on the (extremely) lovely staff at the shoppe working with couples-to-be: Everything is honest, up front and appropriate to the occasion. Planning a wedding can be a major headache, but from what I've seen of the staff and they way they work with the clients, they keep the fun of it all at the fore, with professionalism.

No, I'm not a shill for the shoppe. I just live in the neighbourhood and stop in a lot. And I'm glad they're here.

Add a Comment

Name: Email: URL:
Comment: