Sunday, May 27, 2012Mostly Cloudy 16°C
Restaurants

Sarah's Cafe and Bar

Rating: 1.9/5 (17 votes)

Posted by Staff / Reviewed on July 1, 2009

Sarah's Cafe and BarSarah's Cafe and Bar has one of the best street side patios on the east end of the Danforth. It's a popular spot for afternoon drinks; and on weekends it's a good local brunch option.

Discussion

9 Comments

sheila / January 4, 2011 at 11:32 pm
user-pic
Luke thanks for the review! Small correction: I serve Mussels in 12 different sauces (not 2). Come on back & try the other 10!
Sheila Nolan
Sarah's Cafe & Bar
Patrick / August 10, 2011 at 01:33 pm
user-pic
Good beer,
nice atmosphere,
Pleasant and friendly service,
BLOODY AWFUL FOOD! Sorry Sheila but it was AWFUL!!
....and the guy who calls himself the "HEAD CHEF" is a rude jerk!

I stopped by Sarah's last night to meet up with my wife and another couple on the patio. I am not a regular at Sarah's but we have been there a few times before, it is in our neighborhood. I ordered a Guinness and the Lobster Risotto. The Guinness was great, the Lobster Risotto was, to be honest, it was awful; soggy, bland and lobster-less. Maybe it was the lighting, but I did not see any lobster, I saw some peas. I was much hungrier than I expected to be after having finished my "main course" ($18 plate of wet rice) so I ordered the Seafood Linguine (another $18 entree). Service was speedy and our server was very accommodating, however to my complete astonishment the “Fresh Pasta” was hot wet and RAW! How do you mess that up? Fresh Pasta only takes 3 or 4 minutes to cook?? The shrimp and the little chopped bits of Calamari?, were overcooked and HARD?, like they had just come out of a microwave or spent too much time in a very hot pan, and the muscles were wet flavorless and very nearly raw. I was disappointed to say the least, and still hungry. The server observed my abandoning of the dish and immediately inquired, offering to wrap-up my entree, I thanked her for offering but explained I was finished with it, I politely explained how awful it was. She apologized and offered to bring me the menu, I decline a third try, explaining how disappointing the wet rice was to start followed by the lack luster raw pasta, with mixed overcooked/undercooked seafood. I reassured her that I had been there before and would return, I complimented her on the service, but was not interested in anything more from the kitchen "tonight". I insisted I would still pay for the food that I declined to take home. She apologized profusely and took the food away. To my complete dismay, the server returned, from the kitchen moments later to inform me the "head chef" ??? wanted me to understand I still had to pay for the food. Puzzled I confirmed with the server that I did in fact insisted that I would pay when she took it away, she agreed "yes I know" and added "but he wanted me to tell you", "YOU HAVE TO PAY!" I paid the $185 bill and tipped the server $30 but next time I treat @ The Pan.
My advice to those planning a visit to Sarah’s The beer and wine selection is good! The atmosphere is great, but the food ………. NOT SO MUCH!
My advice to the management at Sarah’s,… Send the jerk home and hire a real “chef”…. or stick to Pub-fair.
Bad food + Bad attitude = Bad business

Roctop replying to a comment from Patrick / August 10, 2011 at 02:00 pm
user-pic
Patrick, you were ROBBED, plain and simple. That "petite chef" should have his head boiled.
michael labencki / November 16, 2011 at 10:18 pm
user-pic
very good food, the mussels r excellent, and great service
Christine / January 7, 2012 at 09:52 am
user-pic
Delicious beers from around the world, amazingly delicious to taste wines, and everything else to make a great drink spot, but thats where it ends.

The kitchen staff is lackluster and depressed looking and can be heard regularily cursing and shouting. The food sucks. Thats it. If its not over cooked its under cooked. I think the cooks have the skills of Mcdonalds employees. The head chef, is always playing on her iphone. They have 2 dishwashers, one who is hard at work at all times, but speaks broken english, and the other, a lazy slob who they dress up as a bartender on weekends.

The servers, other than 'Alex' as he introduces himself as also have no idea what is going on. The aforementioned bartending dishwasher is slow, and cant offer anything about drinks other than "Its delicious, one of my favourites" and the rest of them are equally as uninformed about their products.

The bathrooms never get cleaned unless you beg for them to do something. I remember one instance where I told them there was no toilet paper in any bathroom and it took 30 minutes to rectify this problem.

The owners husband is also quite a piece of work. He should never be allowed in the restaurant. He often smells, often has stains on his shirts, and is even more often than that drunk and causing problems for his already problem stricken place of business. He tries to help the kitchen by standing in the way, and does not take criticism. One time I recall walking north along Monarch Park to witness him yelling, cursing and swearing at an employee out on the patio(which was full of course) openly discussing flaws with the place and how it was that one employees fault.

If they labelled themselves a "bar" and sold their great drinks on hand, and just dealt with generic pub fare they would do much better.
Sheila Nolan-Ozses / April 12, 2012 at 03:59 pm
user-pic
I am disheartened that a disappointing meal has compelled you to launch this bitter rant, especially since you have been a repeat customer.
We don't describe our cuisine as fine dining but we have consistently served generously portioned, hand-crafted meals using fresh ingredients since 1995.
My staff are highly skilled, hard-working professionals who are dedicated to their craft & contribute to the ongoing success of our ever-growing business. We are a close-knit group of caring human beings concerned about food quality & customer service.
I'm not a social cell phone user. My IPhone is invaluable as a kitchen timer, to calculate & convert recipe measurements & to contact clients, suppliers & staff.
Your character assisnation of my family & staff is inappropriate & unwarranted. In your attempt to malign my business reputation your vitriol speaks to the true nature of your own character.
Sheila Nolan-Ozses replying to a comment from Patrick / April 12, 2012 at 04:07 pm
user-pic
We have been a successful business for 16 years, a cornerstone of the community, offering quality hand-crafted meals, a global selection of beer & wine & friendly service. Although Patrick's concerns were responded to that evening & the next day, he continues to spam any website that will print his attention-seeking drivel.
mayor dodge replying to a comment from Sheila Nolan-Ozses / April 13, 2012 at 11:29 am
user-pic
Your ranting reply justifies only one thing: My friends and I shall NEVER set foot in your "successful business".
Mr.redd / April 14, 2012 at 02:23 am
user-pic
Criticism can always be read with a grain of salt however replies that seem rather personally defensive as oppossed to putting yourself in a patrons shoes will have a potential customer like myself looking for cafe on the danforth have second thoughts about stepping foot in yours. Just saying.

Add a Comment

Search

Find a restaurant

Or use the options below to assist you in locating a restaurant in Toronto.

Search Results

Please select criteria from the dropdown menus above to start your search.

Reviews

Recent Reviews

Refine the list using the categories below:


Loading...
Other Cities: VancouverMontreal