best pumpkin pie toronto

10 bakeries in Toronto making pumpkin pies for Thanksgiving

The best pumpkin pies in Toronto have what you need to end your Thanksgiving feast on a sweet note. Cozy as a warm sweater and made with spices that are synonymous with autumn, your must-have pie is waiting at one of these spots.

Here are bakeries in Toronto making pumpkin pies for Thanksgiving.

Staij & Co.

Place an order through this Cabbagetown bakery's website to get your hands on a $28 pumpkin pie made with their signature fluted all butter pastry and spiced pumpkin filling. 

Short & Sweet Bakeshop

Pumpkin pie (also $28) is available either "Fully Loaded" with fresh whipped cream and salted caramel or "Plain Jane" with no toppings from this bakery near Avenue and Lawrence.

Wanda's Pie in the Sky

Kensington Market has this popular pie destination that continuously bakes hundreds of pumpkin pies throughout the weekend in an effort not to sell out. They describe them as "deliciously spicy, creamy and impossible to stop eating."

Mabel's Bakery in the Junction

This bakery with multiple locations is known for its pies, and their pumpkin pie is just as scrumptious as their wild blueberry or sour cherry pies.

Gerrard Street Bakery

East Chinatown is home to this bakery where pumpkin pies ($30) will be available throughout the weekend on a first come, first serve basis. They might just be as good as their famous butter tarts.

Black Pony

Pick up a nine-inch pumpkin pie ($30) from this hangout in Little India. They make a lot but they're selling fast, though hopefully it'll still be possible to snap one up for dessert on the weekend.

Sweetie Pie

Non-vegan and vegan nine-inch pumpkin pies are available from this bakery with multiple locations, but you can always call to make sure before heading in.

The Rolling Pin

This shop near Avenue and Lawrence known for all kinds of baked treats and makes lots for walk-ins. They do a traditional pumpkin pie, as well as jacked up, chocolate and dulce de leche meringue versions. They even have a Biscoff pumpkin cheesecake.

Phipps Bakery Cafe

This charming bakery and cafe that's been in the Yonge and Eglinton area forever bakes furiously to supply dessert lovers with pumpkin pie. Available in eight-inch or 10-inch varieties, they do both a traditional version, and a version decorated with spiced pumpkin seeds.

Kensington Natural Bakery and Cafe

The OG for vegan and gluten-free pumpkin pies in Toronto is still the cheapest on this list. Pies start at only $11 and you can get a discount if you follow their IG account.

Lead photo by

Sweetie Pie. With files from Amy Carlberg


Latest Videos



Join the conversation Load comments

10 bakeries in Toronto making pumpkin pies for Thanksgiving

Leaflet | © Mapbox © OpenStreetMap Improve this map

Latest in Eat & Drink

Caribbean restaurant flagged for 10 infractions by Toronto health officials

Indigo has started to replace its Starbucks locations across Canada with a new coffee shop

100 essential restaurants in Toronto to add to your bucket list

Tim Hortons location hit with 7 infractions by Toronto health inspectors

Popular Toronto restaurant that just permanently closed being given away for free

Lil Jon just surprised staff at a Toronto pizza restaurant with a visit

Tim Hortons just added a new pastry to its menu and people aren't sure it's a winner

Ikea is doing an all you can eat Swedish holiday buffet in Toronto