Sunday, May 27, 2012Partly Cloudy 17°C
Music

Smashing Pumpkins Two Night Takeover

Posted by Corina / November 5, 2008


The Smashing Pumpkins (which in this iteration includes Billy Corgan, Jimmy Chamberlin, and some kick ass backup) packed the seats at Massey Hall this week for a huge two night extravaganza celebrating TWENTY years (!!!) of the band's discography.

Having followed the Pumpkins for a long time (thanks to friends who are devout fans), I've seen the band's constantly 'evolving' sound split their audience. Similarly, this special two night affair had two very unique concert offerings.

Luckily, I got tickets to both nights and brought my camera.

smashing pumpkinsUnlike many others in attendance, I learned about the split shows early on and knew what to expect over the course of both nights. It helps to overhear promoters in line talking about a generalized set list: Monday hard, Tuesday soft - definitely an accurate measure.

Monday night was for the new fans, covering much of the Machina and Zeitgeist and heavier B-side albums. However it was mixed up, and after a wicked drum solo from Chamberlain to kick off the night, Corgan went into a cover of Everybody Come Clap by The Searchers, surprising many fans and baffling the younger ones.

There were a couple old gems thrown in for good measure (Siva and Tonight) as well as mini-covers of Pink Floyd, Jefferson Airplane and even Rush. The diverse set list allowed new comers Ginger Reyes (bassist) and Jeff Schroeder (guitarist) to tear into their instruments, rounding out an incredibly tight performance by Corgan and Chamberlain.

But despite a sprinkling of acoustics, the tone for the night was hard and heavy with lots of distorted feedback - that is until Billy's lengthly speech and rendition of Everyone is Beautiful set to kazoos. Classic Corgan self-indulgence, but I enjoyed it.


Going into night two, I had a good feeling the older fans (those who pine for Gish, Siamese Dream and Mellon Collie) would be rewarded. By far the softer of the two performances, I found the second evening much easier to sit back and take in. With very little pause between songs, the over two-hour performance was almost like listening to an album side (only on your feet, applauding, 5 meters away from Billy Corgan).

The experience of the second night was more fan-friendly, both due to the nostalgic set list and 'less experimental' stage jams. 1979, Zero and Cherub Rock were among the favourites in the crowd, but I really enjoyed the meandering guitar peels as Corgan and Schroeder laced bluesy riffs into classic Pumpkins tracks. There also wasn't a single person sitting through the high energy tribal drumming of Chamberlin - AWESOME.

As usual, Massey Hall had some trouble containing the sheer volume and size of the sound... acoustics always seem to sound perfect at this venue, but as soon as something heavy/electric drops the sound levels go a bit wonky. Clearly it didn't affect the band, or I'm sure Corgan would have raised the issue, and very few audience members seemed to mind. The intimacy of Massey Hall is worth a few tweaks to the sound board.

smashing pumpkinsFinally the evening ended on a somewhat (uncharacteristically) humble note, as Corgan expressed how proud he was of America to have voted in Barack Obama. After such a monumental show and historical political victory, there was little more to be said and members bowed off the stage one by one with very little fanfare, other than the cheers from me and my fellow audience.

For nay-sayers who may have abandoned The Smashing Pumpkins when Corgan took it solo (sort of), don't lose hope - this two night Massey Hall extravaganza not only proved that the Pumpkins can still bring a powerhouse stage performance, but also that there is a lot more creativity left to come from Billy Corgan... he should start planning a 30 year Pumpkins anniversary tour.

Discussion

17 Comments

sippy / November 5, 2008 at 11:22 am
user-pic
I miss James Iha.
Danielle / November 5, 2008 at 11:28 am
user-pic
I wasn't nearly as pumped as I thought I would be. I did really enjoy about half the show on Monday but I was also one of those people who didn't like the bore-rock turn Corgan took when the Pumpkins came back and was turned off during the softer sets.
Corina / November 5, 2008 at 11:34 am
user-pic
Nay sayer! lol, but I think Tuesday was a better show all around, more evenly balanced. Still 48 songs in two days (says Billy)... that's a lot of Pumpkins to take in.
Rich / November 5, 2008 at 12:01 pm
user-pic
I was at the tuesday night show and was very disappointed. It seemed very self indulgent. The encore was a perfect example. Everyone applauds for 5 minutes to get the band back on stage and they play a extended abstract drone session. Did Billy really think that that was what the audience was pounding the floor to hear before they called it a night?
Rich / November 5, 2008 at 12:05 pm
user-pic
Tuesday night first 35 minutes were awesome then 1.5 hours of experimental guitar jamming was not well received by the fans. I even saw people leave 45 minutes early. Billy was being too self indulgant having fun rather than bringing it for the 20 year old fans like moi!
K. / November 5, 2008 at 12:16 pm
user-pic
Agreed. Being a loyal fan, what a huge disappointment. Halfway through the show, the energy in the audience was drained and yes, I saw people leaving well in advance. And not to mention his disconnect with the fans mid-way through the show, saying "this isn't an open forum."
Corina / November 5, 2008 at 12:21 pm
user-pic
They played for almost a full 3 hours on Tuesday and I challenge you to find someone who walked out on a $70 ticket... I seriously doubt it, maybe went to stretch their legs, but there wasn't a single unhappy fan around me - one guy even commented that the guitar rock off was Zeppelin-esque (now I don't know about that measure but it was flippin' awesome)

If you came to a Smashing Pumpkins show expecting something OTHER than self-indulgence well.... I guess maybe you're 20 years old and haven't seen them perform before.

Like I said, Monday was the night for the young fans who think the Pumpkins are about "bringing it for the 20 year old fans" rather than being "self indulgent/having fun" ... maybe stick to bands like, oh... Lincoln Park? :)
sippy / November 5, 2008 at 12:25 pm
user-pic
$70?! Jesus. Sounds like you guys got scammed.
Corina / November 5, 2008 at 12:26 pm
user-pic
(p.s. was anyone at the same show as me????)

The entire house cheered when Billy shut down the open forum... no one wanted to listen to fans yelling 'Obama forever' or 'Billy for pres' - in fact, Corgan himself said it best when he stated he wasn't there to talk, he was there to play a rock concert. He'd talk through music.

Seems like people didn't come to hear the Pumpkins play a show at all... gah.
K. / November 5, 2008 at 12:40 pm
user-pic
I expected Corgan to make a little bit of a speech on the most historical night of the year. He's a Chicago boy, after all.

Also, I'm 30 - have been listening to the Pumpkins for the past 15 years, have been true to my band all the way through and I paid $90 for my ticket and it was only worth a third of that.

Sorry Corina, I didn't want to come down negatively but the prancing and the tambourine? My date and I were shaking our heads in embarrassment.
serotonin / November 5, 2008 at 12:46 pm
user-pic
I was a big Pumpkins fan up until about 2003, but when the new Pumpkins came out, it just didn't have the same appeal as when I was a teenager.

However, I lost interest in these shows as soon as I heard they were at Massey Hall. There are a lot of horrible seats in that venue and - as someone already pointed out - the ticket prices are almost always too high.

I keep hoping they'd renovate that venue, but when no ticket ever seems to be below $50 (and that's often the tickets where you can only see the top of someone's head from the side), I doubt they'd bother.
Corina / November 5, 2008 at 12:48 pm
user-pic
I totally understand K - I feel the same way - I'm just amazed that people don't associate that sort of... let's say experimental self-indulgence.. with Corgan. Ever since Darcy/James left, I've always viewed the Pumpkins as sort of... Billy Corgan on ice :)

I'm truly sorry you paid $90... I thought the $70 was steep. But Corgan did make a little speech at the end... was much more succinct than the kazoo serenade on Monday :)
Rich / November 5, 2008 at 01:06 pm
user-pic
Seems K and serotonin are the type of fans that will flock to see Billy and the be and be happy no matter what they bring. I'm 52 and have followed SP from the early drum machine days of of the late 80's and all the shows I have seen have been amazing until last night.
Ry-Tron / November 5, 2008 at 01:18 pm
user-pic
I thought the Virgin Fest show was pretty good, though the lack of an hour and a half experimental guitar riff was probably because festival shows tend to not have that kinda jizz in them. Sad to hear about the disappointment by show-goers in the comments, I know I'd've been annoyed if I was at either show by the sound of it. If he's got 20 years worth of solid-ROCK to draw from, you'd expect to hear the pick of the litter (no better way to open a show than with Everlasting Gaze, which they did on their "last tour" back in 2001-ish in Montreal).

Pumpkins now join the ranks of Tool's Maynard "I sing with my back to the audience because they disgust me" Keenan in terms of their self-indulgence. Note to self, only see them at a festival.
terry / November 5, 2008 at 02:55 pm
user-pic
i miss james too.

even d'arcy :(
Pumpkins / November 7, 2008 at 12:12 am
user-pic
As Rome Burn - great!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
fighters / April 17, 2009 at 11:21 am
user-pic
Ye!!!
As Rome Burn - greatest song!

Add a Comment

Other Cities: VancouverMontreal