ttc toronto

Why the TTC is playing classical music in the subway

I'm huddling inside Main Street station waiting for a Carlton streetcar when the sound of violins wafts up from the subway. Unless there's a full orchestra busking down there, it's a recording. And then I realize it's playing over the station's internal speakers. But why?

The answer is nefarious youths. In 1998, a community safety audit conducted after a fatal stabbing at Kennedy station suggested piping in Bach, Sibelius, Schumann, and others would repel gangs. New lights, CCTV, and additional security patrols were also ordered.

7-Eleven convenience stores and Vancouver's SkyTrain had used the same musical tactic with mixed results. The thinking, according to the Toronto Star when the Kennedy pilot project began, was that youths would rather move than listen to "highbrow" music. Some kids in B.C. just shouted over the classics.

The London Underground also uses orchestral music for the same reason in some of its stations.

According to TTC spokesman Brad Ross, the idea has since been expanded over the last 16 years to Warden, Victoria Park, Main Street, Bathurst, Dundas West, Runnymede, Finch, and Greenwood stations, stops close to high schools or colleges.

Classical music, in fact any music the listener finds repellant, suppresses dopamine production in the brain, "souring their mood and making them avoid the music," according to a Seattle Times story on the concept.

The music isn't coming from an internal DJ, says the TTC's Danny Nicholson. A company called Stingray360 in Montreal that specializes in "sensorial marketing solutions" provides the music feed and covers the licensing requirements for about $14,500 a year.

"A lot of dentists pay for it," he says. "If you're in a dentist's office you often hear recorded music that comes from the same sort of thing."

Editor's note: This post was originally published in 2014. The TTC has subsequently suspended the classical music program and spokesperson Danny Nicholson is no longer with the organization.

Lead photo by

Jason Cook


Join the conversation Load comments

Latest in City

Toronto is finally getting its first French-language university

This is what caused the TTC subway shutdown during this morning's commute

TTC shutdown forces Toronto man to quit his job

TTC subway service resumes but commuters are still in transit hell

TTC won't have enough streetcars and buses for Toronto's growing population

Toronto reporter harassed on camera while talking about sexual assault

Massive TTC subway shutdown after train derailment sparks commuter chaos

Ontario is getting rid of the transfer discount between GO and TTC vehicles