Sunday, May 27, 2012Partly Cloudy 17°C
Music

A lot of not-so-hot Air at the Phoenix

Posted by Roger Cullman / March 25, 2010

Air at The Phoenix in TorontoAir's music is perhaps best left for movie soundtracks and make-out sessions.

When French band Air brought their trippy sound-and-light show to The Phoenix on Tuesday night, I felt like I should be watching a film to the music. But this wasn't a screening of Virgin Suicides. And there certainly wasn't much visually happening on stage... except for the increasingly trance-inducing iTunes-like screen saver patterns on the plain, white sheet behind the band.

Air at The Phoenix in TorontoClad in crisp, fitting white shirts, the keyboard whiz and guitarist pretty much stood in the same spot throughout their 70-minute set, while the drummer caught the glare of the projected lights.

Air at The Phoenix in TorontoThey opened with a trio of new songs off their latest album, Love 2, starting with the single Do the Joy.

It wasn't until after the third song that the lights -- and the band -- began to shine. It's pretty boring to listen to this music in the dark, and it's a pity that they didn't make good use of the giant disco ball in the center of The Phoenix concert theatre.

Without a central visual focus on stage, save for the aforementioned swirly light projection, I felt like this show wasn't much more than a live broadcast of a collection of Air's tunes, with only the occasional keyboard flourish here and there.

Air at The Phoenix in TorontoI overheard several French-speaking conversations in the audience. Later in the show, I heard a couple of English folks say, "You need heavy drugs to listen to this." While I caught the occasional whiff of something sweet in the crowd, it was pretty much a stand-in-one-place-and-stare-blankly throughout the night kind of a show.

Air at The Phoenix in TorontoAfter playing How Does It Make You Feel off their 10,000 Hz Legend album, we got a curt "Merci Beaucoup" and a "You can sing along to the next one," instruction. But it was, strangely enough, the wordless Alpha Beta Gaga tune from their Talkie Walkie CD, featuring a whistling melody. Oh, those funny Frenchmen.

Air at The Phoenix in TorontoAir ended their set with an overly bass-heavy version of Kelly Watch the Stars!, complete with a game of Pong projected on the screen behind them. By the time Air played perhaps their most familiar tune, Sexy Boy -- also off their Moon Safari album -- during their three-song encore, it was too little too late to get too excited.

Photos by Roger Cullman.

Discussion

15 Comments

Heather / March 25, 2010 at 09:27 am
user-pic
I thought the show sounded amazing, and I really enjoyed the visuals.
no complaints here.
Anitabot / March 25, 2010 at 09:53 am
user-pic
I also thought the show was great. I'm 5'1" and can never see at concerts so I have given up on even trying, but this means that I don't mind if the visuals aren't so great (thought I enjoyed them).
Tom / March 25, 2010 at 10:14 am
user-pic
Looks like someone left an italics tag open...
JT / March 25, 2010 at 10:33 am
user-pic
"You need heavy drugs to listen to this."
"it was pretty much a stand-in-one-place-and-stare-blankly throughout the night kind of a show"

I saw Massive Attack awhile back- and people said the same thing.Still a great show.
Roger Cullman replying to a comment from Tom / March 25, 2010 at 10:42 am
user-pic
Fixed, thanks.
Bartek / March 25, 2010 at 10:48 am
user-pic
I'm a fan of Air's music but the show didn't do much for me. I agree, they seemed very stale on stage and I think in the end, the translation of their music onto the stage is what didn't jive for me. I like listening to them relaxing away, but I don't think I'd see them live again. If the musician's don't even break a sweat during the show .. eh :)
dirk / March 25, 2010 at 11:15 am
user-pic
Why exactly would you have to break a sweat when playing relaxed, dreamy, spaced-out pop? Should they have jogged in place while playing a slow-jam?

This is the third time I've seen them and I seemed to have a much better experience than this reviewer. The crowd was really into it and very receptive to Air's performance (if you were eavesdropping on conversations than you were probably in the back with all the other people that should just go to a nightclub to talk instead of a live show). I think if you're going to see an Air show you should probably expect to see Air play and not some other band that do sweat-drenched guitar freak-outs and manic dance numbers. Why is that not obvious? Do you go to a metal show and say, "I wish they would've played more ballads, it was just too loud".
Jess / March 25, 2010 at 01:05 pm
user-pic
This show was amazing! Everyone I saw at the show was really into it.

(What was the reviewer expecting??)
Len / March 25, 2010 at 01:06 pm
user-pic
This was the first Toronto Air show I missed, going all the way back to '98, so my question is for other long-time Airheads: how was the drumming? No matter how quiet and static past records were, Air have always had fantastic live drumming ratcheting up the intensity of their shows, and I wonder if this one continued or abandoned that trend?
Jake / March 25, 2010 at 01:29 pm
user-pic
The show was brilliant, for the type of music AIR plays that was exactly what I would want to see. I don't need to see people bouncing all over the place to spacey awesome french piano tracks. They performed exactly how someone should perform to that type of music.

Everyone I saw as well was really into the show. We done AIR.
K-Borg replying to a comment from Len / March 25, 2010 at 01:37 pm
user-pic
I think the live drummer added a nice touch. His rhythms were more dynamic than those that appear on Air's albums. He certainly kept time and didn't venture too far from Air's approach but did so in a more interesting way. I found it interesting that the two lead musicians were dressed in white from head-to-toe while the drummer wore all black, making him stand out less. Looks like someone was afraid of being upstaged ;)
Weesy / March 25, 2010 at 02:44 pm
user-pic
I really enjoyed the show. They have a beautiful sound and that’s what they played…what was the reviewer expecting coming to an Air show? For me, their music is a personal experience. It was very fulfilling.
Tom / March 25, 2010 at 04:28 pm
user-pic
I felt the same as the reviewer in that it was sort of like listening to a soundtrack. I don't know if I would see them live again...
Len replying to a comment from K-Borg / March 25, 2010 at 06:05 pm
user-pic
Thanks, K-Borg!

Some of the early official videos grant a pretty good idea of what Air CAN be like in concert. There's a pack of YouTube stuff that does the job. This 2007 clip is as good an example as any (I hope it's cool to post a link here). http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jZfPXXQs_Qg


Frankly, I'm never surprised to see pos AND neg reviews of Air shows. I imagine they polarize the audience - casuals, or people fed up with the soporific later albums, will probably be bored to tears, as evidenced by some comments above... Committed fans dig the fact they play around with some of the arrangements, amid all the laconic six-minute trance pieces. To each their own.
Robb / March 25, 2010 at 11:27 pm
user-pic
Kudos to Roger for his honest review of Air's blasé performance. I too was bored, and tired of their outdated 70s futuristic set and staring at the 10ft projected iterations of their name as a backdrop all night.

During their show I began to question what I expected from them. I'm a fan of their music, and have been to many down-tempo ambient and electronic shows in the past... so I was surprised by their flat performance and lack of connection w/the crowd. The show felt like something was going to happened, but never did.

The band is best consumed with some killer headphones, and not on stage.

Add a Comment

Other Cities: VancouverMontreal