Government Revokes Owen Pallett's Health Care

  • Posted by Tim
  • Filed in Music
  • February 25, 2008

Owen Pallett
Update: An open letter has been sent to the Minister of Health and Long-Term Care from NDP MPPs France Gelinas and Rosario Marchese on February 26, 2008. The letter is copied below.

It's official. Neither indie accolades nor a Polaris Prize can get you health coverage these days. Such is the saga of Toronto's Final Fantasy (Owen Pallett) who in a post on Stillepost yesterday explained how the Ontario Ministry of Health revoked his health card.

According to Owen, it all started when he went to a local office to renew his health card. After answering a bunch of questions about his touring schedule, family and life as a musician, the non-shower-singing He Poos Clouds government worker said he was no longer eligible for health care coverage.

Read the post on Stillepost for the play by play and latest updates.

Photo by Staciaann Photography

The open letter:

--------

Minister:

I am writing to urge your immediate intervention to help Owen Pallett, a Toronto-based musician who was recently denied OHIP coverage. Owen, also known as "Final Fantasy," is an award winning artist who deserves our support. Instead, he was unfairly treated by your Ministry. Please find attached a package outlining his concerns.

Owen is an Ontario resident who frequently travels to perform for audiences not only in Canada but worldwide. When Owen went to renew his expired OHIP card, his coverage was immediately revoked on the basis that he was outside the province for a period more than 153 days. This determination was made simply on the basis of a brief conversation.

Minister, such swift actions are both inappropriate, unnecessary and violate the Health Insurance Act. No Ontarian should see his or her OHIP coverage summarily revoked. Instead, all Ministry officials should work with the public to ensure that all applications are properly processed.

I understand that according to the Health Insurance Act, Regulation 552, Section 1.1 (3) 1, Owen would be considered exempt from the 153 day requirement on the basis of him being absent from Ontario for employment purposes. This exemption should have been more thoroughly explored before Owen's OHIP was abruptly revoked.

Minister, your assistance is required. The right to public health care is a value cherished by Ontarians. The public should never fear that their access to health care can so easily be revoked. Owen deserves to have his OHIP coverage immediately reinstated.

I look forward to hearing from your office.

Sincerely,

France Gelinas
Rosario Marchese
cc: Owen Pallett

Reader Reviews and Comments

Submit a Review or Comment

Owen needs to talk to his MP and maybe also Minister of Health George Smitherman who is opening a constituency office on Parliament. He has loads of agency and can create the kind of embarrassment that will have the Premier saying "sometimes the civil service get out of hand."

Posted by: Yours to Discover at February 25, 2008 7:47 PM

Get rid of those pen pushers paper shufflers sit warmers brain less creatures being fed by our hard earned money.

Posted by: Jamal Uddin at February 25, 2008 8:31 PM

Ahh bureaucracy. It never fails to blow my mind. And this is coming from a full fledged bureaucrat. He needs to write Smitherman and his local MPP on this. Forget Parliament, they'll just push this over to the local/Ontario level.

Posted by: binlazer at February 26, 2008 8:52 AM

This is why, when I lived abroad for two years, I didn't tell the Ontario Ministry of Health. I wanted to be able to see my doctor, hassle-free, when I made brief trips back home.

Posted by: J at February 26, 2008 8:53 AM

I don?t think this is the whole story. His health coverage wasn?t revoked, he?s still going to get a health card in the mail with an effective day of 3 months from the date he presented himself to the OHIP office. Those are the rules and it?s got nothing to do with ?how Canadian? you are. If you?re out of the country for more than 6 months you become a non resident and you?re health coverage takes 3 months to kick back in.
Would you all be happy if someone from Pakistan (for example) though a Canadian citizen, spent most of the year or several years in Pakistan earning money abroad and came back to Canada when he/she developed a serious illness. Would you want OHIP to kick in right away? But people like this aren?t so foolish as our musician friend who spends time away without a valid health card. They renew before they leave so as to have the five years of grace before their card expires.

Posted by: Contrarian at February 26, 2008 10:36 AM

I sincerely hope that someone can take this matter forward to George Smitherman and get it resolved as quickly as possible.

Such treatment at a counter put the lie to the phrase "civil servant". More than an apology is in order
for this person and it'll be interesting to learn how it is resolved.

Posted by: David E [TypeKey Profile Page] at February 26, 2008 11:46 AM

Contrarian, you don't call that temporarily revoked?

Posted by: Chris Orbz at February 26, 2008 12:53 PM

Not sure what the Ontario backstory is, but in Quebec these rules were put in place for snowbirds who lived full-time in Florida and Mexico but flew back for healthcare.

Posted by: Disparishun at February 26, 2008 1:06 PM

Alternate Story:

Government passes law, regulations drafted, employee follows regulation, indie rocker denied coverage on unambiguous breach of regulation, tiny message board outraged.

This is such a non-story.

Posted by: headliner at February 26, 2008 1:32 PM

(Can someone help post this in Stillepost? I don't really want to register for just one post)

In short, the OHIP officer erred. Just go to another OHIP office to get it straighten out if he doesn't want to fight at the same office. He should ask for the General Manager if he still encounter problems. The legislation and statue are very clear on Owen's right to receive a health card as long as his principal home is in Ontario. The Health Insurance Act enables GENERAL, R.R.O. 1990, Reg. 552, s1-1.1 (http://www.canlii.org/on/laws/regu/1990r.552/20080115/whole.html) which is as follows:

(3) A person referred to in clause (2) (a) [permanent/principal home in Ontario] is exempt from the requirement of subclause (2) (a) (ii) [nb. the 153 days clause]if the person provides the General Manager with evidence that he or she meets one of the following criteria:

1. The person?s employment requires the person to travel frequently outside of Ontario.

(...)

Posted by: Afterdark at February 26, 2008 1:38 PM

Wow, it must be tough being a rock star these days.

Posted by: Courtney at February 27, 2008 7:48 AM

It's also hard out there for a pimp.

Posted by: binlazer at February 27, 2008 8:28 AM

Hello Owen,
My name is Lu Zhou, producer for CBC's morning show "Metro Morning". I learned about your story and wonder if you could give me a call as soon as you can to chat about your situation and potencially line up an interview.
you can reach me at 416-205-5828. Thanks ! lu

Posted by: Lu Zhou at February 27, 2008 11:53 AM

Hello, my name is Lu Zhou, producer for CBC radio, and I'm interested in talking to Owen about his experience...I just posted a comment looking for him and left my contact number. if anyone reads this and knows how to get hold of him, could you pass the message along? or pass me his contact? thanks ! Lu

Posted by: Lu Zhou at February 27, 2008 11:56 AM

Lu, be a good journalist and check the link to Owen's original post on Stillepost. In one of his followup posts in the thread he provides an email address.

Posted by: jason at February 27, 2008 5:04 PM

Post a comment

Remember Me?

Email This Entry

Email 'Government Revokes Owen Pallett's Health Care' to: Message (optional):
Your email address:

Please type the verification code displayed in the image:

By forwarding this entry to a friend, we do not opt you or your friend into
receiving any additional mailings from blogTO. We hate spam too.
Disclaimer: Comments and blog entries represent the viewpoints of the individual and no one else.