Autogrill

495 Eglinton Avenue West       Website
Phone: (416) 489-0961

Profile Map
Posted by Debbie Ohi
February 5, 2008

Rating: 2.8/5 (12 votes cast)

Autogrill front
Autogrill's been around since 1996, started by brothers Steve and Sandro Costa and their friend John Bastone. Their goal was to open an upscale restaurant that offered quick service and fresh ingredients and as far as I could tell last night, their efforts paid off.

I've been curious about the place but never tried it until Winterlicious.

Autogrill Winterlicious menu
The interior, like the Web site, is sleek and modern-looking. Check out the intriguing design of the fluorescent light fixtures in the photo below:

Autogrill interior
It also has a well-stocked bar; see their Web site for a list -- you can turn off the annoying percussion-bass loop by clicking on "SOUND OFF" in the lower left corner.

Autogrill bar
They brought us bread with a tapenade spread while we browsed the menu:

Autogrill Bread
I had already made my choices before arriving; for $25, you got a choice of an appetizer, main course and dessert. I started with the P.E.I. Mussels, served with green onions, spicy tomato sauce and crostini -- normally $11.95 when ordered off their regular menu.

Autogrill mussels
Yum. I sopped up the leftover sauce with some bread. For my main course, I ordered the Magic Mushroom Risotto. How could I not, with a name like that? To my surprise, I was served a salad instead. When I told the server that I had ordered the risotto, she just stared at me and then walked away.

Hm. At first I wasn't sure whether she had heard me, but several minutes later our original server brought my risotto and apologized for mishearing my original order.

The wait was worth it; my Magic Mushroom Risotto was fantastic -- flavourful and the perfect consistency. The dish was prepared with shiitake, oyster, and portobello mushrooms in a porcini mushroom stock, drizzled with extra virgin olive oil and truffle essence, and costs $17.95 when ordered off the regular menu.

Autogrill risotto
My dinner companions were also happy with their choices, which were the Absolut Penne with smoke bacon, green onions, fresh basil and parsley tossed in a vodka tomato cream sauce (normally $13.95):


Autogrill penne
and a lemon veal (hm...I couldn't find this on the regular menu):

Autogrill veal
We finished off our Winterlicious meal with the homemade tiramisu (served with Belgian dark chocolate shavings and berry coulis), which was excellent:


Autogrill tiramisu
The waitress who stared at me earlier when I told her about the wrong order was cheerful and friendly by the time we ordered dessert, so I figure she must have just been stressed earlier; the place was packed, likely with other Winterlicious diners.

Autogrill also offers home and office delivery through Restaurants On The Go or call 416-932-3999. Family-friendly, and good for large groups.

Autogrill interior

Gloria on February 5, 2008 3:31 PM

I'm intrigued. Maybe I'll swing by for Summerlicious if they're on the list.

Tim on February 5, 2008 4:18 PM

What's with the name? It makes me think the restaurant is car themed - part of the reason I never checked our their old spot at Adelaide and Charlotte.

Katie on February 5, 2008 4:31 PM

Looks delicious! I might have to try that one out.

p.s. - Tim... not sure if this is the reason why they chose the name for their particular restaurant, but likely, seeing as how it's an Italian place. Autogrill in Italian translates to roadside cafe in English.

Danielle on February 5, 2008 4:39 PM

Where can I go to comment on a really crap winterlicious experience I had last week? It's my first one in many winterlicious years and I feel like I need to share, in order to spare others.

Toshi on February 5, 2008 5:10 PM

http://image58.webshots.com/58/6/17/61/447861761QeidaU_ph.jpg

They have a whole franchise of them in Italy and many are built *on top* of the road. 'cause it's cheaper than one on each side, or they're just cool like that?

Gloria on February 5, 2008 6:52 PM

Danielle, right here! I'd like to hear it, as it's well-known Winterlicious is hit and miss and I want to know which restaurants are which.

jrabbit on February 5, 2008 8:00 PM

Autogrill is a neighborhood restaurant for me. Used to go thier quite often for quick and so-so food on a Sunday night. Would go right from the gym...as in still in my yoga gear...its that kind of place.

Over the years...it's gone from so-so to pretty awful. Service is spotty at best. They serve you and then you never see them again. Never get my order right. Quality of things like fish and seafood is not great.

So...glad you had a good experience there...but really..this place is a local joint where families bring their kids so they can run around and order noodles with butter sauce and cheese and where the parents can get a so-so meal.

MUCH better Italian restaurants in the area....save your $$

Yossi Kaplan on February 17, 2008 12:25 PM

Love Autogrill!

It's a perfect European Cafe, simple, tasty, friendly with neighborhood taste and feel to it. The wine list is decent and the food is good:

Try the carpaccio, risottos, saefood soups, and the rolls (spinello) which are oven baked pizza dough stuffed with whatever you ask for.

From my experience, the guys at Autogrill are happy to custom order meals and party menus, and they treat the customers well. I liiike.

Marco on February 23, 2008 11:03 PM

The restaurant is fantastic.
The owners: John, Steve and Sandro are 3 of the most likeable restauranteurs in the city. Highly recommend it.

Add a Comment

Name: Email: URL:
Comment: