At Midnight: Deadgirl

Posted by Matt
September 7, 2008

Deadgirl
TIFF '08 is off to a rocky start with rescheduled screenings, finicky projectors, and at least one pissed off Toronto Sun writer. Midnight Madness, however, continues apace after last night's ear-throbbingly awesome screening of Detroit Metal City.

Programmer Colin Geddes has been calling Wednesday night's Martyrs "one of the most controversial titles in the history of Midnight Madness," but it was this evening's Deadgirl that had the most on-the-ground buzz for its queasy, I-don't-know-if-I-want-to-see-that subject matter. Hardly surprising: the film's potentially awesome, potentially awful, definitely troubling premise concerns two teenage boys who discover the body of a dead, naked girl... and proceed to "take advantage of the situation."

The good news is that it becomes almost immediately apparent that "Deadgirl" ain't dead, so strike those necrophilia concerns out of your mind. The bad news, though, is that with Deadgirl alive and unwilling, this movie revolves around rape - lots of it, and usually (!) played for gags.

It's a vile piece of work. As with anything, the point need not be what you're using but how you're using it, meaning that if all of this had been in service of a really well-developed (if bent) coming-of-age story for the lead characters, or if the thematic underscore had skewed towards a metaphor about the truly monstrous lusts of the average American teenage male, then maybe we'd have something here.

But we don't. Deadgirl plays like amateurs playing dressup, brash up-and-comers with a terroristic ability to think up a nasty scenario, but no artistic ability to take it anywhere, even down the well-trod road of straight shock-n'-shlock. In the end, the initial qualms were justified: this flick is just gross.

Coming up at midnight: Sunday night sees the premiere of Not Quite Hollywood, a documentary about Australia's oft-overlooked exploitation craze of the 1970s and 1980s. The down-under flavour continues on Monday night with Jon Hewitt's Acolytes, an Aussie fright flick that mirrors Deadgirl when some high school kids stumble upon a corpse. (This time, the corpse is both clothed, and Canadian.) Then, on Tuesday night, comes period western horror flick The Burrowers, which I am really looking forward to - the old west is a terrific, and largely underused, goldmine for scary stories in the night.

Danielle on September 7, 2008 at 10:08 AM

Great, just what the world needs, another senseless and meaningless rape scene (or two, or three) to add to the mix. Glad I skipped it.

Stephanie on September 7, 2008 at 2:04 PM

I have to disagree. Deadgirl was disturbing, but I thought the movie was very well-made and the subject matter was well-handled. The perpetrators of the assaults on the girl were not glorified or put up on a pedestal - it was pretty clear that the filmmakers viewed them as villains. You also made no mention of the one character who refuses to take part in the assaults and spends most of the movie trying to counteract all the sickness in the film.

Justin Decloux on September 7, 2008 at 2:28 PM

I agree with Stephanie. The film has a lurid subject matter, but still took me for an entertaining ride that cared about it's characters instead of relegating them too gross out punchlines. It wasn't a grand affair, but it was a professional one, that delivered on it's premise.

Kat on September 13, 2008 at 5:29 PM

I agree as well. I felt that the film handled its subject matter in a way that was thoughtfully done, but still managed to be an entertaining horror film and not a boring, moralizing tale of suburban teenage angst.

The best thing about Deadgirl is the fact that it manages to present clearly villainous characters and an ethically fairly black & white story and make it fun, in a way attempting to make the audience complicit in the horror taking place, because if we're enjoying it instead of finding it to be a "vile piece of work" then perhaps there's something wrong with us.

Much more clever and (dare I say) tasteful than Matt gives it credit for.

Add a Comment

Name: Email: URL:
Comment: