Tuesday, February 14, 2012Partly Cloudy -2°C
Restaurants

Homebake Pizza Company

Rating: 3.3/5 (26 votes)

Posted by Jerrold Litwinenko / Reviewed on July 24, 2009

20090719_homebakedpizza01.jpgHomebake Pizza Company in Roncesvalles is clearly onto something.

While making fresh pizza from scratch at home is fun, it takes time and effort that I often don't have. Options for good delivery pie in Toronto are also quite limited (I won't touch Pizza Pizza with a 10-foot cardboard pole, Mama's arrives as a soggy messpool, and I'm kind of tired of resorting to and spending money on even the best of the take-out joints like Pizzaaoilo and Magic Oven over and over again).

Although the shop has been around for about a year now, I'd yet to try the Homebake approach. A craving for some delicious pizza, and a desire to indulge in a bottle of South African Chenin Blanc (with my special babe, on the balcony, overlooking High Park, as the sun goes down) sealed the deal.

20090719_homebakedpizza_02menu.jpg

We stop by Homebake Pizza Company and take our time exploring the extensive list of popular combinations and the seemingly endless list of fresh ingredients including everything from organic slider sausage to baby arugula for the create-your-own types. Basic pizzas are $13.95 (11"x14") and $15.95 (12"x18") and ingredients range in price based on pizza size and topping type.

20090719_homebakedpizza_03roll.jpg

20090719_homebakedpizza_04sauce.jpg

20090719_homebakedpizza_05cheese.jpg

The Homebake pizza starts with freshly made, hand-rolled, unbleached organic or multigrain crust. The also do a spelt crust and gluten-free version as well. Sauce choices include an organic tomato sauce, organic garlic glaze, and savoury basil pesto sauce. Then come the cheeses, and again the selection is wide (from mozzarella, feta, chevre, asiago, gorgonzola, and more).

20090719_homebakedpizza_06casseth.jpg

We opt to go halvsies on a regular-sized (11" x 14") pizza (fear not, they don't charge you extra for half ingredients like some pizza joints do). I chose the "Saloomi" (spicy Italian salami with roasted and fresh mushrooms) and my sweetie went with a vegetarian option - the "Opa" (baby spinach, red onion, feta & chevre cheeses, and she easily substitutes the kalamata olives for asparagus for a little extra since it's from the premium ingredients list). The're glad to be accommodating of any special requests (they were even quick to make up a special basil-less sauce for the next guy in line, due to an allergy).

Within fives minutes, our pizza is wrapped and ready to go. We talk briefly about how we wish there was an effective and affordable alternative to self-clinging plastic wrap, but overall the packaging seems quite reasonable.

But before zipping home to preheat the oven, I decide to blow my cover and reveal myself as a blogTOer so I can pick the owner's brain a little and take some behind-the-counter photos.

20090719_homebakedpizza_07ready.jpg

"This [take and bake concept] has been going on in the States for 10 years," Cassidy explains. The brain behind the relatively novel-to-Toronto idea, she used to work in the film industry but gave it all up to pursue the unique pizza shop adventure. "We've always been a big cooking family," she adds.

A year into business, the shop has developed a loyal, mostly local clientele. "Some people come in and pick up three or four at a time," she says. "In the fridge they stay quite fresh for 24hours, and they freeze very well for about a month."

But there was no way we're freezing this fresh and ready-to-bake beauty. We're far too hungry, and the sun is laying low in the sky. Off to the balcony we go.

20090719_homebakedpizza_08preheat.jpg

We preheat to 425F and slide the pie (sitting atop of parchment paper) into the oven for about 14minutes before we deem the crust a perfect golden colour, and see that the cheese is bubbling happily. If the aromas permeating throughout the kitchen and all the way out onto the balcony are any indication, we're in for a treat.

20090719_homebakedpizza_09hot.jpg

20090719_homebakedpizza_09cool.jpg

So... how does it stack up against delivery or store-bought frozen varieties? After allowing our pizza to cool for a few minutes, we both sink our teeth in and at first bite are convinced that it's really no contest. Homebake is quite simply a stellar pizza, and well worth the extra cost.

We both agree that the crust is perfect - thin, light, crispy, and it has a pleasant little chew. We're also striking a chorus and both singing the praises of the tomato sauce - it's light, and strikes the sweet/tart/salty balance just right. Ingredients hold well too, ensuring all the toppings end up in the mouth and not on the shirt.

20090719_homebakedpizza_09c_eat.jpg

We gobble it up slice by slice. Then my smiling dinner companion tries to convince me that if she lived right in the area of the shop, she'd never order delivery pizza again. I try to convince her that it's worth the drive/ride/hike over there... but either way, we'll be going back for more.

20090719_homebakedpizza_09d_eat.jpg

We're excited to try the other crust types and topping combinations, and, when we're feeling motivated, may try the basic pizza and pile on our own toppings at home as well.

And there's something extra neat about the take-and-bake arrangement that is akin to icing on the cake; because we cook it at home, there's no tax added to the purchase!

Tues-Thurs 3-8pm
Fri 3-9pm
Sat 2-9pm
Sun 2-8pm

Discussion

18 Comments

Ratpick / July 24, 2009 at 09:30 am
user-pic
Cost?
badbhoy / July 24, 2009 at 09:42 am
user-pic
Assuming the cost is about the same as delivery why would I do this again?
Jerrold replying to a comment from badbhoy / July 24, 2009 at 09:52 am
user-pic
Because it's leagues fresher and tastier than delivery. That was our impression, on first bite. :)
Jerrold / July 24, 2009 at 09:53 am
user-pic
Prices really depend on what you order. Here's a full <a href="http://homebakepizza.ca/hbpc/HB_Pizza__our_menu.html";>menu/price list</a>. Cheers!
Amrita / July 24, 2009 at 10:33 am
user-pic
I go to this place all the time and love everything about it - great service, totally homemade taste, healthier than most other pizza joints. I order a small pizza that's about $20 incl. tax and I get 3 meals out of it. For me it's not about just the price - the taste and quality are why I keep going back.
MIKEB / July 24, 2009 at 11:27 am
user-pic
They have had this concept in Whistler for decades- Misty Mountain Pizza. They have a take-n-bake option!
badbhoy / July 24, 2009 at 11:30 am
user-pic
I'll admit the pizzas look tasty but I don't see the value in this. If I want convenience I can get get a ready-to-eat pizza from my local Terroni for less. If I care about ensuring the pizza is as fresh as possible I can pick up the ingredients and make my own for way less and not much more effort. Probably would taste better too. I suppose I'll give it a shot before passing judgement on the quality though.

BTW, they should have called the place Kramer's pizza.
andi / July 24, 2009 at 11:51 am
user-pic
Homebake is delicious - I've never been disappointed with their pizzas or salads. Yes, it's not the cheapest, but if you want take-out that's fresh, high-quality and did I mention delicious, it's the way to go.
Moneesha / July 24, 2009 at 12:22 pm
user-pic
you guys are deluded. pizza and fresh is an oxymoron.
Luciano Galasso / July 24, 2009 at 03:07 pm
user-pic
I think this sounds like a great idea. Places like Pizza Pizza and Pizza Nova are such large chains that they don't care about the quality of their pizza anymore, it's all about making money and getting it out before the 40 minutes are up (so then its not free). It's nice to have a fresh pizza you can make at home yourself, which even though places like pizziaolo are amazing, they don't have that option. The frozen stuff is just all high in salt content and preservatives. And as to badbhoy's comment about making it yourself...that was acknowledged at the beginning of the article "While making fresh pizza from scratch at home is fun, it takes time and effort that I often don't have"
-- Luciano Galasso
Lori / July 25, 2009 at 10:37 am
user-pic
There's a place in the U.S. that does this thing and that is all they do, I've seen it on Unwrapped. So this isn't a new concept this particular place came up with.
Lori / July 25, 2009 at 10:58 am
user-pic
Found it. http://www.papamurphys.com/
Jay replying to a comment from Lori / July 26, 2009 at 10:48 pm
user-pic
First, if you read the article the owner indicated that this idea has existed in the states for 10 years already.

Second, what does it matter if this idea is original or not original. Loblaw's has been doing take and bake pizza for years...it tastes like hell.

Home Bake is the freshest and tastiest option in Toronto for take and bake.

Now if they would only make it delivery and bake (they bring it to you and you cook it) that would be both original and ideal for convenience. Until then, this is a good option if you live close to their location. Don't see many people driving from Leslieville to pick up a pie in Roncesvalles to bake at home in Leslieville.
Lori replying to a comment from Jay / July 27, 2009 at 09:33 pm
user-pic
Sorry, I rushed through the article so clearly I missed the 10 yrs thing. Second it doesn't matter if the idea is original or not it just drives me nuts when some businesses lie and say they started an idea when clearly they did not, even though this business hasn't done that. I don't shop Loblaws frequently so I didn't know that.
Neene / May 7, 2010 at 05:42 pm
user-pic
We live in the area and absolutely LOVE eating this pizza! I absolutely will NOT buy pizza anywhere else... I'm totally spoiled now :) If you don't give a rats ass about taste and/or quality healthy ingredients, then you won't understand this place (Loblaws is NOT competition). Besides, it's hella easy grabbing one at any time of day on the way home, and leaving it in the fridge until hubby comes home or until I'm ready to cook it hot and fresh so it's ready to eat when I'm ready to eat. Not to mention, they now deliver - so this pizza place is nothing short of perfection. Cassidy (the owner) is awesome and they're a very welcome - very incredible - local business in the neighbourhood.
Louise / February 12, 2011 at 08:42 am
user-pic
This place is awesome..I do not know of a better "take out" pizza in Toronto..as for the person spewing on about convenience/make it yourself for cheaper..then go ahead and make your own??? or order the shit from Pizza Pizza
WeWill / June 1, 2011 at 09:31 pm
user-pic
Homebake has closed their doors...at least for now.

http://homebakepizza.ca/hbpc/The_HomeBake_Pizza_Company____Torontos_First_Take_and_Bake_Pizza_Shop.html

Dan replying to a comment from WeWill / June 11, 2011 at 08:36 pm
user-pic
WHY!!!!!!!????????

Add a Comment

Search

Find a restaurant

Or use the options below to assist you in locating a restaurant in Toronto.

Search Results

Please select criteria from the dropdown menus above to start your search.

Reviews

Recent Reviews

Refine the list using the categories below:


Loading...
Other Cities: VancouverMontreal