pumpkin pie toronto

10 pumpkin pie in Toronto you'll want to eat all season long

Pumpkin pie in Toronto will make sure your fall celebrations feel complete. Nothing caps off a meal like a fragrant, creamy, spicy and crusty pumpkin pie, and the person who brings one of these over is always welcome back anytime.

Here are my picks for bakeries to buy pumpkin pie in Toronto.

Butter Baker

This narrow shop near Bay and Dundas does a seasonal pumpkin creme brulee pie, their fresh pie crust filled with torched pumpkin custard with caramel and spices.

Kensington Natural Bakery

This Annex bakery does vegan, spelt and gluten-free pumpkin pies at cheaper price points that anywhere else on this list.

Butternut Baking Co.

The gluten-free, dairy-free, keto and paleo pumpkin pie is organic and in an almond pastry crust, and yes, it does actually taste good. Finally, a dessert no one has an excuse not to eat at the end of a holiday dinner. 

Dough

Pumpkin pies made from scratch on site at this Danforth bakery should pretty much be available at all times here, but call ahead to pre-order if you want a guarantee.

Through Being Cool

This vegan bakery near Lansdowne and Bloor often does mini pumpkin pie tarts throughout the cooler months, but it’s best to call ahead to make sure they’re in stock. They can do full pies upon request.

Home Baking Co.

Completely simple, classic, unadorned pumpkin pie can be found at this Bloordale bakery.

Bunner’s 

Full-size pies should be ordered 48 hours in advance from this allergen-friendly shop with locations in the Junction and Kensington Market, but their pumpkin pie is free of gluten, eggs, soy and dairy, so it’s worth it to be able to share it with absolutely everybody.

Wanda’s Pie in the Sky

Full-flavoured spicy, creamy pumpkin pies with perfectly crimped, thick crusts and cute pastry decorations are made from scratch on site at this Kensington bakery.

The Rolling Pin

Not only do they make regular pumpkin pie at this Avenue and Lawrence bakery, they also do pumpkin cheesecake pie, chocolate pumpkin pie and pumpkin pie jacked up with salted caramel, whipped cream and candied pecans.

Tori’s Bakeshop

This place roasts their own organic pumpkin for their pies, so they’re only available by pre-order and for as long as they can get the pumpkins, usually until the end of November.

Lead photo by

Bunner's Bakeshop


Join the conversation Load comments

Latest in Eat & Drink

One of Toronto's favourite sushi burrito joints shut down by landlord

Toronto Restaurant Openings: Fantastic Baby, Yin Ji Chang Fen, Wild Chicory, Lovebird

The historic Wheat Sheaf Tavern in Toronto just announced its reopening date

Toronto pub shut down by landlord over rent

41 essential Mexican restaurants in Toronto

Foodora workers in Ontario just won the right to unionize

10 upcoming food events in Toronto where you're going to want to eat everything

Clinton's Tavern staff speak out after dramatic closure