Monday, May 20, 2013Cloudy 17°C
MB Toronto

Morning Brew: Something stinks about Toronto's trash plans, archaeologists uncover old engine house at condo site, Justin Trudeau hits the GTA for the Liberals, TFC is getting a new facility, and get ready for rain

Posted by Brianne Hogan / April 19, 2011

Toronto SkylineSomething smells a little fishy about Mayor Rob Ford's move to privatize garbage collection in Toronto. The good news: the city's Solid Waste staff says Toronto can save up to $8-million a year by contracting out the trash pick-up west of Yonge Street, which would help with the forthcoming deficit. But when a contract has a term of more than five years, like the seven-year contract Solid Waste is seeking, "the Purchasing By-law states that council is required to make the award regardless of the overall contract value." This is where it gets dicey. The report from the Solid Waste staff recommends that staff do away with this rule and award the contract, which is worth over $200-million, through a "bid committee," without letting council vote on the deal. The report reasons the city will save money bypassing democracy because a council vote would delay a private pick-up by six months. That makes sense. Garbage totally outweighs democracy.

Dig and you shall find...remains of an old engine house from Toronto's 19th-century boom. Archaeologists uncovered brick and masonry foundation walls built by the Grand Trunk Railway in the 1850s at the base of the new Library District condo site, adjacent to the Bathurst Street bridge south of Front Street. According to railway historian Derek Boles, railways transformed Toronto from a warehousing centre to a manufacturing focal point. He says the unearthed remnants should be saved, but their fate is unknown.

I guess the Liberals see Justin Trudeau as their secret weapon. Why else drop him into seven GTA ridings in eight hours, including Liberal candidate Ruby Dhalla's embattled Brampton-Springdale riding. "It was important to come and show my support to Ruby," Trudeau said during a speech at Dhalla's campaign headquarters. "She is an important and valued member of our team." His brief visit is part of the Liberals' strategy to hold onto the 905 regions. And you know the man's dedicated to his party when he drove himself from Montreal in his ten-year old Toyota Camry.

Even though attendance has been low, that isn't stopping Toronto FC from building a world-class training facility worth $17-million at Downsview Park. The 5.7-hectare site, which will serve as a training base for the MLS team and its academy squads, will include three grass fields, one artificial turf field under a bubble and a 3,715-square-metre fieldhouse, which will house locker-rooms and offices. There will also be an area just for goalie training. Construction is slated to started next month. The fields are projected to be ready in April 2012.

IN BRIEF:

Photo by simon.carr in the blogTO Flickr pool.

Discussion

35 Comments

AM / April 19, 2011 at 08:44 am
user-pic
I think it was several TTC shelters destroyed, not TTC stations ;)
The new guy / April 19, 2011 at 09:13 am
user-pic
Let's all pretend to be surprised by rob fords utter lack of respect for democracy
Jane N. Finch replying to a comment from The new guy / April 19, 2011 at 11:42 am
user-pic
Ya mean the democracy where I had to drive to a park, line up and wait my turn to get rid of my garbage 2 summers ago due to a strike by CUPE?
If that is your democracy, you can have it.
Go Rob Go!
rob / April 19, 2011 at 11:49 am
user-pic
The Liberals are disgusting, and Justin Trudeau is as spineless as his father.
Ridiculous / April 19, 2011 at 11:50 am
user-pic
Yes we should flush three million every time we make a decision to prove we live in a democracy. I can't see any problem with that at all / sarcasm
Torontonian / April 19, 2011 at 12:00 pm
user-pic
This whole bid process for garbage collection sounds very much like Harris/Eves tactics. Take legislative decisions and make them administrative decisions. That way the
debates process is eliminated and the councillors are
stymied and rendered ineffectual.

After the Harris Omnibus bill, many further decisions were
made by a cabinet "walk around"* and signed by several members of cabinet and the deed was done--completely
bypassing the floor of the House.

*Walk around. A cabinet minister would propose something in his/her portfolio and walk it around the cabinet table
and get several signatures thus making it a fait accompli.
jason / April 19, 2011 at 12:02 pm
user-pic
It is unfortunate that the city has decided to pick on the garbage men. It is also unfortunate that the union brass at CUPE are most responsible for these pending job losses in the sanitation department. Last year's strike was a CUPE strike, not a garbage strike. Five percent of the striking workers were actually garbage men, but the strike was affectionately known as a "garbage strike". The city of Toronto could cut their staff by 25% across the board and nobody would notice a reduction in service. The garbage men actually provide a tangible service that is noticeable. My father worked as a garbage man for the City of North York and then Toronto for 23 years - before he died of cancer - he earned $53k in his final year, after 23 years on the job. Nobody is getting rich working as a garbage man for the city. There are many bureaucrats milking the city dry earning 6 figures, some of them retired and double dipping, for some reason these people are never mentioned and yet the lowly garbage man is made to feel the brunt of the tax payer's anger.

Having said all this the union is getting exactly what they deserved. They cut their nose off to spite their face last summer. Why can't any of these union bosses ever look past the current contract negotiation? Why can't they look at the big picture?
nn replying to a comment from jason / April 19, 2011 at 12:08 pm
user-pic
Jason, no disrespect to your father but $53K for rock bottom unskilled labour is mind blowing! if he drove a delivery truck for a living which requires more skill than a garbage man he'd make about 60% of that and there's hundreds of thousands of people that do that would think they'd hit paydirt if they made 50K
mrs / April 19, 2011 at 12:19 pm
user-pic
- Trudeau driving here is his job is part of the PR campaign
- TFC sales are low because the ticket prices went up
Jimmysmack replying to a comment from Ridiculous / April 19, 2011 at 12:30 pm
user-pic
Hey thanks for clarifying that your comment was sarcasm we never would have gotten that impression otherwise "/ sarcasm". But you should have also pointed out that it was a thinly veiled fascist rant.

Penny pinching fascists are the worst kind. Let's save some dollahs instead of having freedom!
gimme break / April 19, 2011 at 12:33 pm
user-pic
53 grand to pick up garbage is a fair wage.
It's not amazing, but it's for picking up garbage.
And some garbagemen can't seem to even do that with competence.

That other people working for the city earn more is entirely irrelevant.
Alvin replying to a comment from nn / April 19, 2011 at 12:42 pm
user-pic
After 23 years of service. It's not entirely unskilled either. and what's the matter with a job that's better than driving a delivery truck? Everyone should make a decent wage, but we don't, why pick on the few jobs that afford people the ability to live? Should only people who have spent thousands on education expect to live worthwhile lives? His father worked as a garbage man for 23 years, I wonder what he did for the other years he was working, probably busted his butt in the private sector, worked for bad employers, worked for little pay. The unions have created jobs that allow the average person to live a life worth living, to eat, go out with friends etc. Do you feel that since some people can't get those jobs that no one should have them? That the full breadth of unskilled labour out there be the worst work you could possibly do? everyone shoudl work for bad bosses, pennies and expect little respect at work, if any?

The unions aren't the problem, the system is the problem, MORE jobs should be as "good" as union jobs. Union workers having relatively good jobs positively affects the private sector, it to an extent forces employers to offer competitive wages, benefits etc if they want to keep their employees, and have dedicated workers. Unions made your benefits, minimum wage etc etc. If you want a union job, apply for one somewhere, they offer peace of mind, you won't get rich and you'll still ahve to work hard, btu knowing that you will be able to eat, that you can pay your bills, is a huge load off. The fact that you're unskileld shouldn't mean you're treated as a secodn class citizen, it means there should be opportunity out there for you to better yourself, learn a skill and get a better job, without city services those opportunities aren't there, without unions there wouldn't be a lot of good jobs to strive for.
Jane N. Finch replying to a comment from Torontonian / April 19, 2011 at 12:54 pm
user-pic
Your proof of such activity? Or is your comment just a lazy leftie slur?
agentsmith replying to a comment from Alvin / April 19, 2011 at 12:58 pm
user-pic
"Everyone should make a decent wage..."

$53K per year IS a decent wage, especially for unskilled labour. And yes, driving a garbage truck is rightly classified as unskilled labour, since "skilled labour" = tradesman.
Bob But Not Doug / April 19, 2011 at 01:00 pm
user-pic
First of all, garbage work is not unskilled and not everyone can do it because it requires a measure of strength and stamina. Second, sanitation work is absolutely essential to the city's well-being, more so than many other jobs we deem more "respectable"...and how much would it have to pay before you would take it?
meh / April 19, 2011 at 01:03 pm
user-pic
14 ttc ticket takers earn over 100 grand. Ticket. Takers.

When I was earning a massive 27,000$ pushing paper at a real estate company I certainly didn't think the requirements of my job were worth 100 grand.
agentsmith replying to a comment from The new guy / April 19, 2011 at 01:05 pm
user-pic
Hang on, Solid Waste Management is suggesting this, not Rob Ford himself.
Mike W replying to a comment from agentsmith / April 19, 2011 at 01:21 pm
user-pic
You should know by now these little details never stopped a good anti-Ford diatribe.
agentsmith replying to a comment from Mike W / April 19, 2011 at 01:29 pm
user-pic
That being said, it'll be interesting to see how Ford handles this now. As the Star article pointed out, he criticized sole-source contracts in the past, so he better err on the side of transparency here.
Mike W replying to a comment from agentsmith / April 19, 2011 at 01:40 pm
user-pic
Agreed, I would hope he tries to prove himself worthy for a 2nd term.
The new guy replying to a comment from agentsmith / April 19, 2011 at 01:41 pm
user-pic
don't count on it. also, if he doesn't? will you still support him whole-heartedly?
George Smitherman replying to a comment from The new guy / April 19, 2011 at 02:10 pm
user-pic
I know some good consultants who we could hire to figure this pickle out.
Jimmysmack / April 19, 2011 at 02:27 pm
user-pic
I also love the duality here;

- Uggh garbage men get paid too much!
- Uggh my garbage wasn't picked up for a couple of weeks; apocalypse!

Make up, your effen, minds, neocons. Are garbage men valuable or are they not valuable? And also food for thought; my garbage is picked up LIKE CLOCKWORK. I highly doubt Jimmybob's Private Garbage Service will be as reliable.

This magical world where the private sector does everything so much more efficiently is mostly a wankfantasy that Randroids adhere to, much like Star Wars fans and The Force.
Alvin replying to a comment from agentsmith / April 19, 2011 at 02:29 pm
user-pic
uhh, yeah, very good, that's what I said, thanks.
Bidder replying to a comment from Jimmysmack / April 19, 2011 at 02:47 pm
user-pic
"I highly doubt Jimmybob's Private Garbage Service will be as reliable."

What make you say that, they got into a bid war to pick up your garbage. To keep the bid they will have to do a good job. These are private companies, not the city. Either do the job or get fired, like most of us have to do from day to day.
agentsmith replying to a comment from The new guy / April 19, 2011 at 03:09 pm
user-pic
I never said I support him in the first place.
mike / April 19, 2011 at 03:29 pm
user-pic
My garbage is picked up every week effeciently,at the same time of day, and without problem. I have no problem supporting the city garbage guys making a avg wage. Id rather my tax dollar go to the front line worker instead of going to ceos and profits for the private company/
nn replying to a comment from Alvin / April 19, 2011 at 03:33 pm
user-pic
the definition of an unskilled job is that it requires no skill, ie you could grab someone walking by on the street and train them in 5 minutes.. if someone does this for 23 years it doesn't make it any more skilled.

Why should social equality be paid for on the backs of municipal taxpayers? if a unionized private sector company can pick up garbage more cheaply and more efficiently than the public sector and not hijack us with thuggish behaviour whenever they decide go on strike then how can anyone be against this? practically every municipality in the 905 does it this way now and I bet there's no difference in quality compared to Toronto
The new guy replying to a comment from nn / April 19, 2011 at 03:38 pm
user-pic
I bet there's no difference in quality compared to Toronto.

Says the man who has clearly never been there. Parking lots miles and miles away from water filled with seagulls. thats what I think of when i think of etobicoke or scarborough
nn replying to a comment from The new guy / April 19, 2011 at 03:42 pm
user-pic
i meant quality of garbage pickup, you halfwit
The new guy / April 19, 2011 at 04:05 pm
user-pic
I don't see Seagulls in downtown streets living off of the garbage. If you go to Scarborough and Etobicoke garbage is everywhere and so are seagulls, you numbskull
Mike W replying to a comment from mike / April 19, 2011 at 04:13 pm
user-pic
Funny, because in recent history my city garbage guys not only stopped picking up my garbage, they made it as hard as they could for me to drop off my own garbage. All because they wanted a better "average wage".

I guess you weren't around for that part.
robert replying to a comment from rob / April 19, 2011 at 04:23 pm
user-pic
another right wing slur with no context, no reasoning, and no facts.
A meaningless school yard bully tactic.
JimmySmack replying to a comment from Bidder / April 19, 2011 at 07:28 pm
user-pic
Oh ok so I have to tolerate bad service provider after bad service provider until I find the one true golden service provider? Great! That sounds amazing. That should only take 25 or so YEARS, and then the possible variance of that service provider changing direction because of management decisions.

Talk about fixing something that simply 'aint broke but then totally screwing it up.
Ryan L. / April 19, 2011 at 08:20 pm
user-pic
Just because you work a shitty job for awful pay doesn't mean everyone else should be forced to work for minimum wage as well.

When you grow up and get a real job and have real responsibilities you'll realize that a $53k salary after 20+ years is actually really quite bad. Bad enough that you likely wouldn't be able to survive in Toronto as a homeowner with that as your sole income.

And keep in mind: If sanitation workers got paid minimum (or some other low) wage then you're going to end up with a lot of staffing issues. Who in their right mind would chose that job with its awful hours, awful and potentially hazardous working conditions and back breaking physical activity for the same as what they could be getting paid at a Walmart or McDonalds?

Give me a break, people. Expecting people to work awful jobs for low pay is one of the big reasons why Communism has never worked.

Add a Comment

Other Cities: Montreal